Volume 5 Issue 2
by Rabbi Mordechai Kamenetzky
Noach lived through trying times to say the least. He survived not only a
generation of spiritual chaos, but physical annihilation as well. However,
Hashem walked with him and guided him. He instructed him every step of the
way. He warned him of the impending flood. He instructed him to build an
ark. He told him to bring all the animals to the ark. Yet Noach is
labeled as a man who was lacking in faith. The Torah tells us that, "Noach
with his wife and sons and his son's wives with him, went into the ark
because of the waters of the Flood" (Genesis 7:6).
Rashi quotes a Midrash which proclaims that Noach, to a small degree,
lacked faith as he only entered the ark "because of the waters of the
Flood." The implication is that Noach did not enter the ark until the rain
forced him to.
The obvious question is how can we say that Noach lacked, even to a tiny
extent, faith? He had to believe! After all, he spoke to Hashem! He
built the ark! He gathered all the animals! He was the only one in his
generation to worry about the impending doom! Surely, he must have
believed! Why is there a complaint against Noach? What is wrong in
waiting until he had no choice but to enter? To what degree is he
considered lacking in faith?
Rabbi Shimshon Sherer, Rav of Congregation Kehilas Zichron Mordechai, tells
the following story.
In a small town there was a severe drought. The community synagogues each
prayed separately for rain, but to no avail. The tears and prayers failed
to unlock the sealed heavens, and for months, no rains came.
Finally, the town's eldest sage held a meeting with prominent community
rabbis and lay leaders. "There are two items lacking in our approach,
faith and unity. Each one of you must impress upon his congregation the
need to believe. If we are united and sincere, our prayers will be answered!"
He declared that all the synagogues in the city would join together for a
day of tefilah. Everyone, men women and children would join together for
this event. "I assure you," he exclaimed, "that if we meet both criteria -
faith and unity - no one will leave that prayer service without getting
There was no shul large enough to contain the entire community so the date
was set to gather and daven in a field! For the next few weeks all the
rabbis spoke about bitachon and achdus (faith and unity). On the
designated day the entire town gathered in a large field whose crops had
long withered from the severe drought. Men, women, and children all
gathered and anxiously awaited the old sage to begin the service.
The elderly rabbi walked up to the podium. His eyes scanned the tremendous
crowd that filled the large field and then they dimmed in dismay. The
rabbi began shaking his head in dissatisfaction. "This will never work,"
he moaned dejectedly. "The rain will not come." Slowly he left the podium.
The other rabbis on the dais were shocked. "But rebbe everyone is here and
they are all united! Surely they must believe that the rains will fall!
Otherwise no one would have bothered to come on a working day!"
The rabbi shook his head slowly and sadly.
"No. They don't really believe," he stated. "I scanned the entire crowd.
Nobody even brought a raincoat."
The level of faith that the Torah demanded from Noach would have had him
bolt into the ark on the very morning that the Flood was meant to come. He
had no inkling of the ferocity that was impending at the storm's first
moments. Though it began as a light rainstorm his waiting until being
forced by the torrents is equivalent to one who hears predictions of a
tornado and stands outside waiting for the funnel to knock at his door.
Noach should have moved himself and his family in the ark at zero hour
without waiting for the rains to force him in. The instinctive faith
should have kicked in turning the bright sunny day that he may have
experienced into one that is filled with fatal flood water. But he waited
to see if it would really come. And for that he is chided.
How often do we cancel plans or change a course of action on the say-so of
the weatherman, but plan our activities so in contrast with the predictions
of the Torah? Even Noach, who built the ark under intense pressure, is
held accountable for the lack of instinctive faith that should have been
interred in his bones. And on that level of faith, unfortunately, all of
us are a little wet behind the ears.
Rabbi Mordechai Kamenetzky
Copyright © 1998 by Rabbi M. Kamenetzky and Project Genesis, Inc.
If you enjoy the weekly Drasha, now you can receive the best of Drasha in book form!
- from the Project Genesis bookstore - Genesis Judaica - at a very special price!
The author is the Associate Dean of the
Yeshiva of South Shore.
Drasha is the e-mail edition of FaxHomily, a weekly torah facsimile on the weekly portion
which is sponsored by The Henry and Myrtle Hirsch Foundation