Kedushah, at least the Torah’s conception of it, eludes our quick
comprehension. Sacred space, sacred time, sacred objects – these are so
intuitive that almost every religion has them. But the Torah goes well
beyond the intuitive. Sanctity to other people is assumed to be innate in
some things, or created through contact or association with something
already sacred. According to our Torah, however, sanctity can be
manufactured at will. Take an ordinary object, and simply designate it as
hekdesh, and it becomes hekdesh. (When this happens, the object
is changed profoundly and essentially. We do not simply look at it
differently, or treat it differently. More than its legal status has
changed. We understand that the object has turned into something new and
Moreover, a verbal designation suffices to make the transformation.
Holiness comes about simply through words.
The first verses of our parshah convey an even greater surprise.
Words – ordinary words whose aim is not to create holiness in some object –
are also holy! The Torah instructs us to carefully uphold our vows.
What happens when we fail to do so? We are not described as abrogating
our vow, or violating it, as we might suppose. The Torah calls it
a “desecration” of our word.2 By what
argument are they holy, that they can be desecrated? Nothing changes
intrinsically through a vow. The one who took the vow must relate to its
object differently – but no one else must.
Can words alone be this holy?
Some details of the parshah are also jarring. The parshah
addresses “the heads of the tribes.”3
Nowhere else in the Torah does Hashem direct His mitzvah to them. The
halachic implication of this is well established, as cited by Rashi.
Those similar to the recognized stature of the heads of the tribes, i.e.
those who have recognized expertise in the area of nedarim, are the
ones who as single individuals are empowered to revoke vows. Why, though,
would the Torah teach us how to revoke vows before explaining the vows
Some powerful imagery from Rabbenu Yonah4 provides a partial answer. The keli shares –
one of the ministering vessels used in the beis hamikdosh - plays
a major role in the process of the avodah. The minchah
offering takes on the full status of korban when it is introduced
into the keli. Since the keli is holy, it has the capacity
to invest its contents with holiness.
By extension, a Jew’s mouth can become nothing less than a keli shares!
We should not be surprised, therefore, that the contents of the
mouth – the words that it forms and releases – should become sanctified as
Why would the mouth rise to the level of keli shares, more than any
other part of the body? Surely we serve Hashem with every part of
ourselves, and every bit of energy He gives us! The mouth, however,
stands out from other parts of ourselves. It is with our mouths that we
perform so many of the mitzvos that are constant and unceasing. We use
our mouths to study Torah, the all-important mitzvah which devolves upon
us at all times. Prayer is a constant preoccupation; some of the
remembrance-mitzvos like remembering Amalek, and remembering Shabbos
through Kiddush are performed by oral declaration. The mouth excels among
all the organs of the body in its service of G-d. It truly is a
ministering vessel, constantly enabling our avodah!
As attractive as this thought might be, it appears to suffer from a fatal
flaw. While the mouth can become a keli shares for some people,
for too many others the vessel is flawed and damaged. Not everyone
succeeds in turning his mouth into a constant tool of Divine service, and
yet all Jews can make binding vows!
Earlier, we puzzled over the Torah’s addressing the parshah to the
heads of the shevatim, and to placing the reference to them front
and center, before even setting forth the basic components of vows. The
seforim ha-kedoshim make an observation that sets off a cascade of
associations, leading to a solution of our problem. Immediately preceding
our parshah, the Torah lists all the holidays of the calendar and
their special offerings. The celebration of these holidays depends upon
the leaders of the community, the larger group from which the “heads of
the tribes” are drawn. The chief beis din meets and declares which
of two days is Rosh Chodesh, and when to insert the intercalated month of
the leap year into the calendar. The holiday observances are completely
dependant upon these actions of the court. Moreover, these actions are
really not actions at all, but verbal declarations. Once again, the power
of words surfaces and displays its importance. Mentioning the “heads of
the tribes” at the very beginning of our parshah serves as a
logical bridge between two similar Torah sections. Both of them
demonstrate the value and power of the speech of those who have turned
their mouths into instruments of holiness.
The connection between these sections can be appreciated at a deeper
level. Toras Avos teaches that the Divine Word is directed each
day to humanity, but is only received by the heads of the community and
the masters of Torah. (When Chazal taught5 that Yiftach in his generation is like the Shmuel of
his, this is what they had in mind. Despite Yiftach’s lesser stature
relative to Shmuel, he still served in a similar role. As the de facto
head of his generation, Hashem’s Word came to Yiftach’s generation through
him.) Others benefit from the Divine Influence through their connection
with Torah leaders.
The mouths of ordinary people, despite being unperfected vessels,
nonetheless can generate holiness because their leaders receive the Divine
Influence, and use it to produce kedushah. The leaders sanctify
Rosh Chodesh; they sanctify the holidays; they sanctify ordinary speech.
Some of that power is shared with the ordinary members of the community.
This power manifests itself in the institution of vows, which allows the
holiness of words and speech to create new requirements and restrictions
which should not be desecrated.
Any person’s vow can be undone by the Torah scholar. He serves in the
same capacity as a father regarding the vows of his daughter, and the
husband regarding the vows of his wife. Because the daughter and wife to
some extent answer to the authority of others, those others are empowered
to restrict certain vows. Similarly, all Jews derive their power to make
vows from the Torah leaders to whom they subordinate themselves. Their
vows are contingent upon them. When they do not approve, these leaders
can make the vows disappear.
Torah leaders are what make the vows possible in the first place. It thus
makes perfect sense that the parshah should be addressed to them,
and begins with them. By directing the Divine Influence to us, they
potentiate our speech, giving mere words the ability to be spiritually
significant. (The Gemara tells us that the laws of the Sage releasing
people from vows are not so well sourced in the text as other laws.
They “float in the air.”6 In truth,
these laws do not need to be made explicit. Without the Sage, there would
be no significance to the vows we make. It is intuitive that the Sage have
a key role in validating or dismissing them.)
Non-Jews cannot make halachically significant vows. They can, however,
consecrate animals as offerings in the Temple. Clearly, their speech can
direct objects to the “ownership” of the Temple estate. These objects
then have changed status relative to everyone. Their words, however,
cannot create personalized transgressions that apply to no one else but
the person who uttered them. Such power only come through the chief Torah
personalities, with which non-Jews have no connection.
Our words, it seems, are supercharged with holiness-generating capacity,
drawing from the Divine Word itself, which is brought near to us by our
association with Torah personalities. Comprehending this source of all
vows gives us new appreciation of the gift of speech, and our
responsibility to use it wisely.