Parshas Behar - Bechukosai
... But Were Afraid To Ask
Volume 2 Issue 31
by Rabbi Mordechai Kamenetzky
The Torah does not usually leave room for official questions of faith. It
tells us, in no uncertain terms, what our responsibilities are and the
commitment we must make to be observant Jews. Every mitzvah entails
sacrifice. Sometimes it requires a monetary commitment, sometimes a
commitment of time and morals. Not often does it consider the human trials
one encounters in mitzvah performance. They are our problem and we must
deal with them as human beings and as Jews.
Yet this week the Torah uncharacteristically provides leeway for those who
may waver in their commitment.
In Parshas Behar the Torah charges the Jewish people with the laws of
shmittah. Every seventh year, we are told that the land of Israel is to lie
fallow. No work is to be done with the earth. There is not to be a harvest,
nor may the ground be sown or reaped.
Observing shmittah is a true test of faith. Imagine! One must not harvest
his grain but instead rely on pure faith for his daily fare. Yet the Torah
does not leave us with the austere command. The Torah deals directly with
the human emotion related to the issue. In Leviticus 25:20 the Torah
foretells a human side. "And if you will say in your heart, 'what shall we
eat in the seventh year, behold the land has not been sown nor has it been
reaped?'" Hashem reassures the people that His bounty will abound in the
sixth year and they will live the seventh year in comfort.
This is not the only time the Torah realizes human wariness. In reference
to the command of conquering the Land of Canaan, the Torah states in
Deuteronomy 7:17: "Perhaps you shall say in your heart, 'these nations are
more numerous than me. How will I drive them out?'" Once again Hashem
reassures His nation that He will not forsake them.
The question is glaring. Why does the Torah answer to human psyche? Why
doesn't the Torah just command us to let the land lie fallow, or conquer
the Land of Canaan? If there are problems or fears in our hearts, they are
our problems. Those fears should not be incorporated as part of the command.
Isidore would meet his friend Irving every other week while doing business.
"How are you Irving?" Isidore would always ask. "How's the wife and kids?"
Irv would always grunt back the perfunctory replies. "Fine." "A little
under the weather." "My son Jack got a job."
This one sided interrogation went on for years until one day Isidore
exploded. "Irv," he said abruptly. "I don't understand. For six years I ask
you about your wife, your kids, and your business. Not once mind you, not
once did you ever ask me about my wife, my kids, or my business!
Irv shrugged. "Sorry, Izzie. I was really selfish. So tell me," he
continued, "how is your wife? How are your kids? How is your business?"
Izzie let out a sigh of anguish and began to krechts. He put his hand
gently on Irv's shoulder, tightened his lips, and shook his head slowly.
Reb Leible Eiger (1816-1888) explains that there are many questions of
faith that we may have. The faithful may in fact fear the fact that there
is fear. "Is it a flaw in faith to worry?" "Am I committing heresy by
fearing the enemy?" "Am I allowed to ask?" The Torah tells us in two
places, "you will have these questions. You will ask, 'how am I going to
sustain myself and family?' "You will worry," 'how will I conquer my
enemies?' 'Will I be destroyed?'" The Torah reassures us that there is no
lack of trust by asking those questions. We mustn't get down on ourselves
and consider questions a breach of faith. Life and sustenance are mortal
attributes. They warrant mortal fear.
Adam, the first man was originally blessed with eternal life without having
to worry for his livelihood. After sinning, he was cursed with death and
was told that he would eat by the sweat of his brow. The Torah assures us
that it is not only human but also acceptable to worry about these two
issues -- one's livelihood and survival, as long as we believe in the
reassurances about those worries.
Copyright © 1997 by Rabbi M. Kamenetzky and Project Genesis, Inc.
If you enjoy the weekly Drasha, now you can receive the best of Drasha in book form!
- from the Project Genesis bookstore - Genesis Judaica - at a very special price!
The author is the Associate Dean of the
Yeshiva of South Shore.
Drasha is the e-mail edition of FaxHomily, a weekly torah facsimile on the weekly portion
which is sponsored by The Henry and Myrtle Hirsch Foundation