Shimon and Levi are brothers; stolen instruments are their weapons. Let my
soul not enter their counsel; my honor, you shall not join their assembly,
for in their wrath they killed a man, and with their will they hamstrung a
bull. Cursed be their wrath for it is mighty, and their anger because it is
harsh. I will separate them throughout Yaakov, and I will scatter them
throughout Israel. (Breishis 49: 5-7)
This was the beginning Yaakov blessing the brothers before his passing on.
Things got better and more flattering from here and on but the first three
really received a rugged treatment. Yet these too are counted amongst Birkas
Yaakov-the blessings of Yaakov. It certainly shatters our impression of what
a blessing sounds and feels like. The average person would imagine a
blessing is some general or generic wishing of wellness, “Hope you win the
lottery!”Now we find out, the hard way, that that is not the case. What then
is blessing? Why is it so prized? How can it be riddled with seeming
negativity and still be considered a blessing?
Rabbi Kalonymos Kalman Shapiro ztl., the Piaseczna Rebbe writes in his
introduction to Chovos HaTalmidim, “Every father and every teacher knows
that their children and students will not remain children forever, but will
eventually grow in years and possibly in Torah knowledge and spiritual
devotion. Yet there exist fathers and teachers who are concerned only with
what they see right now. Since all they see, right now, are children, the
goal of their efforts is to educate their charges to become good children.
They wish to infuse them with only a child's measure of Torah and awe of
God. This they consider sufficient. But a teacher or parent who does this is
sinning against God and against His people.
Fathers and teachers must know that their task is to educate and uncover
children of the Lord and giants of Israel. They must see the children
sitting in front of them as great souls still immature; their task is to get
them to grow and flourish. A teacher is a gardener in the garden of God,
assigned to cultivate it and guard it from harm.
Even if some of the children seem rebellious, or flawed in their character,
the teacher must know that the nature of soul-seeds; of unripe angels, is to
taste bitter as they are ripening and to be filled with nectar in their
maturity. Neither the nature, nor any particular quality of a Jewish child,
is absolutely evil.
This is what the holy Baal Shem Tov and his disciples have taught us. What
is necessary is just to know how to use these qualities and how to help them
develop and grow. For example, a particular child may be very stubborn-
which is a character flaw. His teacher may suffer greatly because of the
child's stubbornness. Yet if the teacher were to reflect, he would realize
that when this child matures and receives as his own the yoke of Torah and
of service to God, he will perform all his service of God with great
stubbornnessand self-sacrifice…he will be as strong as the wall of a
When “HASHEM saw everything He created and it was Tov Meod-very good”, the
Talmud explains what gave creation an upgrade from“good” to “very good”. The
statement reads, “Tov meod, zu Yetzer Hora”- Very good, this is the Negative
Inclination!” What’s very good in the child can become a Yetzer Hora. Too
neat and clean or being overly sensitive can be dangerous. The opposite is
true too. What’s negative about the person or child can be sublimated and
disciplined into very goodness, if not greatness. Whoever can give someone a
real read on anything flattering or even painfully true about them is
helpful like an MRI.
Yaakov told Shimon and Levi that their anger was cursed, and not them. In
the end, Levi held onto that fiery nature and reserved it for special
emergencies. It came to positive fruition by the sin of the Golden Calf when
Levi stepped up to defend the honor of heaven when others were less prepared
to do the same. It was the proper employment of that anger that put them on
a pedestal for all time. What Yaakov told them, and the way it was received
was ultimately the ultimate blessing not in disguise.