I will make you a great nation. I will bless you, and I will make
your name great, and you shall be a blessing.
Parshas Lech Lecha
You Will Be the Seal 1
Be’er Mayim Chaim: Rashi, citing the gemara,2 sees this pasuk
describing the first berachah in Shemonah Esrei. The first three phrases
refer to the Avos, beginning with Avraham. They are invoked, serially, at
the beginning of that berachah. The final words brings us back to Avraham
alone. To him goes the distinction of sole billing in the conclusion of the
How are we to understand that a pasuk in the Torah refers to the content of
a berachah in Shemonah Esrei, which is a rabbinic creation?
If we consider the common denominator in the respective missions of the
three Avos, we will resolve our problem.
Our pasuk turns on the word “great.” Ultimately, greatness is about the
chesed that Hashem works. There is no more effective way of winning the
praise of all Creation than showcasing Hashem’s chesed. Through it, His Name
Avrohom’s life’s work was teaching everyone with whom he interacted that all
the good they observed flowed directly from G-d. All the blessings that
people hope for are willed and directed by Hashem.
A huge obstacle stood in the way of people’s acceptance of Hashem as the
source of all good. They saw too much pain and suffering around them. It was
difficult to square this perception with the notion of G-d’s goodness.
The true believer understands that there are no exceptions to Hashem’s
goodness. They all reflect His chesed. Even events that we run from rather
than embrace are reflections of His chesed, although the graciousness of
those events remains obscure to us. What we regard as tragic is sourced in
His chesed. Chazal in various places provide us with a glimmer of the sense
we can make in watching Hashem’s Providence, and seeing it all as chesed. We
are taught that sometimes Hashem multiplies the reward of the righteous by
subjecting them to tragedy that is not punishment for their sins. Or that
sometimes the righteous are made to suffer in order to actualize their
potential for love of Hashem. By accepting their suffering as the Will of a
G-d of good and love, they translate their ahavas Hashem into concrete
reality. In yet other cases, even the tzadik occasionally sins. Even though
the vast majority of his actions are meritorious, a minority element must
still be addressed for Divine justice to work. The tzadik considers it a
chesed to him to deal with his shortcomings in this world, rather than the
next. Finally, for the genuine evildoer, meeting up with Divinely
orchestrated pain and tragedy represents a last opportunity to be jarred
The common thread uniting all these approaches is that even phenomena that
we do not like are outgrowths of Hashem’s chesed, even if we cannot always
detect why. Through these approaches, however, we come to understand that
all pain and suffering serve a positive purpose. Moreover, when a person
accepts his pain as beneficial to him, and embraces it with happiness as he
would a more obvious favor, he succeeds in changing the attribute of din to
that of rachamim. By recognizing what is patently true – that all din is
sourced in chesed – he “sweetens” din, by modifying it at the source. By
doing this, in turn, he draws down vast quantities of berachah from the
Divine attribute of chesed.
Correctly assigning din to the penumbra of chesed (rather than seeing it as
a midah standing opposite to chesed, as many erroneously think) was the
avodah of Yitzchok. His task was to assert and to teach that some of the
outgrowths of din, like awe, reverence, self-judgment and limitation, all
belong at their true root to chesed. Thus, “He sowed in that land, and in
that year found one hundred measures, and Hashem blessed him.”3
As the midrash teaches,4 it was hard land in a difficult year of
famine. Nonetheless, by accepting the difficulties with joy as certainly
designed for Man’s benefit, Yitzchok turned the din of the famine into the
bounty of chesed. In fact, by uniting din and chesed, he established harmony
among all ten sefiros – each of which contains aspects of all ten sefiros
within it. Hence, Yitzchok’s take-home was the product of ten and ten, or
the hundred measures that he reaped in a year of famine.
Thus, Avrohom and Yitzchok, coming as it were from opposite directions, both
drew attention to the greatness of Hashem’s chesed – and therefore to His
essential greatness. We can discern a third way to showcase Hashem’s
grandeur – when His power is evident as working through some exemplary human
being. When a tzadik is treated by people who recognize his piety with
boundless respect, they recognize as well that what makes him special is his
connection to HKBH. The favor shown him by people is really a reflection of
the favor he has achieved in the eyes of Hashem. His stature and position
thus reflect on Hashem who stands behind him.
This describes the work of Yaakov. Yaakov had difficult confrontations with
Eliphaz, with Esav, with Lavan. In all cases, the other party was moved to
release him unharmed. In the clutch, Yaakov lived a charmed existence, one
that testified to his closeness with Hashem.
When we mention the Avos in the first berachah of Shemonah Esrei, we really
mean these three methods of demonstrating and proving Hashem’s greatness.
They are, however, all interconnected. They should be seen as branches
leading out from a trunk through which they develop.
That trunk is Avrohom. The other methods come forth from him, because his
method really contained them all. In fact, he demonstrated all three in his
own life. Besides his commitment to chesed, he had to deal with the
suffering of a famine when he arrived in the Land, and accepted it with joy,
and without complaint. He rose in prominence and stature in the eyes of all
he met, so that people could point to him as one blessed by Hashem working
Still, Avrohom specialized in the avodah of chesed. The other two methods
lived within him mostly as potential. He actualized only one of them. We
recall this in our Shemonah Esrei when we first mention the avodah of each
of the Avos, separately. By the end of the berachah, however, we come back
to Avrohom. His chesed contains the other two.
Avrohom remains the seal.
1. Based on Be’er Mayim Chaim, Bereishis 12:2
2. Pesachim 117B
3. Bereishis 26:12
4. Bereishis Rabbah 64:6
SHEMINI AND THE OMER:
Searing Fire or Reaching Higher
Rabbi Naftali Reich - 5773
Rabbi Naftali Reich - 5767
"Where's The Beef?"
Rabbi Yaakov Menken - 5763
Reality Of Consequence
Rabbi Yochanan Zweig - 5774
Playing With Fire
Rabbi Mordechai Kamenetzky - 5756
The Eloquence of Silence
Rabbi Naftali Reich - 5768
Rabbi Mordechai Kamenetzky - 5761
The End Does NOT Justify the Means
Rabbi Yisroel Ciner - 5757
Why would G-d create the world?
Rabbi Dovid Green - 5758
Oceans of Holy Energy
Rabbi Label Lam - 5765
How To Win an Argument
Rabbi Eliyahu Hoffmann - 5762
Rabbi Pinchas Avruch - 5765
Rabbi Naftali Reich - 5771
Rabbi Raymond Beyda - 5764
We are Toddlers Before Hashem
Shlomo Katz - 5760