Third Perek, First Mishna
In what cases do we state all the rules in
the last two perokim of birds that become mingled? Where the
Kohain asked for instruction before bringing any korbonos.
However, if the Kohain did not consult, but rather brought all
the birds as korbonos, which of the korbonos would be kosher?
When each woman gave an equal number of pairs, for instance this
woman gave the Kohain one kain, and the other woman one kain,
this woman gave two kinim, and the other two kinim, or this woman
gave three kinim and the other three kinim, and the women's birds
became mingled, if he brought them all as Olos at the upper part
of the Mizbayach half are kosher and half are possul. If the
Kohain brought all of them as Chato'os at the lower part of the
Mizbayach half are kosher and half are possul.
Example of the Case of the Mishna
One or more pairs of birds (kinim stumos) belonging to Rochel
mingled with an equal number of Leah's birds. For example,
Rochel and Leah each have three kinim stumos -- a total of twelve
birds. The Kohain mistakenly thought that the birds were all
Chato'os or all Olos and offered them accordingly.
If all the birds were brought as Chato'os each woman
fulfilled her obligation to bring Chato'os. That is, half of
each woman's birds were brought properly. None of the Olos were
brought. If all were brought as Olos the result is analogous.
If the original birds were all brought as Chato'os, each
woman brings three additional birds as Olos. If the original
birds were all brought as Olos, then the additional birds are
brought as Chato'os.
If the Kohain brought half of them at the upper part as Olos and
half at the lower part as Chato'os, of those brought as Olos at
the upper part, half are kosher and half are possul. And of
those brought as Chato'os at the lower part, half are kosher and
half are possul.
Example of the Case of the Mishna
Rochel's kinim stumos became mixed with an equal number of Leah's
kinim stumos as in the previous case. For example, Rochel and
Leah each had three kinim stumos. The Kohain mistakenly brought
half as Chato'os and half as Olos. (The correct disposition is
given in the first Perek, third Mishna.)
Result in the Worst Case
We do not know whose birds were
brought as Chato'os and whose as Olos. In the worst case, all
six Chato'os came from Rochel's group and all six Olos from
Leah's. If this happened, three of Rochel's birds count as
Chato'os, and three of Leah's birds count as Olos. The other six
birds were not valid korbonos. [Diagram 34]
It is possible that fewer than six birds were invalid.
For example, of the six Chato'os the Kohain brought, two might
have belonged to Rochel and four to Leah. The Olos would then
have been four of Rochel's birds and two of Leah's. Rochel has
satisfied her obligation to bring all three of her Chato'os and
two of her Olos. She has one Olah left to bring. Leah,
similarly, has one Chatos left to bring.
It will never be known, of course, whether the true outcome of
the Kohain's actions was the worst case described in the result
above, the example described in this comment, or some other
outcome. Therefore all Chato'os and Olos that the women remain
obligated to bring are sfaykos, they are required because of
When an Olah is brought for an uncertain obligation, the owner
stipulates that the bird should be a voluntary korbon if, in
fact, he is under no obligation. An Olah may always be brought
voluntarily, as an Olas nedova.
A Chatos, however, may not be brought voluntarily. Therefore,
the type of stipulation made for the Olos is not available when a
Chatos is brought for a sofaik. Nevertheless, in some cases one
may bring a bird, though not an animal, when the obligation to
bring the Chatos is a sofaik, as discussed in the appendix.
Each woman must bring three Olos to replace the three Olos
she might be missing. However, each brings only one Chatos,
because of the limitation on bringing Chato'os when the
obligation is in doubt. They may also bring their birds jointly.
See the appendix.
Text © 1997 Rabbi Menachem
Moshe Oppen and Project Genesis,
Feedback is appreciated! It can be sent to: email@example.com.
BESHALACH AND TU BESHVAT:
Planting Our Song
Rabbi Berel Wein - 5760
Pride and Prejudice
Rabbi Mordechai Kamenetzky - 5756
Lessons in Appreciation
Rabbi Yosef Kalatzky - 5763
Thanks for the Suffering
Rabbi Dovid Green - 5756
Separating the Men From the Boys
Rabbi Yissocher Frand - 5761
Leaving To Prey
Rabbi Yochanan Zweig - 5770
Rabbi Label Lam - 5771
Freight and Handling
Rabbi Raymond Beyda - 5764
Anatomy of a Sin
Rabbi Osher Chaim Levene - 5768
Rabbi Yaakov Menken - 5758
Like a GPS
Rabbi Label Lam - 5772
A Seamless Integration On A Higher Plane
Rabbi Naftali Reich - 5773
I Am a Soul
Rabbi Label Lam - 5770
What is Tu B'Shvat?
Rabbi Yehudah Prero - 5761
Moshe Addressing Yosef’s Request
Rabbi Yosef Kalatzky - 5772
The Heart of the Matter
Rabbi Dovid Green - 5759