Volume 5 Issue 23
by Rabbi Mordechai Kamenetzky
The Mishkan is completed in these portions, and the Torah recaps the stunning
accomplishment. "These are the reckonings of the Mishkan, the Tabernacle of
Testimony that was reckoned through Moshe's bidding. And Betzalel son of Uri,
son of Chur, did everything that Hashem commanded Moshe" (Exodus 38:21-22).
The Torah calls the Mishkan a Tabernacle of Testimony. To what is it
testifying? Architectural ability? A fund raising phenomenon? Or perhaps
something even loftier?
Rashi tells us that the Mishkan, in fact, testified that Hashem forgave the
Jewish people for the sin of the Golden Calf.
It always has bothered me. Forgiveness comes with a correction of a misdeed.
Obviously, each account needs direct redress. Stinginess is forgiven with acts
of munificence. Sins of uncontrolled rage are forgiven when the transgressor
acts with undeviating gentleness.
What connection does the building of the Mishkan have with the forming of the
Golden Calf? Why is the completion of the Mishkan a testimony to absolution?
The second verse is also is disconcerting. "Betzalel did what Hashem told
Moshe." Did he not do what Moshe told him? It seems that he jumped the chain
of command. It should have stated that "Betzalel did what Moshe told him."
Dr. Abraham Twerski, in his book Do Unto Others, relates an amazing story
that he personally experienced. Early in his career, Dr. Twerski would
teach students by having them accompany him through psychiatric
institutions. There he would introduce the young observers to the live
subjects, rarely seen outside textbooks.
In a chronic care facility, Dr. Twerski pointed out a most difficult case, a
male patient whom no doctor was able to cure. The man was mute and would not
communicate. He had entered the facility 52 years earlier and was suffering
from strange schizophrenic-like symptoms. Immediately following breakfast he
would go into the corner of the large community room, contort his arms, palms
outstretched in an upward manner and stand there until lunch. After lunch, he
would resume his position until bedtime. No treatment nor medication, shock
therapy, or cajoling was able to get the man off his feet. His condition was
so severe that due to standing all day he developed excessive accumulation of
serous fluid in tissue spaces in his feet.
On one visit, a student asked if he could talk to the patient. Dr. Twerski
agreed, while wondering what the young doctor could offer that had not been
explored by the experts.
After a brief conversation the man stared blankly at the young doctor. But
then the student assumed the man's exact contorted position and said to him,
"I'll stand here like this. You can go sit down." The patient smiled,
proceeded to a couch, and for the first time in 52 years he actually sat down!
Dr. Twerski surmised that the patient felt he was holding up the world.
Without him, it would collapse. (He had no explanation for the meal or
bedtime gaps.) The moment the patient was convinced that someone could
carry the mission as well, he relaxed.
Commentaries explain that the sin of the Golden Calf began when Moshe did not
return from Sinai on time. The minute that 40 days elapsed and Moshe was
missing the nation panicked. No one, they felt, could lead them but Moshe, so
they created a false deity. And they prayed and danced to a new-found god.
The Mishkan, however, was an antidote. Moshe charged Betzalel with the
tremendous task, and he accomplished it. In fact, our sages explain that he
even challenged Moshe in certain directives, and Hashem concurred with him!
Betzalel did what Hashem wantedexactly the way it was told to Moshe. He had
the ability to perform as if he received the directive himself! That is the
goal of mesorah. Tradition has the next generation holding the torch though
passed from previous leaders as if it were passed from the Almighty Himself.
The nation saw that it is possible to continue despite the former leader
holding up the world every step of the way. There is room for young leadership
to carry on the directives of the elder generation. That is the way the Torah
carries on. And that is the way we hold up the world.
Rabbi Mordechai Kamenetzky
Dedicated in memory of George Fisch and Rebecca Stein
by Mr. and Mrs. Lionel Fish
Copyright © 1999 by Rabbi M. Kamenetzky and Project Genesis, Inc.
If you enjoy the weekly Drasha, now you can receive the best of Drasha in book form!
- from the Project Genesis bookstore - Genesis Judaica - at a very special price!
The author is the Associate Dean of the
Yeshiva of South Shore.
Drasha is the e-mail edition of FaxHomily, a weekly torah facsimile on the weekly portion
which is sponsored by The Henry and Myrtle Hirsch Foundation