Breaking The News
By Rabbi Daniel Travis
"[The brothers] broke the news to [Yaakov]: “Yosef is still alive, and
he rules over all the land of Egypt.” But [Yaakov’s] heart became numb,
for he could not believe them." (Bereshith 45:26)
The verse’s description of Yaakov’s heart becoming numb should not be
taken allegorically. Yaakov was already advanced in age and the news that
his son was still alive was a tremendous shock to his system which caused
him to pass out and caused minor cardiac dysfunction (1).
It is always important to consider how the recipient of the information
will receive the tidings. One must be particularly careful when delivering
traumatic news, especially when dealing with the elderly. If someone on
his death bed asks about his condition, it is forbidden to tell him bad
news because in his weak condition this knowledge could prove life
Therefore, when Avraham took Yitzchak to be sacrificed, he did not tell
Sarah where he was going, in order not to upset her. While they were gone,
the Satan came to her and told her what was about to transpire. After God
commanded Avraham not to sacrifice Yitzchak, the Satan returned to her and
blurted out the good news. As a result of the tremendous joy that her son
was still alive, Sarah immediately died.
Whenever possible, it is preferable not to relate bad news altogether.
Therefore, if you heard that a certain individual died, and someone asks
you about it, it is best to avoid disclosing the information (3). This is
among the things about which our Sages advise us to act as if we have no
knowledge (4). If asked, one may even answer, “I don’t know” (5).
Nevertheless, we should not declare that an individual is alive if we know
that he is not (6). Rather one should say, “He is in need of mercy,” or
some other non-committal but true reply (7).
1. Seforno, Radak on Bereshith 45:26.
2. Sha’arei De’ah 337, P’nei Baruch 1:1:29. Similarly, if someone must
eat non-kosher food for health reasons, and he refuses to eat it, or if
the knowledge that the food is not kosher will cause him distress, it is
permitted to tell him that the food is kosher.
3. Pesachim 3b.
4. Brachoth 4a.
5. Kalah Rabbathi Ch. 5; Rav Shlomo Zalman Aeurbach, Rav Yosef Shalom
Elyashiv and Rav Yisrael Yaakov Fisher as quoted in Titein Emeth L’Yaakov
6. Shulchan Aruch, Yoreh De’ah 402:12.
7. Titein Emeth L’Yaakov p. 161.
Text Copyright © 2007 by Rabbi Daniel Travis and Torah.org