There is a lesson, meted out in this week's portion that has eternal
ramifications upon the theological nature of the Jewish nation. It is a
lesson that defines our attitudes toward spirituality and its relevance to
After Bila'am's failed efforts to curse the Jewish people, he devised
another ploy. He advised the nations of Midian and Moav to lure the Jews
to sin through salacious activities. Midian complied wholeheartedly,
offering its daughters as conspirators in the profanity. The scheme
worked. The Jews cavorted with Midianite women, and the wrath of Hashem
was aroused. A plague ensued and thousands of Jews died.
In this week's portion, Hashem commands his people to administer
justice. "Make the Midianites your enemies and attack them!" For they
antagonized you through their conspiracy that they conspired against you in
the matter of Peor, and in the matter of Cozbi, daughter of a leader of
Midian, their sister, who was slain on the day of the plague, in the matter
of Peor" (Numbers 25:17-18). Eventually Jews go to war with Midian.
The issue that may confront the modern thinker is simple. War? Over
what? They were not fighting over land. There was no dispute over oil or
natural resources. Why such vehemence to the point of physical attack over
the incident at Peor? Why call for such physical retribution for an act
that caused spiritual sedition through secular seduction?
Rabbi Eliezer Sorotzkin of Lev L'Achim related the following story: In
November 1938, before the onset of World War II, some Jewish children had
the opportunity to escape from Nazi Germany and resettle in England through
what became known as kindertransport. Unfortunately, their were not enough
religious families able to accept these children and other families who
were willing to take them were not willing to raise the children with
Jewish traditions. The Chief Rabbi of London, Rabbi Yechezkel Abramski,
embarked on a frantic campaign to secure funding to ensure that every child
would be placed in a proper Jewish environment.
Rabbi Abramski called one wealthy Jewish industrialist and begged him for a
donation sizable enough to ensure that the children would be raised in
proper Jewish environment. "It is pikuach nefesh!" cried Rabbi Abramski.
At that point, the tycoon became incensed. "Rabbi," he said, "Please do not
use that term flippantly. I know what pikuach nefesh is. Pikuach nefesh
means a matter of life and death! When I was young, my parents were very
observant. When my baby sister was young, she was very sick. We had to
call the doctor, but it was on Shabbos. My father was very conscientious
of the sanctity of Shabbos. He would never desecrate Shabbos. But our
rabbi told us that since this is a matter of life and death, we were
allowed to desecrate the Shabbos! He called it pikuach nefesh. Rabbi
Abramski," the man implored, "with all due respect. The children are
already here in England. They are safe from the Nazis. The only issue is
where to place them. How they are raised is not pikuach nefesh!" With
that, the man politely bade farewell and hung up the phone.
That Friday evening, the wealthy man was sitting at dinner, when the
telephone rang incessantly. Finally, the man got up from his meal and
answered the phone.
As he listened to the voice on the other end of the line, his face went pallid.
"This is Abramski. Please. I would not call on the Sabbath if I did not
think this was pikuach nefesh. Again, I implore you. We need the funds to
ensure that these children will be raised as Jews."
Needless to say, the man responded immediately to the appeal.
We understand matters of life and death, justice and injustice, war and
peace, in corporeal terms. It is difficult to view spirituality in those
terms as well.
The Torah teaches us that our enemies are not merely those who threaten our
physical existence, but those who threaten our spiritual existence as
well. Throughout the generations, we faced those who would annihilate us
physically and others who would be just as happy to see us disappear as Jews.
What our enemies were unable to do to the Jewish people with bullets and
gas, they have succeeded in doing with assimilation and spiritual
People fail to equate the severity of spiritual disorders with those of a
physical nature. They may scoff at a prohibited marriage in the eyes of
the Torah, or seek a leniency to absolve themselves from following
matrimonial law, yet they will leave no stone unturned in searching for a
genetic incompatibility or suspect health issue. The Torah teaches us that
the two the physical world and the spiritual world are inseparable. An
attack on spirituality, breaches the borders of our very essence, and our
response must be in kind. It is essential to know that when we do some
serious soul-searching there is really something out there waiting to be
Dedicated to a continued refuah shlaimah for Yehuda Boruch ben Sora Menucha
Copyright © 2001 by Rabbi M. Kamenetzky and Project Genesis, Inc.
If you enjoy the weekly Drasha, now you can receive the best of Drasha in book form! Purchase
- from the Project Genesis bookstore - Genesis Judaica - at a very special price!
The author is the Associate Dean of the
Yeshiva of South Shore.
Drasha is the e-mail edition of FaxHomily, a weekly torah facsimile on the weekly portion which is sponsored by The Henry and Myrtle Hirsch Foundation