Parshas Beshalach
Lessons in Appreciation
Rabbi Yosef Kalatsky
1. Appreciating the Wisdom of a Wise Man
Before Yosef passed away he made his brothers take an oath that when they
leave Egypt they should take his remains with them. The Torah states,
"Moshe took the bones of Yosef with him..." In fact, Moshe was the only one
who sought out the remains of Yosef in order to take them out of
Egypt. Shlomo Ha'Melech (King Solomon) in Mishlei states,"A wise heart
takes mitzvos." The Gemara in Sotah explains that this is referring to
Moshe Rabbeinu. The reason Moshe searched for the remains of Yosef while
the other Jews were preoccupied with borrowing the gold and silver vessels
from the Egyptians was that he had "a wise heart." Although it was a
Mitzvah to borrow the personal effects of the Egyptians as G-d commanded
them, Moshe chose to seek out the remains of Yosef because he had a wise heart.
Moshe understood that without locating the remains of Yosef, the Jews would
not be able to leave Egypt, regardless of all the miracles that had taken
place. If this is the case, then it should have been an obvious priority
for every Jew to seek out Yosef's remains. If so, then why did it take
special wisdom to do so? Every Jew, even ones without that special wisdom,
should have understood this.
The Mishna in Pirkei Avos states, "Who is a wise man - The one who sees the
outgrowth of his actions (or other events)." The question is why does the
Mishna state that the wise man is the one who "sees" rather than the one
who "understands" the outgrowth of his actions or other events? The answer
is - understanding is something conceptual. It is something that is
abstract and not tangible. However, if one "sees" the consequences and the
outgrowths of one's actions, it is something that is real and concrete.
Therefore, one deals with this reality differently because it seems tangible.
The Chacham (one who is wise) is a dimension of person who not only
realizes what the future will bring based on the present but one who
"knows" what the future will bring. Therefore, he deals with the future as
the present. For example, if one sees fire and knows that it burns, he
will not act irresponsibly by extending his hand into it; however, if he
only conceptually believes that fire will burn, then it is possible based
on one's conflicts, to justify extending his hand into the fire because its
destructiveness is not a reality.
Shlomo Ha'Melech depicts Moshe as the "Chacham lev - the wise of heart"
because he could not rely on anyone but himself to locate the remains of
Yosef. The possibility of not locating it was a reality for Moshe because
it would mean that the Jews would not be redeemed. However, all the others
who did not have this wisdom of the heart only related to that possibility
on a conceptual basis. Therefore, their priority was to engage in what was
tangible to them - the silver and gold vessels. Their view was that
someone would attend to Yosef's remains. However, Moshe' perspective was
that this could not be left to chance because of the grave possibility that
the Jews would not be redeemed. He understood that they were at their
lowest point - the 49th level of spiritual contamination. If the Jews
remained in Egypt for a moment longer than they were intended to, they
would have become spiritually extinct. Thus, there would not be a Jewish
people or a Sinai. All existence hinged on the remains of Yosef being
located and removed within the proper timeframe.
The Torah tells us that Avraham Our Patriarch trusted his faithful servant
Eliezer with all of his material assets. Despite his enormous wealth, he
trusted Eliezer implicitly. Eliezer was not only astute as the
administrator of his master's estate but he was also spiritualized to the
point of having a similar radiance as his master Avraham. When Avraham
chose Eliezer as the person to locate a wife for his son Yitzchak (who
would be the future Matriarch), he bound him by an oath to take a proper
wife from Avraham's family and not from the daughters of Canaan. If Eliezer
violated this oath, he would forfeit his share in the world to come.
The question is if Avraham had such a level of faith in his servant that he
was entrusted with his fortune, then why when it came to choosing a proper
wife for Yitzchak did he make him take an oath? The answer is - although it
was unlikely that Eliezer would defy the order of his master, when it came
to the spiritual future of the Jewish people, Avraham made him swear. He
"saw" the consequence of what would happen should the proper wife for
Yitzchak, a matriarch of the Jewish people, not be chosen. Therefore, it
was not something he would leave to chance. This is because Avraham had
wisdom of the heart.
When Hashem told Avraham that he would father a child at the age of 99 from
Sarah, the Torah tells us that he rejoiced. Hashem valued this belief as
righteousness for Avraham. However, when Sarah was informed that she was
going to have a child she chuckled. She had a momentary flicker of
doubt. The question is why was Avraham able to rejoice although he at that
age was no longer able to father a child? The answer is because Avraham was
a man who had wisdom of the heart; he "saw" Hashem's Word as a
reality. Therefore, he rejoiced and Sarah did not.
2. The Attribute of Truth is a Key Element in Prayer
The Torah tells us that after the Jewish people left Egypt, the Egyptians
pursued them to the Sea. The Torah states, "Pharaoh approached; the
Children of Yisroel raised their eyes and behold! - Egypt was journeying
after them, and they were frightened; the Children of Yisroel cried out to
Hashem." It is clearly indicated from this verse that the Jewish people
believed that it was within the power of Hashem to save them from the hands
of the Egyptians. As it is stated, "and they cried out to Hashem." However,
the next statement expressed by the Jews seems contradictory. In the
following verse the Torah states, "They said to Moshe, "Were there no
graves in Egypt that you took us to die in the Wilderness?" On one hand the
Jewish people prayed to Hashem (indicating their firm belief), and yet they
spoke to Moshe as if they were heretics, blaming him for taking them out of
Egypt to die in the wilderness. How do we understand this?
Rashi cites Chazal who explain that the verse - "they cried out to Hashem"
to mean that Jewish people took hold of the "craft" of their forefathers
Avraham, Yitzchak, and Yaakov. Just as the Patriarchs prayed to Hashem at
various times of need, so too did the Jewish people pray to Hashem at this
perilous moment. If the Jewish people truly believed in tefillah (prayer)
as their forefathers did, then why did they immediately complain to Moshe
about their imminent destruction? The Ramban explains that the Jewish
people prayed; however, when Hashem did not immediately respond to them
they came to Moshe with their claim. Rashi uses the term they took hold of
the "craft" of their forefathers to indicate that they did not pray with
the level of conviction and belief in Hashem as their forefathers had
done. They merely mimicked the behavior of the Patriarchs by praying in a
time of need.
The Jewish people did not truly understand or appreciate tefillah nor did
they have relevance to it at this moment. They had just emerged from being
idol worshippers in Egypt. However, they were aware of the blessing that
Yitzchak had given to his son Yaakov, "Ha'Kol kol Yaakov - the voice is the
voice of Yaakov." This indicates that the power of tefillah (prayer)
belongs to Yaakov and his decedents. Tefillah is the weapon of the Jew;
however, there are certain criteria necessary to give it effectiveness.
What are these criteria? They include the characteristic of self-negation
combined with the belief and understanding of tefillah which make it
effective. The Jewish people prayed because they knew the Patriarchs had
done so. However, they did not have the self-negation or the belief that
was possessed by the Patriarchs. Therefore, Hashem did not respond to their
prayers immediately and this caused them to complain to Moshe.
We say every day in the Ashrei (the Psalm that is said three times a day),
"Hashem is close to all who call upon Him - to all who call upon Him
truthfully (b'emes)." On a literal level, one would understand this to
mean that when one calls out to Hashem sincerely, He will be close to
him. If Hashem is close, then He will respond. On a deeper level, one can
understand this verse to mean that Hashem is close to those who possess
Emes (truth). If one lives a life of Emes (truth), which is consistent
with what is dictated by the Torah then this causes Hashem to be close and
to respond. The Gemara in Tractate Shabbos tells us "the signet of Hashem
is Emes." Therefore, if a person possesses this attribute then he has a
commonality with Hashem, thus causing Hashem to be close to him. However,
if one lacks integrity and is not true to what he understands and believes,
then he does not possess the attribute of Emes and Hashem will not be close
to him.
The ultimate truth -Emes- is Torah. As it is written in Mishlei, "Acquire
truth and do not sell it." The Gemara in Tractate Avodah Zarah explains
that the acquisition of truth is referring to Torah, which is
unadulterated. The Prophet states, "Teetain Emes L'Yaakov - Give truth to
Yaakov." Yaakov, our Patriarch, is identified as the "man of truth"
because he was the man of Torah. Therefore, one can understand why the
weapon of Yaakov was his tefillah- "Ha'Kol kol Yaakov - the voice is the
voice of Yaakov." If one possesses Emes, then his voice truly reflects the
voice of Yaakov.
The Gemara tells us in a number of locations that Hashem created the yetzer
ha'rah (the evil inclination) and Torah as its antidote. Meaning, one is
able to counter and neutralize the evil inclination with Torah study. The
Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh explains that this is true only if one studies Torah
"l'shmah- with the proper intent (which is study of Torah for its own
sake)." If one studies Torah with the proper intent then it defuses the
evil inclination and acts as an antidote. However, if a person studies
Torah with an ulterior motive, then the person's involvement in the mitzvah
is lacking integrity. He is studying it for his own sake and not for the
Torah itself. Therefore, since he is lacking in Emes, his Torah study is
not an effective antidote against the evil inclination just as prayer is
not effective if one is lacking in Emes.
We say at the conclusion of the Amidah (silent prayer), " May it be Your
will Hashem...that the Holy Temple be rebuilt, speedily in our days, Grant
us a share in Your Torah, and may we serve You there with reverence, as in
the days of old..." First, we beseech Hashem to rebuild the Bais HaMikdash
and then we ask Him to give us a portion of His Torah, which is the means
by which one identifies with Emes. Only when we possess truth are we able
to serve Hashem with reverence, as in the days of old. We reinstate the
commonality with Hashem through Torah, which is truth. At the sea, since
the tefillah of the Jewish people was lacking in the quality of Emes,
Hashem did not respond immediately to their outcries. Their commitment to
tefillah was only as a "craft" of their forefathers.
3. When Does One Truly Fear G-d?
Hashem split the Sea and enabled the Jewish people to cross
safely. Afterwards, Hashem closed it on Pharaoh and his army. The Torah
states, "On that day, Hashem saved Yisroel from the hand of Egypt, and
Yisroel saw the Egyptians dead on the seashore. Yisroel saw the great Hand
of Hashem that inflicted upon Egypt; and the people feared Hashem, and they
had faith in Hashem and Moshe, His servant."
Rashi cites Chazal who explain that when the Sea closed on the Egyptians,
the Jewish people were concerned that perhaps they were not destroyed and
that they came up on the other side and would continue to pursue them. In
order to alleviate their fears and concerns, the Torah states, "Yisroel saw
the Egyptians dead on the seashore..." This indicated that Hashem had
performed a miracle by causing the Sea to cast the remains of the Egyptians
onto the seashore. The Torah tells us that only after the Jewish people
saw the Egyptian remains on the seashore did they "fear Hashem" and had
"faith in Him and Moshe his servant." It is difficult to understand why
the Jewish people only feared Hashem after they saw the destruction of the
Egyptians. They had already witnessed revealed miracles such as the ten
plagues. They experienced the splitting of the Sea, which was the greatest
miracle of them all which even caused the pagan nations of the world to
tremble in fear of Hashem. The Midrash tells us that the level of
revelation experienced by the maidservant at the Sea was greater than that
of Yechezkel the prophet. So why did they fear Hashem only after seeing
that their oppressors no longer lived? How do we understand this?
The Torah is teaching us something profound - that as much as one
recognizes the omnipotence of Hashem (even at a level that is greater than
Yechezkel the prophet), if one fears anyone other than Hashem, then he does
not truly fear Him. If one fully comprehends and internalizes the reality
of who G-d is, then he has no reason to fear anyone. Nothing can happen to
him that is not the Will of Hashem. It was only when the Jewish people no
longer feared the Egyptians (because they were destroyed in the Sea) that
they were able to fear Hashem. We also can understand from the verse,
"they had faith in Hashem..." (only subsequent to the destruction of the
Egyptians) that one does not have sufficient clarity to have "faith in
Hashem" unless all distractions are removed. As long as the Jewish people
were distracted by the existence of the Egyptians, they were blocked from
fully internalizing who G-d was. Therefore, they could not have complete
faith and reverence for Him.
The reason a person fears anything is because he believes and feels that
his life or his predicament is dependent on that which he fears. However,
if one has faith that Hashem totally dictates one's existence, then there
is no reason to fear anyone other than Him. Thus, if one does fear someone
other than Hashem, it is a deficiency in his faith.
In the Portion of Mishpatim, the Torah tells us that every Jew has an
obligation to visit the Temple Mount (Bais HaMikdash) three times a year on
the festivals and "see the Presence of the Master, Hashem." The Gemara in
Tractate Chagigah discusses a case of a Canaanite slave who had two masters
and was subsequently emancipated by one of them. As a result of this
emancipation, half of him is considered a full Jew who has all the
obligations of the Torah incumbent upon him. The other half of this
individual (the part owned by the master) retains the Canaanite slave
status (he is only bound by the mitzvos of a woman).
Since half of him is fully obligated in all the mitzvos, one would think
that perhaps such an individual would be obligated to visit the Bais
HaMikdash and "see the Presence of the Master, Hashem". However, the Gemara
tells us that even though half of him is fully obligated in the mitzvos, he
is absolved from visiting the Temple Mount. The reason for this is that
this mitzvah entails going to "see the presence of the Master, Hashem,"
indicating that the individual who has one master is obliged to go, not the
one who has two. If one has a master other than Hashem, he cannot fully
appreciate and internalize Hashem, who is the Master. Therefore, the
half-Jew/half-slave is exempt from visiting the Temple Mount.
The degree one reveres and fears Hashem is determined by the concerns and
trepidations that one has in his life.
4. To what Standard is One Held?
The Torah states after the Jewish people crossed the Sea to safety, "Moshe
caused Yisroel to journey from the Sea of Reeds and they went out to the
Wilderness of Shur; they went for a three-day period in the Wilderness, but
they did not find water. They came to Marah, but they could not drink the
waters of Marah because they were bitter...The people complained against
Moshe saying, "What shall we drink?" ...There He (Hashem) ....tested them."
Rashi cites Chazal who explain that Hashem "tested" the Jewish people in
Marah and He saw how "stiff-necked" they were because when they spoke with
Moshe they did not address him in a respectful manner. Rather than
complaining to Moshe, the Jewish people should have asked him to pray on
their behalf to Hashem for water. The Jews failed the test, which
demonstrated that they are a "stiff-necked" people. The question is - why
only in Marah was it considered a test and their failing proved that they
were a stiff-necked people? Why was it not considered a test when they
were at the shore of the Sea and complained?
When the Jewish people were pursued by the Egyptians to the Sea, they said
to Moshe, "Were there no graves in Egypt that you took us to die in the
Wilderness?" Soon after the Sea split and the Jewish people crossed to
safety. The Jewish people demonstrated the identical failing which was
shown later in Marah vis-à-vis Moshe. Rather than saying to Moshe "why did
you take us into the desert to die" the Jews should have said, "pray to G-d
so that He should save us." This is something they did not do. Before Moshe
passed away, he recounted all the failings of the Jewish people over the
forty-year period from the time of the exodus from Egypt. One of the
failings that he mentioned was how the Jews had lacked in faith before the
splitting of the Sea and thus complained - "were there not sufficient
graves in Egypt..." If this is the case then why was it not considered a
failing of a test, which proved that the Jews were a stiff-necked people?
How do we understand this?
The Jews initially complained to Moshe by saying, "Were there no graves in
Egypt that you took us to die in the Wilderness?" This was before they had
witnessed the splitting of the Sea. Although they had seen the plagues in
Egypt, which were clearly identified as the Hand of G-d, nevertheless, they
had not yet achieved the level of spirituality that they reached after the
Sea was split. The Torah states, "They believed in Hashem and Moshe His
servant," which did not precede the splitting of the Sea. There was no
comparison between the level of revelation during the period of the plagues
and the revelation of Hashem at the time of the splitting of the Sea. Thus,
once the Jewish people reached this advanced level of belief, how could
they address Moshe in the inappropriate way that they had done in
Marah? As a result of the splitting of the Sea, they understood who Moshe
was and instead, should have asked him to pray for them. However, this was
not the case. They complained and thus failed the test. This was
considered a failure because they already understood that Moshe was the
servant of Hashem and therefore they should have behaved differently
towards him.
Those who are less learned in Torah are less culpable than those who are
learned. This implies that those who have an advanced level of
understanding are more culpable. Thus, if one behaves in a manner that is
not consistent with his level of understanding, then it is considered a
serious failing. Although it was considered a failing and a lack of faith
for the Jewish people to complain to Moshe before the splitting of the Sea,
it was not considered a failure nor did it indicate that they were
stiff-necked people. However, after the splitting of the Sea, (when they
understood who Moshe truly was) the appropriate thing would have been for
them to ask him to pray on their behalf. Since they did not, it is
considered that they failed the test and demonstrated that they are a
stiff-necked people.
The Torah states, "Hashem spoke to Moshe saying,' Take vengeance for the
Children of Israel against the Midianites; afterward you will be gathered
unto your people (Moshe will pass away).'" Rashi cites Chazal who say that
despite the fact that Moshe understood that he was going to pass away after
fulfilling the commandment to destroy the Midianites, "he nevertheless
performed the Mitzvah with joy and he did not delay." If Moshe had decided
not to act immediately upon the dictate of Hashem, he would have extended
his life. The Midrash tells us that Moshe's immediate response to the
dictate of Hashem without considering its consequences makes him
"praiseworthy." Meaning, even a person as great as Moshe is considered
praiseworthy for making this decision despite all of the reasons to delay.
The Midrash continues -Yehoshua Bin Nun, the disciple and successor of
Moshe Rabbeinu led the Jewish people into the Land of Israel. Upon entry,
Hashem commanded him to conquer the land and divide it among the tribes and
then he will pass away. Understanding that his passing was going to be
determined by when his mission was completed, Yehoshua chose to delay. His
justification was that as long as he was alive the Jews would not succumb
to idol worship. Nevertheless, Yehoshua had ten years taken from his life.
The Midrash tells us that initially he was meant to live 120 years like his
Rebbe, Moshe.
The difficulty is that if Chazal tell us that even for a person as great as
Moshe Rabbeinu that his decision (not to delay) was considered
praiseworthy, it indicates that if he had chosen to delay it would not have
been considered a claim against him. So, why was Yehoshua held accountable
for his decision to delay the conquest and division of the Land? How do we
understand this?
The answer is that although the decision not to delay the battle with the
Midianites was considered "praiseworthy" even for a person as great as
Moshe Rabbeinu, despite all the considerations, Moshe's decision to ignore
all the considerations establishes precedence. When G-d gives a dictate,
one must attend to it immediately without any delay. Therefore, Yehoshua
should have followed the precedent that was set by Moshe Rabbeinu. He
should not have delayed regardless of how pure his intent may have been.
This failing was the cause his early passing.
A person is only held to a standard that is consistent with his own level
of understanding. Therefore, if one understands how to behave and does not,
it is considered that he has failed.
5. The Evolution of the Spirituality of the Jewish people
The Torah tells us that one of the four expressions of redemption that
Hashem related to Moshe was, "V'lakachti lachem li l'am - I will take you
for Myself to be My people and I will be your G-d (Elokim)." This
expression of redemption is referring to the Sinai experience when the
Jewish people became the Am Hashem (the Nation of G-d). At Sinai, we find
that the Jewish people are referred to as "mamleches kohanim v'goy kadosh -
a kingly priestly holy people." The Jewish people did not immediately
ascend to that level, but rather it was a progression.
Initially when Hashem sent Moshe to tell Pharaoh to release the Jewish
people from bondage, He said to Moshe "Tell Pharaoh... Release My son, My
firstborn (Beni Bechori)." Hashem identifies the Jewish people as his
first-born child, which signifies that it is the most intimate
relationship, as between a father and his son. The first-born son is the
most special to his father. The relationship of a father and his son is not
the same as that of a king and his subjects.
Subsequently, the Torah tells us that Hashem said to Moshe "Tell Pharaoh in
My Name Shlach Ami - Send out My people." This verse identifies the Jewish
People as "My People." Meaning, that at this moment the relationship
between G-d and the Jewish people was: King to subject. The nature of this
relationship is that the subject is selflessly dedicated to do the will of
the master and the master is dedicated to provide for the subject. The
relationship between G-d and the Jewish people has a duality; on one hand,
the relationship is father (Avinu) to son, but at the same time, the son
must recognize that the father is the master (malkeinu). Thus, the son must
be dedicated to doing His will. Even before the Exodus, the Jewish people
had established themselves as G-d's people and G-d's children. However,
regarding Sinai, the Jewish people are referred to as "mamleches kohanim
v'goy kadosh - a kingly priestly holy people." As a result of the receiving
the Torah at Sinai, which is accepting Hashem as their G-d, the Jewish
people became sanctified. This established the status of Kedushas Yisroel
- the sanctity of the Jewish People.
In Egypt, the Jewish people were devoid of mitzvos, as the verse in
Yechezkel states, "and you are naked (devoid of spirituality)." As pagans
in Egypt, the Jewish people had no relevance to spirituality and were no
different from the Egyptians. Then Hashem gave them two mitzvos: the
mitzvah of milah (circumcision) and the mitzvah of Korban Pesach (the
Pascal Lamb Offering). Circumcision is the "sign that is engraved in our
flesh." It is the manner in which the Jew identifies with G-d, as the Torah
refers to circumcision, "ohs bris kodesh - the sign of the Holy
Covenant." The bris milah is something that is part of a Jew's physicality
and cannot be removed. Concerning the mitzvah of the Korban Pesach, the
lamb/goat was an Egyptian deity. Thus, the significance of slaughtering it
was the rejection of idolatry.
After the Jewish people were circumcised and they sacrificed the Korban
Pesach, they reached a point where they developed the capacity for
kedushah. (Sanctification). Thus, the Commandment that follows is, "Kodesh
Li Kol Bachor - Sanctify for Me all the first born sons." At this point
Hashem sanctified the bachor (first born) of the Jewish people because the
bachor shares a commonality with Him. Just as Hashem is the Rishon the
First (and Only), who is the essence of all that is holy, so too is the
first born - who shares that characteristic. The sanctity of the bachor is
innate to who he is. However, the sanctification of the Jewish people as a
whole Kedushas Yisroel ) was not able to take place until Sinai.
Kedushas Yisroel was only bestowed upon the Jewish people at Sinai.
Although they were considered "G-d's people" (even before the Exodus - as
it is stated "Shalch Ami"), at that moment they had no relevance to
kedushah. This is explicit in the verse, "V'lakachti lachem li l'am - I
will take you for Myself to be My people and I will be your G-d
(Elokim)." It was only when the Jewish people ascended to the level of
accepting Hashem as their G-d, "Elokim," could they be sanctified. This
could not have taken place if there were any spiritual impediments.
Hashem identified the Jews as His people before Sinai. However,
identification as "a holy and priestly nation" only occurred at Sinai. Why
could He not bestow this new status upon the Jewish people before the
Exodus? Rashi at the beginning in the Portion of Yisro explains that the
greatest miracle of Egypt (even more than all the plagues) was that the
Jewish people were able to leave Egypt. The difficulty is, after Egypt was
devastated through the plagues, and the Jews were asked to leave - why was
the Exodus itself the greatest miracle? The Egyptian people literally
drove the Jews out of Egypt in order to stop the death that was brought
upon them. Ramchal (in his work Derech Hashem) explains that the Jewish
people, as a result of their bondage in Egypt, were so infected with
spiritual contamination that they had virtually no capacity to internalize
and have any sense of spirituality.
When Hashem took the Jews out of Egypt, He purged all of their impurities
and gave them a capacity to relate to and be receptive to kedushah. In
Egypt, it was impossible for the Jewish people as a whole to attain
sanctity (Kedushas Yisroel).
6. The Value of Being Appreciative
The Torah states, "The Children of Israel were armed (chamushim) when they
went up from Egypt." Rashi cites Chazal who explain the word "chamushim"
to mean that only one fifth of the Jewish people left Egypt and four fifths
perished during the days of darkness. In the Portion of Bo, Rashi cites
Chazal who explain that the reason four fifths of the Jewish people
perished during the plague of darkness was so that the Egyptians should not
witness the demise of the evil ones among the Jewish people (those who did
not want to leave Egypt). It was important that the Egyptians should be
unaware of the destruction of four fifths of the Jews because they would
say that the Jewish people were dying as they were. Hashem wanted the
Egyptians to understand that it was only they who were being punished.
The Midrash Tanchuma offers another interpretation as to why the Jews who
were evil died during the days of darkness. The Jews who survived the days
of darkness praised and offered thanks to Hashem for not allowing the
Egyptians to be aware of the demise of the Jews who perished during
darkness because the Egyptians would have rejoiced over their death. The
question is - why is it important for Chazal to inform us that the Jews who
survived the days of darkness gave thanks and praise to Hashem for not
allowing the Egyptians to witness the demise of the evil Jews?
It is difficult to understand. If all the Jews in Egypt witnessed the
revealed miracles, which clearly identified the Hand of Hashem- how is it
possible that the vast majority of the Jewish people did not want to leave
Egypt? As it is stated, "v'chamushim - only one fifth left Egypt." It is
clear that there was a fundamental difference between these two groups of
Jews. One group possessed a characteristic and quality that allowed them
to fully appreciate and internalize the events that they had
witnessed. However, the other group did not possess this quality.
The most fundamental quality an individual needs in order to be able to
recognize and understand situations correctly is "ha'karas ha'tov-
recognition of the good." If a person has the ability to recognize that he
is the beneficiary of some one else's kindness then he is able to
appreciate and understand his benefactor. However, if the person does not
have the capacity to view himself as the beneficiary of someone else's
kindness then he is always suspect of his benefactor's motive. Thus, he
remains untrusting.
Despite the tragedy of the destruction of four fifths of the Jewish people,
the one fifth that survived gave thanks and praise to Hashem for not
allowing the Egyptians to rejoice in the demise of the evil Jews who did
not want to leave Egypt. One would think that those who survived were
overwhelmed with their grief and could not think of anything but attending
to the burial needs of those who died. Nevertheless, the Midrash tells us
that despite the tragedy that had befallen them, they saw Hashem's kindness
and thus offered thanks and praise to Him. Because of this quality of
ha'karas ha'tov, they were truly able to appreciate Hashem's concern for
them. Therefore when they witnessed the miracles and the destruction of
Egypt, they were fully trusting that this was only to bring about their
redemption. If a person has the quality of ha'karas ha'tov, he will then
have relevance to spirituality because he is able to process the events of
his life in a way where he sees the goodness of Hashem.
The Gemara tells us that Dovid Ha'Melech (King David) promulgated that
every Jew should recite at least 100 brachos (blessings) every day. Dovid
Ha'Melech enacted this in response to ending a plague that had befallen the
Jewish people. Initially he did not understand why they were deserving of
this punishment. However, he finally realized that it was because the Jews
were beneficiaries of Hashem's sustenance and kindness but did not
acknowledge this fact. Thus, Dovid Ha'Melech and his Bais Din (Rabbinic
Court) enacted that every Jew should say 100 brachos every day, which
caused the plague to cease. The 100 brachos encompassed every aspect of
our existence.
For example, the brachos we recite each morning articulate our
acknowledgement that Hashem allows us to stand erectly, gives us the
ability to see, and provides the amenities that are necessary such as
clothing the naked etc. It is irrelevant how much wealth a person may
have; the fact that he able to cloth his own nakedness is only because
Hashem is his provider. It is not that we thank Hashem for the luxuries of
life, but we must acknowledge Him for the bare necessities. People take
these things for granted. Everything in life is a manifestation of the
kindness of Hashem and we are the beneficiaries of His kindness. Therefore,
we must be beholden and thank Hashem for everything we have. If one is able
to recognize and appreciate this fact then one is humbled because he
understands who he is not.
Copyright © 2003 by Rabbi Yosef Kalatsky and Project Genesis, Inc.
Rabbi Kalatsky is the founder of the Yad Avraham Institute, a New York-based learning center whose mission is to disseminate Torah to Jews of all backgrounds and walks of life.