Hamaayan / The Torah Spring
Edited by Shlomo Katz
Volume XII, Number 38
2 Av 5758
July 25, 1998
Mel and Barbara Ciment and Family
in memory of Mr. Jack Ciment a"h
Sarah bat Yitzchak Hakohen Katz a"h
Yerushalmi Eruvin 12
R' Moshe Tzuriel shlita writes: R' Samson Raphael Hirsch z"l
comments that the mourning period of the Three Weeks, beginning
on the seventeenth of Tammuz and lasting until the ninth of Av,
is to be taken as an unfolding drama and not as a period of
isolated afflictions. The various phases of remembrance include:
the beginning of the siege of Jerusalem, the capture of the city,
the burning of the Temple, and the murder of the kohanim. In
other words, the historical fact of military defeat at the hands
of the Babylonians (First Temple) or the Romans (Second Temple)
was not the last word. The punishment for national sins was an
ongoing process, capable of being halted at any step; more so,
capable of being reversed from catastrophe to victory, if only we
would have seized the opportunity to repent. It is never too late
to return to G-d. Even as the flames licked at the sacred altar,
if our ancestors had changed heart and returned to Torah loyalty,
G-d would have reversed the disaster.
That is why when Caramel, a cousin of the Prophet Yirmiyah came
to the latter to sell his field, G-d ordered Yirmiyah to make a
proper legally-binding deed, with good witnesses etc. (see
Yirmiyah Ch. 32).
Yirmiyah objected, "Behold the siege-works are
being clasped against our city walls so to capture it, the city
is falling before the sword, hunger and (subsequent) plague. What
you proclaimed will be is being actualized - and yet you say,
'Make a legal and binding sale of the field'?!" Hashem answered,
"True, I am the G-d almighty, is there anything impossible for
Me? The Babylonians are burning the houses . . . yet I will still
gather together the dispersed Jews from all their places of
captivity, I will bring them back to Israel and they will dwell
securely. They will be My people and I will be their G-d. I will
give them one heart and one path, so that they fear Me forever.
Therefore fields will be negotiated, since I will return their
We learn from the above that the destruction was done in
stages, allowing Bnei Yisrael to halt or alter it. This ability
to stem the tide of disaster, this ability to be reborn and start
life afresh, stems from G-d's mastery of history, G-d's manifest
providence. The flood tides of countless persecutions all passes
over our heads; individuals die, but the nation as a whole
continues in full force. We reel with the forces of the waves,
flexible as reeds, but immediately afterwards we stand
spiritually erect, firm as oaks (see Taint 20a). We are resigned
to our destiny, but steadfast in our obligations. (From
Destruction and Correction, an e-mail lecture)
"Moshe spoke to the heads of the tribes of Bnei Yisrael
saying, 'This is the thing that Hashem commanded'." (30:2)
"To the heads of the tribes" may be translated, "Regarding the
heads of the tribes." In other words, Moshe spoke to Bnei
Yisrael regarding the heads of the tribes, and he said, "Whatever
the heads of the tribes say, you should regard it as if that is
the thing that Hashem commanded." One must obey the decrees of
the Sages no less than the decrees of G-d Himself.
quoted in Ma'ayanah Shel Torah)
Why, of all of the Torah's laws, do the laws of vows open with
a reminder about the importance of obeying the Sages? Also, why
is it that rabbis can annul vows?
The answer is that the Torah expects a Jew to order his
lifestyle according to the will of the Torah scholars. It
therefore follows that, "Whoever takes a vow does so only if the
rabbis approve." If the rabbis do not approve of a specific vow,
they can annul it.
When one does not consult with rabbis, he may inadvertently sin
precisely when he thinks he is performing a mitzvah. To take an
extreme example, one may build an altar in his backyard and
sacrifice an animal on it. Even if he is exacting in all of the
laws of the sacrifices, he commits a grievous sin by bringing a
sacrifice outside of the Temple.
quoted in Ma'ayanah Shel Torah)
R' Mordechai Gifter shlita writes that the obligation to submit
to the opinions of Torah scholars comes from our recognition that
they are our link to Moshe Rabbenu and the giving of the Torah.
From this deep conviction, he writes, Jews have derived the
fundamental principle of emunat chachamim/faith in Torah sages:
to believe in and be convinced of the correctness of the
teachings of Torah sages. In the words of Chazal, even when they
tell you that right is left and left is right - even when you
feel that you know better, you must submit to their words. Woe
to the generation that seeks to know the Torah's "right" and
"left" but that seeks it according to its own understanding
instead of according to the wisdom of the Torah itself.
(Adapted from Torah Perspectives pp. 14-15)
"My master was commanded by Hashem to give the inheritance
of Tzlofchad our brother to his daughters." (36:2)
R' Avigdor Nebenzahl shlita taught: Chazal (Bava Batra 119b)
praise the daughters of Tzlofchad: "The daughters of Tzlofchad
were wise, they were expounders of Torah, and they were
righteous." The gemara explains that they were wise in that
"they spoke in a timely fashion," they posed their question to
Moshe precisely when Moshe was studying and teaching the laws of
yibum/ levirate marriages. What made these women wise was that
they understood the true purpose of inheriting from their father.
They did not simply desire his gold, silver, or even his portion
in the Land of Israel. They realized that the purpose of
inheritance was to provide a tikkun/correction for the soul of
the departed. The Torah mandates that inheritance go to the next
of kin. If there is a son, the son inherits, if there is not a
son, then a daughter, and so forth as prescribed by the Torah in
Parashat Pinchas. The reason the inheritance must go to
relatives is because when one inherits his father's land, one can
provide a tikkun for the father's soul.
The same can be said of yibum. Rambam writes that although the
law of yibum (that if a man dies childless his widow should marry
his brother) applies only to the deceased's brother, the deeper
meaning of this halachah applies to other relatives as well.
Thus, the story of Yehuda's relationship with Tamar is referred
to as one of yibum, as is Boaz's marriage to Ruth. Although the
strict halachah cannot be fulfilled by other relatives, the
tikkun can certainly be accomplished by them.
The daughters of Tzlofchad applied this principle to all
inheritance. Hashem gave a man a wife, as well as all his
worldly possessions, in order to serve Hashem. If a man was
unable to apply to the utmost in serving Hashem that which he had
during his lifetime, his next of kin can provide a tikkun for
that situation by inheriting it and using it in the correct
manner. (R' Nebenzahl says that this is how his teacher, R'
Eliyahu Dessler z"l understood the request of Tzlofchad's
The Torah (Bereishit 33:19) relates how Yaakov Avinu purchased
a field. The Torah tells of this incident because purchasing a
field in the Land of Israel is akin to acquiring for oneself a
portion in the World to Come. The daughters of Tzlofchad felt
that through them, their father would merit a share in the land
of Israel and thus in the next world. Although one may argue
that if inheriting the land is what provides the tikkun, then it
need not be the daughters that inherit; perhaps if Tzlofchad's
brothers had inherited, the same tikkun could be accomplished.
However, Tzlofchad's daughters understand that the tikkun is
greater if closer relatives such as themselves are the heirs.
(From a lecture delivered at Yeshivat Hakotel
20 Tamuz 5758)
R' Moshe Hadarshan z"l
R' Moshe Hadarshan is the earliest known scholar from Provence
(the Mediterranean coast of France) whose works are cited by
later authorities. R' Natan ben Yechiel, author of the Aruch,
was his disciple and cites him several times in that work.
A great-grandson of R' Abun, who was reputedly the first rosh
yeshiva in Narbonne, R' Moshe inherited that position from his
father, R' Yaakov ben Moshe ben Abun. R' Moshe composed an
anthology of midrashim arranged according to the verses of the
Torah (similar to Yalkut Shimoni) insterspersed with his original
inserts and spiced with allusions and gematriot. Rashi (in
several places in his Torah commentary) refers to this work as
the Yesod of R' Moshe Hadarshan.
Rabbenu Tam lists R' Moshe and his brother R' Levi as the
foremost halachic authorities in their land. In the commentary
to Divrei Hayamim I (4:31) ascribed to Rashi, a son of this R'
Levi is cited. A son of R' Moshe himself is cited in Rashi's
commentary to Yirmiyah 31:21.
R' Moshe Isserles writes about a R' Moshe Hadarshan who
traveled throughout Provence and Spain fighting intermarriage.
However, this appears to be a different person. (Sources: The
Artscroll Rishonim p.161; She'eilot U'teshuvot Rema No. 30)
* ** * ** * ** * ** * ** * ** * ** * **
The second of this week's two parashot opens with a list of all
of the places where Bnei Yisrael camped during their 40 years in
the desert. Why? R' Moshe Hadarshan explains as follows:
Reading this list teaches us Hashem's kindness, for even though
Hashem decreed that Bnei Yisrael must wander in the desert, you
should not think that they wandered around for forty years
without respite. In all, Bnei Yisrael stopped in 42 places. Of
these, 14 were during the first year, before the decree [that
they would wander] was made. Another eight stops occurred after
Aharon died [in the 40th year]. It turns out that in the
remaining 38 years, Bnei Yisrael made only 20 stops. (Quoted in
Rashi to 33:1)
Copyright © 1998 by Shlomo Katz
and Project Genesis, Inc.
The editors hope these brief 'snippets' will engender further study
and discussion of Torah topics ("lehagdil Torah u'leha'adirah"), and
your letters are appreciated. Web archives at Project Genesis
start with 5758 (1997) and
may be retrieved from the Hamaayan page.
Text archives from 1990 through the present
may be retrieved from
to HaMaayan are tax-deductible.
KEDOSHIM AND PESACH:
Elevated by Divine Command
Rabbi Naphtali Hoff - 5770
How Do We Approach This Child?
Rabbi Label Lam - 5764
Holiness - Served Fresh
Shlomo Katz - 5764
Not Every Thing is Spelled Out in Shulchan Aruch
Rabbi Yissocher Frand - 5771
Rabbi Eliyahu Hoffmann - 5758
Maybe Next Year, in Jerusalem!
Rabbi Label Lam - 5768
Beginning with Matza
Rabbi Yehudah Prero - 5755
Will That Be A Medium, Or Well Done?
Rabbi Pinchas Winston - 5764
Rabbi Yehudah Prero - 5766
A Potential Lesson
Rabbi Yehudah Prero - 5760
What is the Question?
Rabbi Label Lam - 5763
Rabbi Yochanan Zweig - 5773
Symbolism Over Substance
Rabbi Mordechai Kamenetzky - 5757
From the Inside Out
Rabbi Dovid Green - 5761
Appreciating the Value of the Jew
Rabbi Yosef Kalatsky - 5763
Rabbi Mordechai Kamenetzky - 5761