The Special Value of the Jew
Rabbi Yosef Kalatsky
To attend over 4,000 Torah classes online go to www.yadavraham.org
(Multimedia Library). You will find classes in Gemara, Halacha, Mussar,
Hashkofa, Chumash, and other lectures.
1. The Special Standard to Which a Jew is Held
The Torah states, "If your brother becomes impoverished and his means
falter in your proximity, you shall strengthen him - proselyte or resident
- so that he can live with you." The Torah tells us that if one sees a
pack animal of his fellow faltering under its load, he is obligated to
unload the animal so that it should not fall. Should the animal fall it
would require many people to lift the load. Similarly, if one sees his
fellow faltering due to his financial situation, he must assist him before
he becomes destitute.
The Midrash Tanchuma cites a verse in Mishlei (Proverbs), "Do not steal
from a poor man because he is poor. Hashem will take up his cause." The
Midrash explains, "Do not steal from the poor man because I (Hashem)
decreed that he should be poor. If one victimizes the poor person it is as
if he is mocking Me (Hashem)." The Midrash asks, "What is the meaning of
"stealing from a poor man?" Why would one attempt to steal from one who has
nothing? Shlomo HaMelech (King Solomon) must be addressing a specific
situation. Initially one had taken upon himself to give financial
assistance to his fellow to alleviate his financial plight. However, after
some time the benefactor asks himself, "How long must I continue to support
this needy person?" He then decides to withdraw his support.
Since the needy person had relied upon his benefactor for support,
withholding the assistance is considered stealing. One must continue to
support the needy individual because he has nowhere else to turn. If one
withdraws his support, then Hashem will take up his cause and fight his
battle. Thus if one ceases to support a needy person (who has come to rely
upon him) he is culpable. How do we understand this?
The reason an individual merited wealth while his fellow did not is only
because Hashem Willed this to be so. If G-d wanted to reverse the
circumstances of these two individuals, He could do so easily. Thus, the
person of means should be thankful that G-d put him in a position to be the
benefactor rather than the beneficiary of someone else's support. If the
wealthy man decides to withdraw his support (of the one in need), G-d
considers it "stealing." Thus, we see the standard to which a Jew is held
is far more reaching than the standard of the nations of the world.
The Gemara in Tractate Shabbos tells us that prior to the Sinai event, G-d
approached the nations of the world and offered them His Torah. Each
nation refused the Torah because its laws were not in conformity with their
lifestyle. For example, when G-d offered the Torah to the Edomites
(descendents of Esav) they asked, "What is written in it?" G-d responded,
"Thou shall not commit murder." To this they responded, "If this is the
case then we cannot accept it because we received a blessing from our
grandfather (Yitzchak) - you shall live by the sword." Why did all the
nations reject the Torah because its principles were contradictory to their
lifestyle? Every civilized society has within its governing laws that
prohibit murder, stealing, etc.
Rabbi Y.I Ruderman zt'l (Baltimore Rosh HaYeshivah) answers this question
by explaining that when G-d said, "It is stated in My Torah - Thou shall
not commit murder" it was not the blatant violation of shedding blood and
taking a life (which is one of the seven Noachide Laws). Rather it was
something at a more sensitive level. The Gemara in Tractate Bava Metzia
states," If one embarrasses his fellow in public to the point that his face
changes color, it is considered as if he had killed him. If one undermines
his fellow's livelihood it is considered as if he had taken his
life." Although within the context of the seven Noachide laws, killing
means literally taking a life, however, if one were to accept the Torah, he
is held to a higher standard. Thus when the verse states, "Do not steal
from the poor man," it does not only mean taking something that is not
rightfully yours but rather one should not deprive the person who relies on
Therefore when G-d provides one with wealth it is for the sole purpose of
alleviating the plight of his fellow -as the verse states, "If your brother
becomes impoverished and his means falter in your proximity, you shall
strengthen him - proselyte or resident - so that he can live with you."
2. Focusing on One's Spirituality
The Torah states, "If your brother becomes impoverished and his means
falter in your proximity, you shall strengthen him..." On a literal level,
the verse is addressing one's obligation to his fellow when he falters
financially. The Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh explains this verse allegorically.
The "brother" who falters is referring to one who is closest to the
individual who can help him. One's soul (neshama) is closest to
oneself. The "brother" faltering is thus referring to one's own
spirituality. The Torah is telling us that when one sees that he is
faltering spiritually (no longer senses illumination and does not feel
energized by his own performance of mitzvos and Torah study) he must
strengthen himself. One who is spiritually deficient is considered
impoverished because he is disconnected from his source and has thus lost
The Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh explains that the reason for spiritual faltering
and disconnection is due to the neshama being influenced by the physicality
of man. Thus, one must pray to Hashem to restore it to its original state
which is unaffected by his own physicality. How does one restore his sense
of spirituality when engaging in Torah study and mitzvos? It is only
through teshuvah (repentance) that one is able to restore and re-instate
his neshama to its original and exalted state. The Torah is telling us
when one focuses on materialism it causes his neshama to
wither. Therefore, the only approach to reinvigorating one's spirituality
is through the process of teshuvah.
Most people feel and believe that the time for teshuvah is the period of
time that leads up to Yom Kippur. We recite three times a day in our
tefillah (prayer), "Bring us back, our Father, to Your Torah, and bring us
near, our King, to Your service, and influence us to return in perfect
repentance (teshuvah) before You. Blessed are You Hashem Who desires
repentance." We continuously beseech Hashem to assist us to do teshuvah.
If we continuously acknowledge that Hashem wants us to do teshuvah, and we
do not attempt to repent, then for what are we praying? Are our prayers
sincere? If one truly desires to do teshuvah as much as he wants G-d to
assist him with his livelihood, then there is no question that G-d will
respond and give him the ability to do teshuvah.
Rabbi Yosef Dov Ber Solovetchik zt'l (The Bais HaLevi zt'l) at one point in
his life became disillusioned with the rabbinate. His only interest was to
focus on the study of Torah. A delegation from Brisk approached him to
assume the position of Chief Rabbi of their community. The Bais HaLevi
refused the position outright. However when they returned to him a second
time they informed him that the 25,000 Jews of the Brisk community were
waiting for him to assume the position of their Chief Rabbi. The Bais
HaLevi was not able to refuse. He said, "If the Jews of Brisk are awaiting
my acceptance, I cannot refuse." He accepted the position.
When the Chofetz Chaim heard this story he had said, "If the Jewish people
were truly sincere when they pray for the coming of Moshiach, Hashem would
bring him immediately." If the Bais HaLevi could not refuse the sincere
request of the Brisk community, it is logical to say that Hashem, the All
Merciful One, could not refuse our sincere request to bring Moshiach
The Gemara tells us, "If it were not for Hashem's assistance, one could not
subdue his evil inclination." Without Hashem's intervention, it is not
possible to develop, refine, and protect one's spirituality. Every Jew
needs G-d's Assistance. However, one only merits this assistance if he
sincerely desires it. Thus, one must first focus on developing a sincere
interest in his own spiritual development and then act upon it by
beseeching Hashem through tefillah (prayer).
On the holidays, we say a prayer in which we ask G-d to enable us to do
deeds that are truly good "in His eyes." Meaning, even when one believes
that he is doing the right thing, it may not be the case. It is only if
Hashem values deeds as being "good" that they are so. Therefore, we must
continuously pray for His Assistance to direct us to do what is truly good
in His eyes.
3. The Innate Value of Torah
The Torah states,"Im BeChukosai teileichu v'es Mitzvosai tishmeru... (If
you will follow My Statutes and observe My Commandments and perform them);
then I will provide for your rains in their time. And the land will give
forth its produce and the tree of the field will give forth its fruit." If
one follows Hashem's Statutes, he will be deserving of G-d's endless
bounty. Chukim (Statutes) are laws that are not able be understood within a
Rashi cites Chazal who explain that when the Torah states," If you will
follow My Statutes..." it is referring to the quality of the Jew's
commitment to toil in the study of Torah. Thus, the Statute that the Torah
is referring to is the selfless commitment to the study of Torah. In
addition, the Torah is telling us that one must study for the sake of
performing mitzvos. Both the study of Torah and the performance of mitzvos
should be done with selfless dedication. However, the Torah states, "If
you will not listen to Me and will not perform all of these
commandments...I will turn My attention against you..." Evidently, if one
toils in Torah, he will be deserving of endless blessing; however if he
does not selflessly toil in Torah (although he is studying) he will be
deserving of the curses stated in this Portion. How do we understand this?
Toiling in Torah study is classified as a Chok (Statute) which cannot be
understood within a rational context. One would think that one's
dedication to Torah study would be a prerequisite for one's quality of
performance of mitzvos and understanding of the Will of Hashem. However
the Torah is telling us that the reason one must toil in Torah and apply
himself selflessly is not because of one's own personal understanding but
rather because it is the Decree of G-d. If one's approach to Torah study
was solely based on one's own rational understanding of value, then it is
possible that it could be undermined by another rational approach to the
contrary. However, since dedicated Torah study is classified as Chok, it
is a level of commitment that cannot be questioned.
The verse that introduces the curses - "If you will not listen to Me..."
does not necessarily refer to one who does not toil in Torah. Rather it
refers to one who may toil in Torah but he does not do so, "for Me (G-d)."
Meaning, he does not accept it as a Statute of G-d (Chok). The dedication
of Torah study must be purely for the sake of fulfilling G-d's Decree and
not for any other reason.
One only merits the bounty and the blessing of Hashem only if he negates
himself to G-d and accepts Hashem's Will as a Statute. However, if one
adheres to the Statutes because of his own rational understating, (although
he is observing the law) he will not merit the advanced level of blessing.
One's adherence to Torah must be rooted in one's unequivocal acceptance of
the G-d's Divine Edicts. If one does not accept the Torah in this context,
his observance of any mitzvah (rational or not) can come into
question. Whenever the Torah delineates one's obligations it does so in
the following order: Chukim (Statutes), Mishpatim (Commandments), and
Mitzvos. This is to communicate that even when one performs a mitzvah that
we can relate to its value, in essence it is being observed as a
Chok. This is why the Mishpatim are always predicated on Chukim - to
communicate this principle. For example, the Commandments that prohibit
killing and stealing, which are classified as rational laws, are in effect
not rooted in rational thought but rather based on the Divine. One adheres
to all mitzvos (including the ones we seemingly understand) only because it
is the Will of Hashem. One merits Hashem's blessing when one adheres to
the Torah under these terms.
Rambam rules that one is only permitted to interrupt his Torah study if
another mitzvah presents itself which cannot be delegated through a third
party. Thus, if one decides to interrupt his Torah study for any reason
other than that permitted by the Torah (although he may be performing a
mitzvah) he will not merit blessing. It is only the one who studies Torah,
as outlined by the Word of Hashem, who merits blessing.
To achieve a selfless level of dedication to Torah and its ideals, one must
negate his own personal rational understanding of its value. Only then will
he merit the endless bounty of Hashem.
4. Why are Jews not Counted?
Ramban at the beginning of the Portion of Bamidbar addresses the failing of
Dovid HaMelech (King David) vis-à-vis the census that he had taken. Dovid
HaMelech took a census of the Jewish people in order to quantify the
dimension of his kingdom. As a result of this, thousands of Jews died from
plague. Ramban explains that Dovid had violated the law that is stated,
"They (the Jewish people) shall not be counted because of their
abundance." The consequence of transgressing this negative precept was the
onset of plague. If the basis of the prohibition (of quantifying the
Jewish people) is because they are "abundant in number" (and are
un-quantifiable), then if they can be counted, they are not at that
"un-quantifiable" number. In addition, why is plague a consequence of
The Torah states," If you will follow My Statutes and observe My
Commandments and perform them...You will pursue your enemies; and they will
fall before you by the sword. Five of you will pursue a hundred, and a
hundred of you will pursue ten thousand..." The Torah is communicating to
us that if the Jewish people adhere to the Word of Hashem, five Jews could
pursue one hundred of the enemy and a hundred Jews could pursue ten
thousand enemies. How is this possible when the number of people is so
The intrinsic value of a Jew does not emanate from his own capabilities.
His innate value rests in the fact that he has a connection to Hashem. The
Jewish people are the "Kingly, priestly, and holy nation" of Hashem. Just
as G-d's essence is un-quantifiable and limitless, because He is infinite,
anything that is connected to Him has a semblance of limitlessness. When
the Jewish people adhere to the Torah and live their lives as prescribed by
Hashem, they become invincible. Quantitative value plays no role whatsoever.
The Torah tells us that G-d promised Avraham our Patriarch that his
offspring will be as innumerable as the stars in the heavens and the sand
on the seashore. The reality is that the Jewish people (throughout
history) have never reached those numbers. We have always been few in
number vis-à-vis the world. How do we understand G-d's promise to Avraham?
The "abundance" of the Jewish people that is stated in the Torah is not a
quantitative measure, but rather qualitative. The Mishna in Tractate
Sanhedrin tells us that if one saves the life of one Jew it is the
equivalent of saving the whole world. Since this is the case, is it not
possible to compute the value of even one Jew. Thus if one takes a census
of the Jewish people for the sake of quantification, it is a distortion and
a detraction of their true value. Dovid transgressed because his focus was
on the physicality of the Jewish people (which is quantifiable) rather than
the essence of the Jewish people.
Thus, consequence of this negative precept of counting the Jews is
death. If one attempts to value the physical rather than recognizing and
appreciating the essence (which is the spiritual), Hashem teaches us that
the physical does not matter (i.e. plague).
Shamai, the Elder, tells us in Pirkei Avos that one's Torah study should be
primary while one's work should be secondary. One's focus needs to be on
his spirituality. As the Torah states,"Im BeChukosai teileichu v'es
Mitzvosai t'shmeru... If you will follow My Statutes and observe My
Commandments and perform them..." Meaning if a Jew prioritizes his
spirituality/Torah study then his focus is his own essence. If this is the
case then there are no limitations. One becomes a receptacle for unlimited
bounty and blessing without making a commensurate amount of effort.
In the story of Chanukah we read that a handful of Choshmona'im (who were
known as Maccabim) were able to defeat the mighty Greek army. How was this
possible? The name Maccabe identified the devoted group of Choshmona'im
(priests) whose war cry was Me ChaMocha B'elim Hashem (Who is like you
G-d). The Choshmona'im defeated the mighty Greeks because they relied
solely on their relationship with Hashem and not their own physical
capabilities. It was only because of their belief and dedication to G-d
that their miniscule number was irrelevant. Thus, one who is committed to
G-d and adheres to His statutes will be able to surpass many limitations
and merit unlimited beracha (blessing).
5. Appreciating the Merit of the Patriarchs
The Torah tells us that after the Jewish people experience tragedies for
not adhering to the Statutes and Commandments of the Torah, they will
repent. The Torah states, "Then they will confess their sin...perhaps then
their unfeeling heart will be humbled and then they will gain appeasement
for their sin. I will remember My covenant with Yaakov, My covenant with
Yitzchak, and also My covenant with Avraham will I remember..." It is
evident from this verse that the Jewish people will do a sincere teshuvah
(repentance) after experiencing the curses. If in fact the quality of
their teshuvah is sincere and complete, then why is it necessary for Hashem
to "remember" the covenant of the Patriarchs? One would think that teshuvah
in its own right would be sufficient.
Rambam writes in Hilchos Teshuvah (The Laws of Repentance) that since we no
longer have the Bais HaMikdash (Temple - where the offerings of atonement
were brought), "teshuvah itself is the altar of atonement." If teshuvah
brings about full atonement there should be no additional prerequisite.
However, the Torah tells us that without G-d remembering the covenant of
the Patriarchs, the Jewish people will not be forgiven. How do we
The Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh explains that confession and repentance alone can
only annul the decrees that come upon the Jewish people. The Jewish people
are no longer held liable for their past transgressions. However in order
to be fully reinstated (as if they had never sinned before) in the Eyes of
Hashem, one needs the merit of the Patriarchs - Avraham, Yitzchak, and Yaakov.
The Gemara in Tractate Zevachim states when one would bring a sin offering
it was accompanied with a burnt offering (korbon olah). The Gemara uses an
analogy to explain the need for the additional burnt offering. If one sins
against the king and is subsequently forgiven, although a claim against him
no longer exists, he is still not in the good graces of the king. He can
only reach full reinstatement when he offers a gift to the king.
Identically, when one brings a sin offering it brings about atonement;
however, full reinstatement is not achieved until the burnt offering is
brought. As much a Jew may do teshuvah, he will not regain an intimate
relationship with G-d without the merit of the Patriarchs.
The Patriarchs were able to achieve a unique level of intimacy with G-d
because of their spiritual accomplishments. When one mentions them in the
course of tefillah (prayer), one identifies with the Patriarchs and
consequently Hashem is more attentive to his prayers. Without their merit,
it is not possible to attain that special level of intimacy with Hashem.
The Torah tells us that despite the failings of the Jewish people, they
were not considered "detestable, or despicable to be destroyed and to have
the covenant of the Patriarchs nullified." How has this been demonstrated
throughout our history?
The Gemara in Tractate Megillah tells us that despite the fact many of the
Jewish people were Helenized and assimilated during the time of the Greek
occupation, Hashem did not abandon them. When the Jews were in Babylon,
many of them assimilated and intermarried; Hashem did not abandon
them. After the destruction of the Second Temple by the Romans, the Jews
were not cast away. This was demonstrated by sending Reb Yehudah HaNassi
(Judah the Prince) and Torah sages throughout the generations to the Jewish
In fact, the only reason the Jewish people have been able to survive
spiritually throughout the Edomite (Roman) exile, is that they were sent
these Torah luminaries. Since G-d provided special individuals, who
guaranteed the perpetuation and dissemination of the Torah, it is an
indication that He does not want His covenant to be nullified. Despite the
failings of the Jewish people, G-d did not abandon them. However, it is due
to the merit of the Patriarchs that the Jewish people have that special
standing vis-à-vis Hashem.
The Maharal of Prague explains that the reason G-d's law (Five Books of
Moses) is referred to as "Torah" by G-d Himself, is to indicate (as the
meaning of the word implies) that it is meant to be a guide to direct and
give perspective to the Jewish people. Hashem provides the Torah sage in
order to transmit and communicate the Torah throughout all the generations,
thus, confirming that the covenant of the Patriarchs is still intact.
6. The Foundation of Torah Judaism
As a precursor to the curses (tochachah), the Torah states, "If you will
not listen to Me and will not perform all of these commandments; if you
consider My Statutes (Chukim) loathsome and if your being rejects My
ordinances (Mishpatim)...so that you annul My covenant - then I will do the
same to you..." Why would one loathe the Chukim, which are laws that
cannot be understood on rational basis, and not all the laws that were
transmitted at Sinai?
During the era of the Greeks, circumcision, the sanctification of the new
moon, the observance of the Shabbos, and the study of Torah were
banned. The Greek civilization prided itself in its intellectualism and
appreciation for nature and its beauty. Yefes, the son of Noach, is the
patriarch of the Greek people. He received a blessing from his father
Noach that he should "dwell in the tents of Shem." The tent of Shem is
referring to the wisdom of Torah and its intellectualism. The Greeks had
an appreciation of the intellectualism of the Jew; however, they had
difficulty with its limitation because it is bound by the parameters of the
Torah. Within the framework of Torah the depth and breadth of wisdom is
infinite. Although there are many practices and concepts in the Torah,
which are not within the human grasp, nevertheless, the Jew accepts them
unequivocally because of his absolute belief in G-d. This is demonstrated
through the acceptance of the Chok (Statute).
Although existence is bound by time, by Divine order, the Jewish people are
able to sanctify and control time through the sanctification of the new
moon. One can only accept this reality if one accepts G-d as the
Absolute Omnipotent Being. The Greeks could not accept anything unless it
was something they were able to comprehend within their own capacity. The
concept of the human being affecting time was something beyond their
comprehension and thus intolerable. The Greeks therefore decreed that the
sanctification of the new moon was forbidden.
A male is naturally born with a foreskin/uncircumcised. The Greeks
believed that the uncircumcised state, being part of the natural order,
should be appreciated and recognized as part of the perfection and beauty
of the human body. Contrastingly, G-d commanded the Jew to remove that
foreskin through circumcision because it is only through that act man can
achieve perfection. The act of circumcision is classified as a
Chok. There is no rational basis for its understanding. Since the Greeks
viewed the human body as naturally perfect, circumcision was seen as an act
of mutilation. Thus, they forbade circumcision.
The mitzvah of charity for example is a commandment that is embraced even
in the secular world only because it is understood as rational and
humanitarian. However, Chukim such as circumcision, dietary laws, and the
observance of the Shabbos are seen as archaic and primitive
practices. Therefore, they are loathed. Since the Chok is
incomprehensible, it is loathed and rejected, which is not the case
regarding Mishpatim (rational laws). In essence, loathing the Chukim is
rejecting G-d's Will.
One who initially loathes the Chukim will ultimately come to despise the
Mishpatim as well. Rational laws such as not stealing, not killing, etc.
are accepted by the secularist because they are perceived as moral,
ethical, and humanistic. However, these laws were given by G-d at Sinai
and the Jew accepts them not because of their humanitarian aspect but
solely because they are G-d's Dictate. Thus, in essence, even the
Mishpatim are not accepted because of rational understanding but because
they are the Will of Hashem. If Mishpatim were to be based on human
reasoning, then it would be possible to justify euthanasia. Thus, the
Mishpatim would ultimately be rejected and despised because they are
contrary to one's intellectualism.
To serve G-d selflessly, one must understand that not everything is
comprehensible. Man is finite and limited and therefore there are many
areas that are not within the human grasp. If one believes that G-d is the
Omnipotent Being, there is no basis for not accepting and adhering to the
Chukim that are His Will. The moment one has difficulty accepting the
Chukim because he "does not understand," it is an indication that his
weakness lies in his understanding of G-d. As long as one is unequivocally
committed to the Statutes, the path to spiritual growth and development is
open before him.
Copyright © 2003 by Rabbi Yosef Kalatsky and Project Genesis, Inc.
Rabbi Kalatsky is the founder of the Yad Avraham Institute, a New York-based learning center whose mission is to disseminate Torah to Jews of all backgrounds and walks of life.