BREAKING SOMETHING IN A STORE
QUESTION 80: BREAKING SOMETHING IN A STORE
If you break something in a store, who is the person you should
ask whether or not you have to pay for it? Should it be the owner,
manager, or is it okay to ask a cashier or salesperson. I've
found that cashiers and salespeople invariably say it's okay,
since they don't lose anything. For example, in a supermarket
chain, my daughter broke a large yogurt, and the cashier refused
to accept payment. Am I still required to go ask the store manager?
RABBI BELSKY
I would simply say that when it comes to a very small item,
like a yogurt - maybe a little less or a little more - you could
ask the cashier. I believe the cashiers are told that they
should be nice and polite, and that it's not good for the
reputation of the store to be very strict with customers. So
this isn't a problem. Since it's important for public relations
to establish a sort of flexibility, they generally don't mind.
When it comes to anything larger than just a dollar or so, if
someone damaged a large item, he should take it to the
management and say, "This happened accidentally, but nevertheless,
I'm responsible." The manager will very likely say, "Don't
worry about it," since he still wants to follow the "customer
leniency" policy of the supermarket. But still, you should ask.
When it comes to a smaller item, however, you can go to the
cashier, and you don't have to go to someone higher up.
NEXT WEEK'S QUESTION 81: CLOTHES INTENDED FOR CHARITY
As I gained weight, I put aside some clothes to give to charity.
I assumed that since the clothes did not fit me, I would not need
them anymore. I felt that even if I might be able to wear them
later, I would still buy new clothes. Several months later, I
lost enough weight so that the clothes fit me again. I had never
gotten around to giving the clothes away as intended from the
beginning. I would like to now use at least some of the clothes.
Am I allowed to wear the clothes temporarily until I give them
away? Can I opt to not donate them at all, and wear them on a
permanent basis?
Participate in the Honesty Forum, and discuss the issues we confront in this class!
Subscribe to Honesty and receive this class via e-mail.
