Hamaayan / The Torah Spring
Edited by Shlomo Katz
Behar: Whose Land Is It Anyway?
Volume XVII, No. 32
15 Iyar 5763
May 17, 2003
Sponsored by
Marcia Goodman and family,
on the yahrzeit of mother Rivka bat Yehuda Halevi a"h
The Vogel family
on the yahrzeit of mother and grandmother
Bluma bat Shabtai Hakohen a"h
Today's Learning:
Kinim 1:1-2
O.C. 30:4-31:1
Daf Yomi (Bavli): Avodah Zarah 65
Daf Yomi (Yerushalmi): Yoma 25
Our parashah opens: "When you come into the Land that `Ani' /
I give you. . ." This and similar phrases are found 22 times in
the Torah. Why, asks R' Shaul Yedidya Elazer Taub (see page 4),
does G-d remind us so many times that He is the One giving us the
Land? R' Taub explains:
We read in Yoel (4:21) [and also recite in the Av Harachamim
prayer on Shabbat], "Though I cleanse - their blood I will not
cleanse, and Hashem dwells in Zion." What does Zion have to do
with G-d's avenging the blood of our martyrs? Furthermore, this
verse appears to be contradictory - has Hashem avenged their
blood or not?
The answer is that although Hashem will avenge the blood of
Jewish martyrs, the primary vengeance will be incomplete until G-
d dwells in Zion, until G-d and His people return from their
dispersion among the nations. This is the explanation for our
verse, as well. When G-d refers to himself as "Ani" / "I", he is
referring to His attribute of vengeance. Indeed, "Ani" is an
acronym for "E-l nekamot Hashem" / "Hashem is the G-d of
vengeance." When will G-d be "Ani" / the G-d of vengeance? When
you come into the Land! (Quoted in Otzrot Tzaddikei U'geonei
Ha'dorot)
********
"The seventh year shall be a complete rest for the land . .
."
(25:3)
R' Moshe ibn Chaviv z"l (1654-1696; "Rishon Le'tzion" and
author of several halachic works) writes: The laws of shemittah,
as well as the laws of terumah and ma'aser, did not take effect
until 14 years after Bnei Yisrael entered Eretz Yisrael,
specifically, after they completed their conquest of the Land.
Why? The purpose of the agricultural laws is to remind us that G-
d is the Master of the Land, not we. As long as Bnei Yisrael did
not yet control the Land, they did not need that reminder.
He adds: Why is shemittah only one year in seven? Why should
we not be reminded more often that the Land is G-d's? There are
two answers: First, G-d has mercy on us, so He lets us work our
Land for six years. In addition, it is not unusual for farmers
to leave their fields fallow every third year or so in order to
let the land rejuvenate. In order to make clear that this is not
the purpose of shemittah, the Torah commanded that shemittah be
observed only once every seven years.
(Derashot Maharam Chaviv)
********
"If you will say, `What will we eat in the seventh year?'" (25:20)
R' Yisrael Isserlin z"l (author of Terumat Ha'deshen; died
1460) asks: Why would people worry about what they will eat in
the seventh (i.e., the shemittah) year? In the seventh year they
will eat the produce of the sixth year. If they have anything to
worry about at all, it should be the eighth year!
He answers: It is human nature for people to hoard their
belongings for the future. Thus, when they realize that there
will be no harvest in the seventh year, they will hoard the
produce of the sixth year to eat in the eighth year. Then they
will worry, "What will we eat in the seventh year?"
(Beur Mahari)
********
"If your brother becomes impoverished . . . , ve'ha'chazakta
bo."
(25:35)
R' Eliezer Zusia Portugal z"l (the Skulener Rebbe) observes
that the grammatically correct form of this verse would seem to
have been: "If your brother becomes impoverished . . . ,
ve'chizakta oto / you shall strengthen him." Why does the verse
say, "ve'ha'chazakta bo" / "you shall be strengthened through
him"?
R' Portugal explains based on the Chafetz Chaim's similar
question about Mishlei (3:18), "It [the Torah] is a tree of life
for those who hold-on to it." Since this verse is speaking of
those who give financial support to Torah study, should it not
have said, "for those who uphold it"? This verse's lesson is
that the Torah doesn't need man's support. Rather, the Torah's
merit supports those who give to its institutions and students.
Says R' Portugal: Our verse teaches the same lesson, but about
supporting the poor. G-d has many agents through whom to support
them. The one who truly benefits - the one who is strengthened -
is the one who gives charity.
(Noam Eliezer)
********
Pirkei Avot
"Ben Zoma says, `Who is wealthy? One who is happy with his
portion'."
(Chapter 4, Mishnah 1)
R' Yoel Sirkes z"l (the Bach; 1561-1640) explains: Every
person's earnings are made up of two parts - the portion that a
person is obligated to gives as terumah, ma'aser, and charity,
and the portion that is his to enjoy. Some people are not happy
unless they keep both shares for themselves, but a truly wealthy
person is the one who is content with keeping his own portion and
giving the other portion to its rightful recipients.
(Meishiv Nefesh: Introduction)
***
"R' Yose says, `Whoever honors the Torah will himself be
honored by people'." (4:6)
Rashi explains: This refers to a person who does not put a
sefer [e.g., a chumash or siddur] on a bench on which someone is
sitting.
***
"If you neglect the study of Torah . . ." (4:10)
The Gemara (Chagigah 5b) states that there are three people
over whom Hashem cries every day: (1) someone who is able to
occupy himself ("la'asok") with Torah study, but who does not
occupy himself thus; (2) someone who is unable to occupy himself
with Torah study, but does occupy himself thus; and (3) a
communal leader who acts haughtily. R' Ovadiah Yosef shlita
writes: The second of these three descriptions requires
explanation. [At first glance, the gemara appears to be speaking
of a person who has many distractions that legitimately prevent
him from studying Torah, yet he makes time to study anyway.] Why
should G-d cry over such a person?
R' Yosef answers: This is not a correct understanding of the
Mishnah. The term "to occupy oneself" / "la'asok" refers to
advanced Torah study learning such as is necessary to render
halachic decisions. The Gemara (Ta'anit 10b) records that Yosef
told his brothers not to occupy themselves with Torah study on
their return trip to Eretz Canaan. (See Bereishit 45:24 and
Rashi.) Yet, the Gemara states that if two Torah scholars are
traveling together and are not exchanging divrei Torah, they
deserve to die. The Gemara itself resolves this contradiction by
explaining that Yosef was referring to in-depth Torah study,
while the other Talmudic statement is referring to less taxing
study. Here, too, explains R' Yosef, what Hashem cries over is
people who are not fit to render halachic rulings but do so
anyway.
(Anaf Etz Avot)
********
R' Shaul Yedidya Elazar Taub z"l
R' Shaul Yedidya Elazer Taub, the second Modzhitzer Rebbe, was
born in the city of Osherov, Poland, on Hoshanah Rabba 5647 /
October 20, 1886. Modzhitz chassidut is known for its music, and
from young Shaul's birth, an auspicious future as a musician was
foretold for him, for not only was he born on the day before
Simchat Torah, but the year of his birth was "zemirot" ("songs").
R' Shaul assumed the leadership of Modzhitz in 1920 upon the
passing of his father, R' Yisrael. At the outbreak of World War
II, R' Shaul made his way through Lithuania, Russia, China and
Japan, then to San Francisco, and, from there, to New York. From
1940 until 1947 he resided in Brooklyn, New York. During this
time, he traveled extensively, bringing Torah and chassidic music
to many communities. It is claimed that he was probably the most
prolific Hasidic composer of all time with his total compositions
numbering close to 1000. The famous chazzan, Ben Zion Shenker,
was his musical secretary.
In keeping with a tradition established by his father, R'
Shaul created new melodies for the Hallel text so that the verses
could be sung as marches. It is reported that when chassidim
questioned both the composition and singing of such march tunes
by a people without country, flag or military, R' Shaul's
responded prophetically that a Jewish State would soon come into
being and that marches would then needed.
R' Shaul was also renowned for his Torah learning and for his
love for Am Yisrael. He was especially known for his
extraordinary love for Eretz Yisrael. He said: "Certainly,
Yeshivat Eretz Yisrael / living in Eretz Yisrael is no less
important a mitzvah than putting on tefilin. Would one think
that he can perform the mitzvah of tefilin simply by thinking
about it or intending or wanting to do it? Even with the
greatest of intentions, one who does not actually tie the tefilin
onto his arm and head does not fulfill any mitzvah. The same is
true of Yeshivat Eretz Yisrael." R' Shaul himself visited Eretz
Yisrael three times from Poland. His fourth and last trip to
Eretz Yisrael was from the United States in 1947, and he planned
to settle there on that occasion. Suddenly, however, he became
ill, and he passed away on Shabbat, 16 Kislev 5708 / November
29,1947, the very day that the U.N. voted to partition
"Palestine" and create a Jewish state. It is believed that R'
Shaul was the last person buried on Har Hazeitim (Mount of
Olives) until after the Six Day War. (Source: www.modzitz.org)
Copyright © 2002 by Shlomo Katz
and Project Genesis, Inc.
The editors hope these brief 'snippets' will engender further study
and discussion of Torah topics ("lehagdil Torah u'leha'adirah"), and
your letters are appreciated. Web archives at Project Genesis
start with 5758 (1997) and
may be retrieved from the Hamaayan page.
Text archives from 1990 through the present
may be retrieved from
http://www.acoast.com/~sehc/hamaayan/. Donations
to HaMaayan are tax-deductible.
|