Rabbi Jonathan Rosenblum
|``The claim that ultra-Orthodox Jewish women freely choose to bring 12
children into the world is about as solid as the claim that there are women
who freely choose to become prostitutes or paid surrogate mothers. If it
were not for their emotional misery and if it were not for the social
pressure they are under and the state of abject poverty in which they live,
ultra-Orthodox women would not opt for a life of slavery. It is doubtful
whether most ever had the opportunity to make any personal choices
whatsoever in their lives.''|
So writes Orit Shohat in Ha'Aretz about large chareidi families. For sheer
condescension, her description of the mindless, bovine existence of chareidi (fervently Orthodox)
women would be hard to beat.
From her writing, one must guess that Shohat has never had a serious conversation with a
chareidi woman (perhaps she assumes that they are incapable of
it). Surveys of Israeli society regularly show that the most devoutly
secular and those furthest to the left on the political spectrum - i.e.,
the typical Ha'Aretz reader and writer - are the least likely to know well
anyone who differs from them politically or religiously.
Some clearly prefer living in claustrophobic boxes of
like-minded people and passing judgment on the lives of others, to actually
learning something about those whom they purport to describe.
Granted, chareidi women do not spend a lot of time deciding which restaurant
to eat in tonight, or whether to take a ski vacation or have another child.
But there are other choices in life than those between various material
The upbringing of each child involves countless decisions and a great deal
of wisdom. Does Shohat think that children in large families raise
themselves, or that within each family they are all raised the same way?
Dr. Yitzchak Kadmon, executive director of the National Council for the
Child, recently exploded this myth as "complete nonsense." And Professor
Menachem Friedman of Bar Ilan University characterizes chareidim as
"excelling" at child rearing (yes, I know many do not), due in large part
to the community's great emphasis on children.
One group of chareidi woman who have incontestably made large lifetime
decisions are those who were not raised in observant homes. Rutgers
sociologist and self-described feminist Debra Renee Kaufman interviewed 150
baalot teshuva, most of them veterans of the women's movement and the
sexual revolution, for her book Rachel's Daughters. Unlike Shohat, Kaufman
was not interested in polemics, but in honestly listening to what her
subjects had to tell her.
And what she heard bears little resemblance to the emotional misery and
cow-like existence assumed by Shohat. Rather than the strictures of Torah
Judaism being something that these women had to overcome on the road to
religious observance, they are all quick to point out that "the most
valued part of their lives has to do with their lives as women within
Jewish orthodoxy." Not one expressed any doubts about her "theological
equality in Orthodox Judaism" or doubts that she is as "capable and
worthy of spiritual bonding with G-d as men are."
Upon entering the Orthodox community these women found themselves for the
first time members of a community in which the traditional "feminine
virtues" - modesty, the centrality of home and family, sharing rather than
competing - are those emphasized by the society at large. As a consequence,
they are "able to make demands on men as husbands and fathers in ways they
believe less possible in the secular world."
Orthodoxy empowers them. "Before I became Orthodox," one woman told
Kaufman, "I was male-identified. You know: what's male is better. Not in
Judaism. If anything, it is a bit reversed." Orthodox women engage in a
daily round of communal activities dominated by other women.
Many find that their female friendships are deeper than in the past because
they no longer "compete with one another for men's attention." One
teacher of the laws of family purity reports secular Jewish women "brought
to tears by the thought of a society in which every move is not subject to
the lens of male appraisal, and where they may be truly free to be
Even the laws of family purity, with their mandated periods of sexual
separation and coming together, are experienced positively. "The family
purity laws are so in line with me as a woman. . . [I]t is commanded that I
not be sexually taken for granted, that I have two weeks each month for
myself," one woman told Kaufman. Going to the mikveh, these women feel
"connected to history and other women."
Because their intimate lives are wholly reserved to a private domain,
Kaufman discovered, "the baalot teshuva seem to stimulate and deepen their
sense of sexuality." After decades of marriage, Orthodox women still
report experiencing the excitement of new brides upon returning from the
In a Los Angelos Times first-person feature story, a former "Cosmo girl"
describes her Orthodox wedding: "After the ceremony, before the dancing...Aaron and I went to a separate room to spend a few private moments.
There, he held my hand for the first time. That small gesture had a
richness and intimacy I could never have imagined."
Doesn't sound so bad. Maybe Ms. Shohat would like to meet a few observant
Copyright © 2000 by Rabbi Jonathan Rosenblum. We welcome your comments.
|I suspect that the truth lies somewhere between Orit Shohat and Rabbi Rosenblum.
That is, for some women, having 12 children may be experienced as a blessing; for others, a health-endangering burden. And let's not forget that Ba'al Teshuvah women often have educational experiences that are closed to Charedi-from-birth women; many of the latter are married by the time they are 17 years old. How many Charedi women truly have a choice about deferring marriage to pursue a college education? |
- M. L. -0/5-/2003
|* * * * *|
It's not just Ha'Aretz. The 28 June 01 ce, 7 Tammuz, Jerusalem Post has a gossip column entitled "Modest Dress Said To Cause Vitamin Deficiency". No difficulty with the topical medical analysis. Probe beyond the health care tip on vitamin supplements to Charadi women and we see our enemies at work.
Perhaps another health tip from Tel Aviv will be "Come, I will get wine and we will guzzel liquor together; and tomorrow we will also be like this, and even much greater" Isiah 56:12.
What do the publicly funded Israeli studies say about go go shorts, heels and skimpy tops? Malaria is making a comeback.
Babylon West coastal Virginia |
- B. W. -0/6-/2001
|* * * * *|
|A very thoughtful, insightful piece. Many more of those are needed to counter the mindless and incorrect perception of chareidi women in this world. As somebody who only recently entered Judaism and is longing for a family, I fully identify with the women described.|
|* * * * *|
Aharon's Unique Gift
Rabbi Yisroel Ciner - 5761
Rabbi Pinchas Winston - 5769
A Refreshing Look at the Menorah
Rabbi Eliyahu Hoffmann - 5764
The Torah is Not Just for Rabbis
Rabbi Yaakov Menken - 5759
Nothing and Everything
Rabbi Naftali Reich - 5769
Appreciate the Present
Rabbi Berel Wein - 5767
Was Moshe Really Humble?
Rabbi Yaakov Menken - 5762
Control Your Life
Rabbi Pinchas Winston - 5770
Our Daily Challenge
Rabbi Label Lam - 5765
The Ear That Hears
Rabbi Label Lam - 5767
We Don't Even Understand Our Own Motives Without Wise Counsel From Others
Rabbi Yissocher Frand - 5772
The Lesson of the Menorah: Focus
Rabbi Berel Wein - 5772
The Most Important Person
Rabbi Dovid Green - 5759
Moshe Vs. Yisro
Rabbi Aron Tendler - 5759
Understanding Hashem's Love
Rabbi Yosef Kalatzky - 5762
Closed Gates and Dead-Ends
Rabbi Eliyahu Hoffmann - 5761