One of the most joyous customs associated with the holiday of Sukkos is the
celebration of Simchas Bais Hashoaevah. In the times of the Bais HaMikdash,
a water libation accompanied the customary offerings. Simchas Bais
Hashoaevah, literally, the Joy of the Water Drawing, was observed with a
most ebullient celebration. It included a marvelously varied array of
harps, lyres, cymbals, and trumpets, among other instruments. The greatest
sages and most pious of rabbis performed acrobatics and antics that would
have normally been below their dignity. In fact , the sages in Tractate
Sukkah 51, note that, "one who has not seen the celebration of the Bais
Hashoaevo has never seen true joy."
Rambam (Maimonides) discusses this aspect of exuberance and adds that "one
who in his insolence restrains himself from serving Hashem in a joyous
manner is a sinner and fool." Yet the Rambam adds a caveat. "But this joy
was not performed by the ignorant ones and by anyone who wanted (to
dance). Only the great sages of Israel, the heads of Yeshivos and the
Sanhedrin, the pious, the elders and men of righteous action would dance,
clap, and sing in the Bais haMikdash on Sukkos. Everyone else, men and
women would come to watch and listen" (Rambam Hilchos Lulav 8:14).
This passage begs explanation. Why shouldn't everyone, even the most
profane of men, sing and dance and make merry in celebration of the L-rd?
Further what does the Rambam mean by not including "those who want to dance"?
Ultimately, anyone who ended up dancing, even the most pious of
sages, obviously wanted to dance. What, then, does he Rambam mean when he
said that this joy was not performed by anyone who wanted to dance?
A classic story circulates in all Jewish humor anthologies.
Before the start of the Ne'eilah service, the holiest and final
supplication of Yom Kippur, the rabbi rose from his seat and bolted toward
the Holy Ark. He spread his hands toward heaven and cried out, "Ribbono
Shel Olam, Master of the Universe, I am a total nothing before you! Please
inscribe me in the book of life!"
All of a sudden the chazzan (cantor) ran toward the Aron and joined the
rabbi! "G-d Almighty," he shouted, "please forgive me, too, for I am truly
a nothing before you!" There is an awed silence amongst the congregants.
The shammas (sexton) then followed suit. He, too, ran up toward the ark
and in tearful supplication pronounced, I too am a nothing!"
Mouths around the congregation dropped open. The President of the
synagogue's men's club, Ed Goldstein, a large man, was also caught up in
the fervor of the moment. Suddenly, he, too, bolted from his seat in the
back, and lumbered toward the front of the shul. With great eagerness he
prostrated himself in front of the Ark and cried out at the top of his
lungs. "Forgive me Oh L-rd he shouts, for I too am a nothing!
Suddenly a shout from the back of the synagogue was directed toward
Goldstein's hulk of a figure. It shouted with incredulity. "Harrumph! Look
who thinks he's a nothing!"
Rambam teaches us that whoever runs to dance and sing and make himself crazy
is not truly lowering himself before the Almighty. If someone inherently
likes to cavort wildly, then he is not dancing for the sake of lowering
himself before the Almighty, rather he is having a wonderful time. When King
David liberated the Aron (Ark of the Covenant) from the Phillistines, he
danced in front it as if he were a lowly slave. When confronted by his wife,
Michal, for dancing like a servant, he retorted. "I would make myself even
lower before Hashem."
When rejoicing during the festivities we must bear in mind our true reasons
for enthusiasm -- who we are, and why we dance. Because in order to be a
nobody, you gotta be a somebody.