For The Sake Of Peace III
By Rabbi Daniel Travis
Yosef’s brothers began to realize [the implications] of their father’s
death. “What if Yosef is still holding a grudge against us?” they
said. “He is likely to pay us back for all the evil we did him.” They
instructed messengers to tell Yosef: “Before he died, your father gave us
final instructions. He said, ‘This is what you must say to Yosef: Forgive
the spiteful deed and the sin your brothers committed when they did evil
to you.’ Now forgive the spiteful deed that [we,] the servants of your
father’s God, have done.” (Bereshith 50:15-17)
From these verses the Gemara derives that one may for the sake of peace
deviate from factual integrity, for Yaakov never suspected Yosef and had
given them no such command.1 The above verses teach us that one may
initiate such a remark even if nothing has yet directly happened to
threaten the peace.2 Although the brothers had sold Yosef into slavery,
that had happened many years before, and during the many years that had
passed since they had been reunited, Yosef had not shown any sign that he
would harm them. Nevertheless, since the brothers feared that Yosef might
have been restraining himself for Yaakov’s sake, they were permitted now
that their father had died to say whatever they thought necessary to
preserve the peace.
A common application of this principle is that a woman may make flattering
remarks about the beauty of a bride even if no one has asked for his
opinion. One might think that it is better simply to keep silent if one
does not see the bride’s beauty, however the Sages felt that silence in
such a case would detract from the couple’s joy at their wedding. However
our Sages established that in such a case one should only say “the bride
is charming and beautiful”, because there is an element of truth to it.3
Every bride is beautiful in the eyes of her husband, for if this were not
the case, he would not be marrying her.4
Seen from a different angle, there can be no harmful consequences to
saying that she is beautiful, and furthermore, this is an accepted figure
of speech.5 For these reasons, a bride is to be praised for her beauty and
charm even if one personally does not consider her beautiful.6
1. Rashi on Bereshith 50:17.
2. Aruch L’Ner Yevamoth 65b.
3. Masecheth Kallah Rabbathi Ch. 10.
4. Maharsha Ketuvoth 17a; Taz, Shulchan Aruch Even HaEzer 65:1.
5. Responsa Zacher Yosef 1:70.
6. Tosfoth Ketuvoth 17a, Shulchan Aruch Even HaEzer 65:1.
Text Copyright © 2009 by Rabbi Daniel Travis and Torah.org