Volume 5 Issue 36
by Rabbi Mordechai Kamenetzky
The Book of Numbers begins with -- of course -- numbers. In fact, it
begins with many numbers! Moshe is told by Hashem to "Count the entire
assembly of the Children of Israel.. by number of the names, every male
according to their headcount." (Numbers 1:3) but no apparent reason is
offered. There was no road infrastructure that had to be built, they were
in a desert. There was no housing development plan that had to be
assessed, they lived in sukkos. And there was no need to calculate
agricultural concerns, food was sent from Heaven. So why did Hashem want
And the recorded numbers seem to have no bearing on any moral issue that is
necessary for us as Twentieth Century Jews. Does it truly matter that the
tribe of Gad had 45,650 males over twenty or or that the tribe of Menashe
had 32,200? And the customary Haftorah for this week* tells us that "the
number of the Children of Israel will be like the sand of the sea, which
can neither be measured or counted" (Hosea 2:1). So why count?
[* This year, the customary Haftorah is superceded by that for the eve of
the New Month, as the month of Sivan begins Sunday.]
At the outset of his career as a journalist, Walter Cronkite worked as a
copy editor for the Houston Chronicle. His boss, city editor Roy Rousell,
was a stickler for detail and accuracy, who would raise a ruckus for the
slightest error or inaccuracy. There was a price to pay if a Mr. Smythe
was spelled as Mr. Smith.
Cronkite was responsible for a two-line item carried every day on the front
page of the final edition, "Bank Clearings." Each day a small line simply
read, "Today's Houston bank clearings were," followed by a large monetary
One day Rousell called him into his office. He was clearly enraged. "You
had the bank clearings all wrong yesterday," he snarled. His jaw was
clenched. Cronkite had the clearings at $3,726,359.27, the correct amount
was $3,726,359.17. He was off by ten cents, but the city editor was
adamant, and visibly distraught.
"Such a stern reaction to a ten-cent mistake on a multi-million dollar
figure?" thought Cronkite. Perhaps this outrage meant that this line of
work was truly not for him.
When the young Cronkite walked back toward his colleagues, they looked
grim. "How you're gonna fix this one?" they jeered. "So, are you getting
bodyguards?" they taunted. Cronkite was baffled and finally exploded.
"What's all this fuss about a ten-cent error on a 3 million dollar
clearing!?" He exclaimed. "What's the big deal?"
The other reporters looked at him in shock when then realized he truly did
not understand the severity of his trivial mistake, their shock turned to pity.
Finally, the local columnist explained. "Do you think anybody really cares
about the bank clearings? The numbers racket in Houston pays off using the
last 5 digits of the bank clearing. Well, yesterday they paid off based on
your number." He paused. "The mob don't like paying off on a bad number."
For the next few weeks, Walter Cronkite lived in literal fear of his
seemingly insignificant ten cent error.
Numbers, no matter how irrelevant they seem to the unenlightened, are not
meaningless. To us in a modern society we may read that Yehuda had 74,600
males over twenty and Naftali 53,400. But they are not mere numbers. Rav
Naftoli of Ropshitz comments that each Jew mentioned brought immense
spiritual greatness to this earth. Each person counted was a cherished gem
whose existence impacted eternally. We often cite numbers and statistics
without realizing the tremendous impact of their importance. We teach our
children the significance of the destruction of European Jewry, but can
they fathom the significance of 6,000,000 Jews lost? Does a Jew harmed in
a terrorist attack or an Israeli soldier killed become a statistic, or is
he mourned as a soul who graced this world with tremendous significance?
The Torah's reiteration of the importance of counting each and every member
of our nation remains with us to this very day. We do not have to be
counted for any socio-economic reason. We are counted for the inherent
value of each and every soul. And ultimately each soul can alter the
course of our history. Because each and every Jew's two cent's worth is
worth more than millions.
Rabbi Mordechai Kamenetzky
Dedicated by Mr. and Mrs. Avi Lauer & Family in loving memory of Avi's father,
Rabbi Elias Lauer - Harav Eliezer ben Aharon Dovid, A"H,
on the occasion of his second yartzeit on the 26th of Iyar - May 12, 1999.
In other news... I will be giving a Shavuos shiur "Searching for Sinai" at
1:00 PM on Tuesday May 18th 1999. The shiur and a light lunch will be held
in the Office of Martin Oliner, 375 Park Avenue (Seagram's Building) corner
53rd -- 37th floor.
The shiur, filled with insights and anecdotes will last approximately 35 to
40 minutes followed by mincha. I look forward to meeting many of the
readers of Drasha whose only link with each other is the "@" in their
Copyright © 1999 by Rabbi M. Kamenetzky and Project Genesis, Inc.
If you enjoy the weekly Drasha, now you can receive the best of Drasha in book form!
- from the Project Genesis bookstore - Genesis Judaica - at a very special price!
The author is the Associate Dean of the
Yeshiva of South Shore.
Drasha is the e-mail edition of FaxHomily, a weekly torah facsimile on the weekly portion
which is sponsored by The Henry and Myrtle Hirsch Foundation