By Rabbi Doniel Neustadt
A discussion of Halachic topics related to the Parsha of the
week. For final rulings, consult your Rav.
HOW EARLY AND HOW LATE MAY WE DAVEN?
CORRECT TIMES FOR RECITING SHEMA
There are five different time slots in which Shema may be recited:
1. The B'dieved time: After alos amud ha-shachar. Alos amud ha-shachar, the
crack of dawn, is generally defined by the poskim as 72 minutes before
sunrise(1). One is not allowed to recite Shema at this time. However, one
who did recite Shema that early, fulfills the mitzvah b'dieved(2). If this
happens more than once a month, however, he does not fulfill the mitzvah
even b'dieved(3). Under extenuating circumstances (b'she'as ha-d'chak), one
may regularly recite Shema at this time even l'chatchilah(4).
2. The correct time: When it is light enough "to be able to recognize an
acquaintance"(5). Different poskim have different calculations(6), ranging
from 60 minutes before sunrise(7) to 35-40 minutes before sunrise(8).
3. The preferred time: Immediately before sunrise. Since the preferred time
to recite Shemoneh Esrei is immediately after sunrise, the preferred time to
recite Shema is immediately before sunrise so that one can lead into
Shemoneh Esrei without interruption(9). This is known as tefillas vasikin.
4. The questionable but customary time: Until three hours of the day have
elapsed. If one recites Shema after sunrise, or at any time before three
hours of the day have elapsed, he has performed mitzvas Kerias Shema
properly. While many poskim maintain that l'chatchilah this is not the
proper time to recite Shema(10), for various reasons it has become commonly
accepted even by those who are meticulous in their mitzvah observance(11).
[Still, some poskim refer to one who recites Shema at this time as
fulfilling the mitzvah only b'dieved(12). According to these poskim, one
should recite Shema before sunrise even if he is not wearing tefillin(13).
Also, according to some poskim, one should recite Shema before sunrise even
if he is unable to recite birchos Kerias Shema(14).]
5. The too-late time: After three hours of the day have elapsed. There is a
basic and well-known dispute among the poskim as to how to figure these
three hours. Some maintain that the three hours are counted from alos amud
ha-shachar, while other poskim rule that the three hours are counted from
sunrise(15). Most authorities rule leniently, like the second view, and this
is the practice followed in most places(16).
Although one cannot fulfill the mitzvah of Kerias Shema after three hours
have elapsed, one should still say Kerias Shema at the time he says birchos
Kerias Shema and Shemoneh Esrei(17). Birchos Kerias Shema may be recited
l'chatchillah until the end of the fourth hour of the day(18).
CORRECT TIMES TO RECITE SHACHARIS SHEMONEH ESREI
There are five different time slots in which Shemoneh Esrei may be recited:
1. The b'she'as ha-d'chak/b'dieved time: After alos amud hashachar. When
absolutely necessary, e.g., before embarking on a trip or going to work or
school, one may daven at this time l'chatchilah(19). Otherwise, one is not
allowed to daven at this time(20). A retired person who was formerly
permitted to daven before sunrise due to his work schedule, should now daven
after sunrise only. B'dieved, if one davened before sunrise, he has
fulfilled his obligation and does not need to repeat Shacharis(21).
2. The preferred time: Exactly at sunrise. This is known as tefillas
3. The correct time: After sunrise.
4. The b'dieved time: After four hours of the day have elapsed.
L'chatchilah, one must daven before this time. If he failed to do so, he
must still daven now, although his davening is not considered as if he
davened on time.
5. The forbidden time: After chatzos (midday). After chatzos, it is forbidde
n to daven Shacharis(22). Under certain circumstances, a tashlumin [makeup
tefillah] may be said(23).
QUESTION: As stated earlier, one should not daven Shemoneh Esrei before
sunrise l'chatchilah. What should one do if an early minyan needs him to
join in order to have the minimum number of men required for a minyan?
DISCUSSION: Contemporary poskim debate this issue. Some(24) rule that he may
join the minyan but he may not daven with them. Therefore, if there are only
five people davening besides him, he should not be the sixth one. If,
however, there are nine other people davening besides him, he may join them
in order to complete the minyan - but he may not daven along with them.
Other poskim(25) hold that in a situation where his refusal to join will
cause the minyan to be canceled, he should daven with them so that they,
too, will daven with a minyan.
QUESTION: What should one do if the only minyan in town davens Shemoneh
Esrei before sunrise? Is it better to daven without a minyan at the proper
time than to daven with a minyan at an improper time?
DISCUSSION: If the choice is to daven without a minyan but exactly at
sunrise, thus gaining the advantage of vasikin, then one should do so. If he
cannot do so, some poskim(26) allow him to daven with the minyan available
[provided that they daven Shemoneh Esrei after it is "light enough to
recognize an acquaintance"], while many others(27) maintain that he should
wait for the proper time and daven without a minyan.
1 Beiur Halachah 89:1 quoting the Rambam. See further in Beiur Halachah who
recommends waiting a few minutes past alos amud ha-shachar - so that the
"face of the east lights up."
2 O.C. 58:4.
3 Mishnah Berurah 58:19.
4 O.C. 58:3 and Mishnah Berurah 19.
5 O.C. 58:1.
6 Harav Y.Y. Kanievsky is quoted (Tefillah K'hilchasah pg. 68) as saying
that it is difficult to estimate this time without a daily visual
7 The custom in Eretz Yisrael, as quoted by Harav Y.M. Tikutinsky in Sefer
Eretz Yisrael, pg. 18. There are other times as well.
8 Igros Moshe O.C. 4:6. Harav Y. Kamenetsky calculated the correct time as
36 minutes before sunrise (oral ruling quoted in Emes l'Yaakov, Berachos
9 O.C. 58:1.
10 This is the view of Rif, Rambam and Gra, and it is quoted without dissent
by Mishnah Berurah 58:3 and 4. This is also the ruling of Aruch ha-Shulchan
58:6 and Harav S.Y. Elyashiv (oral ruling quoted in Avnei Yashfei on
Tefillah, 2nd edition, pg. 103).
11 The basis for this leniency is in the wording of Shulchan Aruch 58:1
which rules that the time to recite Shema is from when it is light enough to
be able to recognize an acquaintance, until three hours of the day have
passed; it does not differentiate between l'chatchilah and b'dieved. See
Shulchan Aruch Harav 58:4 and Kaf ha-Chayim 58:8 who quote two views on this
issue and tend to be lenient. Note also that neither Chayei Adam 21:3 nor
Kitzur Shulchan Aruch 17:1 require that l'chatchilah one recite Shema before
12 See above note.
13 Shulchan Aruch Harav 58:4; Beiur Halachah 58:1. See, however, Kaf
14 Harav S.Y. Elyashiv (quoted in Avnei Yashfei on Tefillah, 2nd edition,
pg. 103) based on Shulchan Aruch Harav 58:4. Harav Y. Kamenetsky, however,
did not recommend this approach; see Emes Lyakov O.C. 58, note 69.
15 Both views are quoted in Mishnah Berurah 58:4 without a decision. See
also Beiur Halachah
16 Aruch ha-Shulchan 58:14; Chazon Ish O.C. 13:3; Igros Moshe O.C. 1:24;
Minchas Yitzchak 3:71; Yalkut Yosef pg. 100. There are also those who are
stringent and rule like the first view (see Teshuvos v'Hanhagos 1:56 quoting
Harav A. Kotler and Orchos Rabbeinu 1:53 quoting Harav Y.Y. Kanievsky). Many
shuls in Eretz Yisrael conduct themselves in accordance with the first view.
17 O.C. 60:2. See Mishnah Berurah 4 and Aruch ha-Shulchan 2.
18 O.C. 58:6. B'dieved and under extentuating circumstances, they may be
recited until chatzos. Women, however, may not rely on this.
19 O.C. 89:8; Igros Moshe O.C. 4:6.
20 This is the general consensus of all poskim. Note, however, that there is
a minority view, the Pri Chadash, who rules that it is permitted
l'chatchilah to daven before sunrise, as long as it is light enough to
recognize an acquaintance. Beiur Halachah 89:1 rules that although it is
preferable not to do so, (possibly) we should not object to those who are
21 Mishnah Berurah 89:4. Note, however, that tefillin may not be put on
until it is light enough to recognize an acquaintance.
22 Rama 89:1. Men and women are included in this--see Halachah Discussion on
Parashas Va'eira, pg. 119.
23 See O.C. 108 for details.
24 Harav S.Y. Elyashiv (quoted in Tefillah K'hilchasah pg. 78 and in Avnei
Yashfei on Tefillah, 2nd edition, pg. 169).
25 Harav S.Z. Auerbach (quoted in Tefillah K'hilchasah pg. 78 and in Avnei
Yashfei on Tefillah, 2nd edition, pg. 169).
26 Harav Y. Peterburger in Pri Yitzchak 2; Yaskil Avdi 5:10.
27 Responsa Sh'eilas Shmuel O.C. 12; Igros Moshe O.C. 4:6; Harav S.Y.
Elyashiv (oral ruling quoted in Avnei Yashfei on Tefillah, 2nd edition, pg.
167); Harav O. Yosef (Yalkut Yosef pg. 137).
Weekly-Halacha, Copyright © 2002 by Rabbi Neustadt, Dr. Jeffrey Gross and
Project Genesis, Inc.
Rabbi Neustadt is the principal of Yavne
Teachers' College in Cleveland, Ohio. He is also the Magid Shiur of a daily
Mishna Berurah class at Congregation Shomre Shabbos.
The Weekly-Halacha Series is distributed L'zchus Hayeled Doniel Meir ben
Hinda. Weekly sponsorships are available--please send email to the moderator, Dr.
Jeffrey Gross email@example.com.
The series is distributed by the Harbotzas Torah Division of Congregation
Shomre Shabbos, 1801 South Taylor Road, Cleveland Heights, Ohio 44118--HaRav
Yisroel Grumer, Marah D'Asra