Volume 6 Issue 20
by Rabbi Mordechai Kamenetzky
In this week's portion Moshe is charged to prepare every detail of the
priesthood for his brother Aharon and his descendants. In intricate detail,
the sartorial traits of every one of the priestly vestments are explicated,
down to the last intertwined threads.
And though Moshe is in charge of setting up the administration and
establishing the entire order of service while training his brother and
nephews, his name is conspicuously missing from this portion.
Our sages explain the reason for the omission. When Hashem threatened to
destroy His nation, Moshe pleaded with Him: "And now if You would but
forgive their sin! -- but if not, erase me now from Your book that You have
written"(Exodus 32:32) As we all know, Moshe's plea were accepted. The
nation was spared. But Moshe was not left unscathed. His request of
written eradication was fulfilled in one aspect. He was left out of one
portion of the Torah Tezaveh. Thus the words of the tzadik were fulfilled
in one aspect. But why this portion?
Though this English-language publication is not wont to discuss Hebrew
etymological derivations, it is noteworthy to mention a thought I once
heard in the name of Rabbi Ovadiah Yosef. Moshe's plea "erase me now from
Your book," bears an explanation. The word sifr'chah, "your book" can be
broken down to two words sefer chaf -- which means the twentieth
book. Thus Moshe was removed from this portion of Tezaveh, the twentieth
portion of the Torah.
But why would Moshe intone such omission in this, of all the portions of
the Torah? Why not omit his name in the portions that declare the tragic
outcome of sin or the calamities of insurrection? Wouldn't that be a better
choice for omission? Why did Moshe allude to having his name omitted in the
week he charges Aharon with all the honor and glory that is afforded the
Rav Yitzchak Blaser was once seated at a gathering of the most prominent
sages of his generation that was held in his city of St. Petersburg.
Among the Talmudic sages present was Rabbi Yosef Dov HaLevi Soleveitchik of
Brisk, world renown for his Talmudic genius. Rabbi Soloveitchik presented a
Talmudic question that his young son, Reb Chaim, had asked. After posing
the question, a flurry of discussion ensued, each of the rabbis offering
his own answer to the riddle, while other rabbis refuted them with powerful
rebuttals. During the entire repartee, Rabbi Blaser, who had a reputation
as a Talmudic genius, sat silently. He did not offer an answer, nor did he
voice approval to any of the answers given by the Rabbis.
When Rabbi Soleveitchik ultimately offered his son's own solution, Rabbi
Blaser sat quietly, neither nodding in approval nor shaking his head
in disagreement. It seemed as if he did not comprehend the depth of the
insightful discourse. It was as if he was not even there!
Bewildered, Reb Yosef Dov began having second thoughts about the renowned
Rabbi Blaser. "Was he truly the remarkable scholar that the world had made
him out to be?" he wondered.
Later that evening, Rabbi Soloveitchik was in the main synagogue where he
got hold of the book "Pri Yitzchok," a volume filled with Talmudic
exegesis authored by none other than Rabbi Blaser himself.
After leafing through the large volume he saw that the afternoon's entire
discourse, his son's question, the offered and reputed responses, and the
final resolution, were all part of a dissertation that Rabbi Blaser had
himself published years earlier!
"Now I realize," thought Rabbi Soleveitchik, "Rabbi Blaser is as much a
genius in humility as he is in Talmudic law!"
Our sages tell us that actually Moshe was to have been chosen as the Kohen
Gadol in addition to the leader of the Jewish nation. It was his
unwavering refusal to accept any of those positions that lost him the
opportunity to serve as Kohen Gadol. Instead, Hashem took it from him and
gave it to Aharon.
Many of us would have always harped on the fact. How often do I hear the
claims "I got him that job!" "I could have been in his position!" "I
started that company! Had I stayed, I would be the one with the stock
options!" "That was really my idea!"
Moshe, too, could have injected himself as the one who propelled and
engineered Aharon's thrust to glory -- especially after a seemingly tainting
experience with the Golden Calf. In his great humility, Moshe did just the
Moshe did not want to diminish Aharon's glory in any way. He wanted the
entire spotlight to shine on Aharon and his great service to Klal Yisrael.
Therefore, in the portion in which Moshe charges, guides, and directs the
entire process of the priesthood, his name is conspicuously omitted.
One of the greatest attributes of true humility is to let others shine in
their own achievement without interfering or announcing your role in their
success. The greatest educators, the wisest parents, and most
understanding colleagues know when to share the spotlight and when to let
another friend, colleague, sibling, or child shine in their success or
accomplishment. They know exactly when to be conspicuously or
inconspicuously "missing from the book." Good Shabbos © 2000 Rabbi
Dedicated by Ira & Gisele Beer in memory of Harry Beer -- L'Iluy Nishmas
Reb Zvi Mendel ben Reb Pinchas -- 8 Adar Aleph
If you would like to be on a shiur update list which sends messages
regarding Rabbi Mordechai Kamenetzky's various lectures in NY City and Long
Island and other locations, please send a blank email to
email@example.com You will receive bulletins about those classes.
If you want to be on a shiur announcement faxlist, fax request along with
your fax number (dedicated line, please) to 516-569-7954
Copyright © 1998 by Rabbi M. Kamenetzky and Project Genesis, Inc.
If you enjoy the weekly Drasha, now you can receive the best of Drasha in book form!
- from the Project Genesis bookstore - Genesis Judaica - at a very special price!
The author is the Associate Dean of the
Yeshiva of South Shore.
Drasha is the e-mail edition of FaxHomily, a weekly torah facsimile on the weekly portion
which is sponsored by The Henry and Myrtle Hirsch Foundation