Volume 27, No. 11
Sponsored by Milton Cahn in memory of his mother
Abby Cahn (Bracha bat Moshe a"h)
and his wife Felice Cahn
(Faygah Sarah bat Naftoli Zev a"h)
Arline & Irving Katz and Robert & Hannah Klein,
extending a “yasher koach” to
Gordon Lederman for his help
We read in our parashah (45:1), “Yosef could not restrain himself in the
presence of all who stood before him, so he called out, ‘Remove everyone
from before me!’ Thus no one remained with him when Yosef made himself
known to his brothers.” Midrash Tanchuma comments that Yosef behaved
improperly, for he risked his life by remaining alone with his brothers, who
did not yet know his identity. Nevertheless, Yosef found that risk
preferable to shaming his brothers in front of the Egyptians when he
R’ Chaim ben Attar z”l (1696-1743) writes, citing the Zohar, that there are
seven tzaddikim who parallel the seven days of the week. The tzaddik who
parallels Shabbat is Yosef. Shabbat is associated with shalom / peace or
harmony, as reflected in the greeting, “Shabbat Shalom,” and the blessing,
“Ha’porais sukkat shalom / He who spreads the shelter of peace over us . .
.” (Ohr Ha’chaim to Vayikra 19:3)
What is the connection between Shabbat and shalom? R’ Aryeh Finkel shlita
(rosh yeshiva of the Mir Yeshiva in Modi’in Ilit, Israel) explains: Our
Sages say that Shabbat is the source of all blessing. And, the Mishnah (end
of Tractate Uktzin) states: “Hashem found no vessel that could hold a
blessing other than shalom.” Thus, the blessing of Shabbat requires shalom.
R’ Finkel continues: In light of the midrash quoted above, we can see how
Yosef exemplifies the trait of shalom, preferring to risk his life rather
than shame another person. In next week’s parashah we read, as well
(50:21), how Yosef “comforted them and spoke to their hearts.” Similarly,
says the midrash, at the time of the Final Redemption, Hashem will console
Yerushalayim and speak to her heart (see Yeshayah 40:1-2). (Yavo Shiloh)
“Yosef said to his brothers, ‘I am Yosef. Is my father still alive?’ But
his brothers could not answer him because they were frightened before him.”
R’ Shlomo Algazi z”l (1610-1677; Izmir, Turkey) asks: After Yehuda had been
speaking at length about Yaakov’s pain, why would Yosef ask, “Is my father
still alive?” Also, why were Yosef’s brothers unable to answer him?
We read later (45:27), “The spirit of their father Yaakov was revived
(literally, ‘came alive’).” Rashi z”l explains this to mean that the
Shechinah rested upon him. It was in this sense that Yosef was asking
whether Yaakov was “alive.” “My father was a prophet. Why didn’t he know
where I was all these years?”
Yosef’s brothers were unable to answer this question, for they understood
that their actions were the cause of Yaakov’s losing his ruach ha’kodesh.
“I am the Kel -- Elokim of your father; have no fear of descending to Egypt,
for I shall establish you as a great nation there.” (46:3)
Why would the information that he would become a great nation in Egypt
console Yaakov? R’ Yosef David Sinzheim z”l (1745-1812; Chief Rabbi of
Strasbourg, France) explains: Yaakov was aware of Avraham’s prophecy
regarding a 400-year exile, and he feared that decree. Hashem responded: Do
not fear! Your descendants’ numbers will be so great that they will finish
the work of 400 years in only 210 years, as actually happened. (Shlal David)
“Then Yisrael said to Yosef, ‘Now I can die, after my having seen your face,
because you are still alive’.” (46:30)
R' Aharon Dovid Goldberg shlita (Rosh Ha’yeshiva of Telshe-Cleveland) asks:
Earlier we read (45:27), “[Yaakov] saw the wagons that Yosef had sent to
transport him, and the spirit of their father Yaakov was revived.” Rashi
z”l explains that this verse alludes to the fact that Yosef had informed his
brothers of the Torah subject he had been studying with Yaakov at the time
he left him. If his spirit was revived then, what is the meaning of
Yaakov’s exclamation now?
R’ Goldberg explains: Our Sages speak of the importance of seeing the face
of one’s teacher. For example, in Eruvin (13b), Rabbi Yehuda Ha’nasi says,
“The reason I am sharper than my friends is because I saw the back of Rabbi
Meir. Had I seen his face, I would have been sharper still.” R’ Yitzchak
of Volozhin z”l (1780-1848) explains (in his introduction to his father’s
work, Nefesh Ha’Chaim) that a person’s words and deeds convey only his
outermost thoughts, while his deeper thoughts are conveyed by the “glow” on
his face. Thus, writes R’ Goldberg, Yaakov was pleased when he saw from
Yosef’s deeds and heard from Yosef’s words that Yosef remembered his
learning. However, Yaakov could not know Yosef’s deeper feelings until he
saw him. (U’vacharta B’Chaim Al Nefesh Ha’Chaim p.7)
Elsewhere in the Torah . . .
When one says the Divine name “Elokim” while reciting a berachah, he should
have in mind that it means, “Mighty and All-Powerful and Master of all
powers.” (Shulchan Aruch: O.C. 5:1)
What does it mean that G-d is “Master of all powers”? R’ Chaim of Volozhin
z”l (1749-1821) explains:
When a human builder constructs a building out of wood, he does not create
the wood or other raw materials; rather, he takes wood that was created
previously and arranges it in his structure. When he is finished
constructing the building, he departs the scene, yet the building remains
standing behind him.
Not so G-d. With His unlimited powers, He created everything from nothing.
(All the raw materials out of which His creations are made are also His
creations.) And, since then, He re-creates everything at every moment of
every day, meaning that the continued existence of all of Creation is
dependent upon His continuous Will that it exist. In contrast to a human
builder, if G-d would “depart” the scene, nothing of His “building” (the
world) would continue to exist.
This, concludes R’ Chaim, is the meaning of “Master of all powers,” i.e.,
that no powers or forces can exist or endure independent of His Will.
(Nefesh Ha’Chaim I ch.2)
R’ Yisrael Elya Weintraub z”l (Brooklyn, N.Y. and Bnei Brak, Israel;
1932-2010) explains further: When man builds something out of wood, for
example, he is not doing something that is contrary to the wood’s nature.
It is inherent in the wood’s nature to submit to the forces that the builder
applies to it. That is why the builder doesn’t have to remain with the wood
after his work is finished; the material was wood before and it is wood now;
its essence is unchanged.
Not so when Hashem makes something. For example, when He split the Yam Suf
and the water formed a wall, that was not something that is in water’s
nature to do. Thus, if G-d had not maintained the wall of water, it would
have ceased to stand.
Similarly, none of Creation exists naturally. Therefore, if G-d would not
maintain it continuously, it would cease to exist. It follows that He is
“Master of all powers.” Man appears to have powers, as do angels, animals,
and even plants. In reality, though, G-d continuously causes those powers
to exist. Thus, He is the sole Master of all powers. (Yirat Chaim Al
Letters from Our Sages
This letter was written by R’ Shimshon David Pinkus z”l (rabbi of Ofakim,
Israel; died 2001) in response to a question by a reader of R’ Pinkus’ Torah
I received your letter, and I am very grateful to you that you read the book
Tiferet Torah. It is a great merit [for an author] when Torah scholars read
Regarding Yosef [this reference will be returned to below] – There is no
question that the kinyan / method of acquisition by which Yisrael acquired
the Land and will acquire it again in the future is the kinyan of “kibbush”
/ conquest. This is an effective method of kinyan, and the complaints of
the nations of the world [against Israel] do not arise from the method of
acquisition used, for those nations also obtained their lands by conquest.
Think about it! The nations of the world say [to us], “You are thieves!”
But is there any nation which has been living in its current land since the
generation of the Tower of Bavel [when the nations of the world were first
formed]? All nations obtained their lands by conquest from one another.
What then is their complaint? They are asking, “Is it right [for Yisrael to
conquer land]? It is understandable that we [the nations] should do so.
After all, we [the nations] are heirs of Esav who received the blessing
(Bereishit 27:40), ‘You shall live by your sword,’ and of Yishmael, who was
blessed with the words (Bereishit 16:12), ‘He shall be a wild man.’ But you
are righteous! How can you do such a thing?”
This is why the Torah goes to lengths to defend our actions [by relating
that Hashem created the world and gave Eretz Yisrael to the nation of His
choosing]. Our honesty is demonstrated by Yosef [at the end of this week’s
parashah]. He could have kept the Egyptians’ land for himself [when they
gave it in exchange for food], but he did not do so. He acted as if he did
not exist and gave every-thing to Pharaoh. . . .
Signed with respect and friendship, Shimshon David Pinkus
The editors hope these brief 'snippets' will engender further study
and discussion of Torah topics ('lehagdil Torah u'leha'adirah'), and
your letters are appreciated. Web archives at Torah.org start with 5758 (1997) and
may be retrieved from the Hamaayan page.
Hamaayan needs your support! Please consider sponsoring Hamaayan in honor of a happy occasion or in memory of a loved one. The low cost of sponsorship is $36. Donations to HaMaayan are tax-deductible.