The jig is up. Rabbi Eric Yoffie has us figured out, and the time has come to `fess up.
Delivering his keynote sermon at the UAHC convention earlier this month, Rabbi Yoffie attacked supporters of school vouchers who "claim that their goal is to help the poor and improve public education by creating competition" when their "real aim is to secure funding for their own schools." And, the rabbi revealed, it's not only Protestant and Roman Catholic groups whose pro-voucher stance is founded on parochial interests, but also (gasp!) "Jewish organizations that have supported vouchers, or remain silent, hoping to secure funding for yeshivas and Jewish day schools."
Well, all right, we'll admit it (though we've never pretended otherwise):
The organization I represent (Agudath Israel of America) supports vouchers primarily because we think they will help Jewish schools and Jewish families. We also think they will help other segments of the American population, especially the inner-city poor who desperately seek but are unable to afford an alternative to the failing public schools to which their children are consigned. But, to be perfectly frank, that consideration is only of secondary significance in our admittedly self-interested calculation.
Indeed, if the factor of self-interest were removed - if all Jewish schools were on firm fiscal footing, if all Jewish parents who would want to enroll their children in Jewish schools could afford to do so - we might well disengage from the entire voucher debate.
But the reality is that many Jewish schools are struggling mightily - sometimes unsuccessfully - to meet skyrocketing budgets. Some of the most outstanding teachers are being driven away because paychecks are skimpy and late. Facilities are often inadequate, basic maintenance and repairs frequently neglected, educational materials in short supply, resource rooms and other special education services few and far between - all for a shortage of funds. Worst of all, despite extremely generous school scholarship policies, all too many children are being turned away because of their parents' inability to pay tuition.
Frankly, if we had our druthers, we would much prefer not having to look to government to help address these problems. Our first choice would be to rely on Jewish communal sources of support for what is, after all, a precious Jewish communal resource. Unfortunately, while Federations across the United States have supported Jewish schools to some extent, the reality remains that the schools continue to be woefully under-funded.
And so self-interest is very much a factor in considering the question of vouchers. If we stand accused of formulating our positions on educational policy with a primary focus on how they might help our choking schools, and how they might impact on parents seeking a Jewish education for their children, we plead guilty.
The rabbi is "embarrassed and ashamed when [he] hear[s] such arguments coming from Jews" - because, after all, "the public schools were the ladder that we used to climb from poverty to affluence in American life, and how dare we deny it to others." However, we wear our commitment to Jewish schools as a badge of Jewish pride, not shame. And we question whether public school education is as closely aligned with Jewish interests as this rabbi thinks.
It is not difficult to understand why so many of our parents and grandparents embraced the ideal of American public education. They arrived in this country, having escaped persecution, pogroms and even Holocaust, determined to ensure that life in America would be different. Their children, they resolved, would be part of the great American mainstream, fully integrated in American society, shedding once and for all the burden of being outsiders. Their children would attend school with children of other faiths, develop friendships with children of other faiths, and eventually share equally in all the wonderful opportunities America had to offer.
The plan succeeded - but it succeeded too well. Jews in the United States have today become accepted in virtually every nook and cranny of American society. But immersion in the American melting pot, whose fires were stoked at the doors of the public schools, has robbed the large bulk of American Jewry of the religious identity and heritage that is its most precious possession. With intermarriage rates soaring, with so many Jews feeling entirely disconnected from their roots and heritage, Jews in the United States are, G-d forbid, at risk of disappearing.
We stand at a moment in American Jewish history when the crisis in Jewish continuity is broadly acknowledged as the single largest problem facing our community. What should be causing us embarrassment and shame - and, frankly, sleepless nights - is the sorry state of Jewish knowledge and Jewish commitment, and the prospect that our children or grandchildren may grow up without any sense of meaningful Jewish identity.
If public schooling was the antidote to the problems our forebears faced when they arrived in this country, religious schooling is the antidote to the problems we face today. As the Louis Guttman Israel Institute of Applied Social Research concluded in a 1993 study, "Jewish day schools are the best vehicle for implementing Jewish involvement and are the only type of Jewish education that stands against the very rapidly growing rate of intermarriage" in the United States.
To his credit, the rabbi does appear to recognize the essential link between Jewish education and Jewish continuity; he used his convention platform to call on his movement to establish new day schools and strengthen after-school "Talmud Torah" programs for public school children, calling religious schools "critical to our future." Yet despite that recognition, he rails against Jewish groups whose position on vouchers is motivated principally by concern for that very Jewish future.
To be sure, Americans of all faiths have a stake in improving education for all children. Reasonable people can differ whether expanding parental choice through vouchers will advance or inhibit that cause. But whatever the outcome of that debate, let's not lose sight of the fact that our most urgent Jewish priority today must be the strengthening of our own educational institutions.
And let's stop pretending that there's anything shameful about Jewish groups formulating public policy positions with a focus on Jewish interests - especially when what's at stake is nothing less than Jewish survival.
AM ECHAD RESOURCES
[David Zwiebel is Agudath Israel of America's executive vice president for government and public affairs. This article first appeared in the January 4, 2002 issue of the Forward.]
|What I see as the greatest danger to the continuity of Judaism or any other independent religious group in America is the movement to reduce the influence of parents in our homes to physical responsibility without the teaching of values. One of the tremendous advantages which Judaism has exercised by tradition is the teaching of real fact based values to children who carry them on for generation after generation. I believe that comfort, prosperity and success of pursuit in its endeavors has caused all of our peoples to reduce dependence on G-d and pat ourselves on the back for things which have been given us for which we claim the credit.
We are currently giving permission to a group of arrogant manipulating authoritarians to do our thinking for us. Big Brother is alive and well, and if we want to see our children survive this situation as real people who do their own thinking and doing, we are going to have to change our thinking and approach to our children and our government while there is time. |
- R. S. -0/1-/2002
|* * * * *|
|Government will always be part of education. The question is how, and at what level. In Connecticut(USA) at least, most of the public K-12 school funds come from local tax payers. We have a standing national military but we also have state militias. "To provide for the common defense, to promote the general welfare"...education is part of that "general welfare". Vouchers are simply the most centralise way of funding decentralized choice. American Jews have as much right to funding as any other group. |
|* * * * *|
|Vouchers are a false hope. They are a remote possibility, particularly in New York, and will only help a few poor people. They are many years away, if at all, and if they ever come, will only marginally make a difference. Looking to the Government for help is not the answer. I heard that Rav Moshe Feinstein once said that if all the Jews paid maaser (10-20% of income), the yeshivas would not have financial problems. We Jews in general, and the yeshivas in particular, need to do a better job of raising money, particularly from wealthy Jews. The financial burden on parents is now far too great, and has become a source of many social problems. |
- E. P. -0/1-/2002
|* * * * *|
|I've got a better idea than vouchers.
Let's get government out of the education business!
Make the government give back the tax money that they waste on public(or as I like to call them "prison") schools. Parents could then enroll their kids into private schools where their religous teachings are backed up or not.
People argue against this because they think that poor people would not be able to afford school. But using an immoral income tax to rob Peter and pay Paul in order to fund a failing system is not a better system for the poor. |
- J. P. -0/1-/2002
|* * * * *|
Working on the Outside
Rabbi Aron Tendler - 5760
The Segulot of Mitzvot
Shlomo Katz - 5772
If It Can Happen To Bilaam, It Can Happen to Any of Us
Rabbi Yissocher Frand - 5765
Rabbi Label Lam - 5771
A Real Yiddishe Kup!
Rabbi Label Lam - 5766
Uses and Misuses
Rabbi Berel Wein - 5765
Rabbi Yisroel Ciner - 5760
Mixed Multitude of Troubles
Rabbi Pinchas Winston - 5760
Bilam's Big Appetite
Shlomo Katz - 5760
Symbolism Over Substance
Rabbi Mordechai Kamenetzky - 5759
Three Differences Between Bilaam and Rabbi Yosi ben Kisma
Rabbi Yissocher Frand - 5771
A Different Kind of Friend
Rabbi Yochanan Zweig - 5770
Rabbi Pinchas Winston - 5759
Rabbi Pinchas Winston - 5770
The Epitome of Righteousness
Rabbi Naftali Reich - 5768
The Good Tents
Rabbi Yaakov Menken - 5761