Cry To Hashem
By Rabbi Daniel Travis
"The prophets and the beis din in the days of Mordechai and Esther
commanded that we should read the megilah on Purim in order to proclaim
the praises of Hashem and the salvations that He wrought through the merit
of our tefilos. In this way we will bless and praise m'varech and m'hallel
Hashem, and establish for all generations the truth of which the Torah
writes "Which nation is so great that Hashem answers them when we cry out
to Him." (Rambam in his introduction to his minyan hamitzvos).
Face to face with the threat of complete annihilation, Mordechai directed
us to turn our hearts to Hashem in prayer. On the thirteenth of Adar,
before going to war against our adversaries, the Jewish people fasted and
prayed that they should succeed in battle. Ta'anis Esther was established
to commemorate this day of fasting and prayer tzom and tefilah (Rosh,
If we have tzaros we usually consider davening as a means to be freed
from them. In truth however, troubles are the "illness" and tefilla is
the "cure." The real reason for our tzaros is that Hashem wants to hear
our tefillos (Rav Chatkel Levenstein zt"l). Before we can appreciate the
myriad of hidden miracles that Hashem did for us during the days of
Mordechai and Esther, we first need Ta'anis Esther in order to focus on
the fact that all the tribulations and subsequent redemption were for the
purpose of reestablishing a relationship with our Creator.
Purim On Sunday
When Purim is on Sunday, we are presented with a problem in regards to
Taanis Esther. Since we do not fast on Shabbos (with the exception of Yom
Kippur), the fast should be observed on Friday. However in most cases our
Sages did not allow a public taanis on Friday, due to the numerous
additional prayers which would seriously cut into Shabbos- preparation
time and cause us to enter Shabbos famished after the fast. We therefore
observe Taanis Esther on the previous Thursday.
Altering the date of the fast has an impact on how the day is observed.
Since the ta'anis is coming to commerate an event that took place on a
specific day, changing the date of the fast allows us to be lenient in
regards to certain halachos. Understanding where our Sages allowed
leniences offers us insight into the nature of this special fast day.
One ramification regards the issue of making a bris on the day of Taanis
Esther. The Rema argues that since this is not the official time of the
fast, the baal bris and all of his guests may break the fast for the sake
of the seudas milah. They are nonetheless obligated to make up for the
fast on Friday (Shulchan Aruch 686,2).
If our Sages saw a danger in establishing a taanis on Friday, then why
should it be alright for the sake of a bris? Since everyone else is
fasting on Thursday, the extra tefilos will be recited then and not on
Friday, so this issue ceases to be a problem. A number of great halachic
authorities concur with this ruling of the Rema (Shvus Yaakov and Mor
Some opinions, however, take a more stringent view and argue that when
Chazal established Thursday as the altered date of the fast, Thursday is
now its correct time and the taanis may not be pushed off for the sake of
a milah. The seudah should then be celebrated after breaking the fast, as
is usually done when a bris takes place on a fast day (Taz and Elia Raba
ibid, Chaye Adam 155,3).
At this point we might be tempted to ask, "Isn't it preferable to stay
clear of dispute, and just put the seudah off until after the fast has
concluded?" It is worthwhile to consider that bris milah transforms the
day into a Yom Tov for the person who makes the bris. Yom Tov is a time
for celebration and rejoicing, and in this light, delaying the seudah is
not a simple matter.
On the other hand, pushing off the fast to the following day is also
problematic, because eating on a day when everyone else is fasting is
considered separating oneself from the rest of the community. Furthermore,
fasting on erev-Shabbos is problematic, for one would enter Shabbos in a
famished state. Since there are many factors to be taken into account
before arriving at a final ruling on this complex halachic question, a
rabbinic authority should be consulted (Mishna Berura 686,7).
Backwards and Forwards
There is a striking difference between when Ta'anis Esther comes out on
Shabbos, and when the fast of Tisha B'Av falls on a Shabbos. While the
fast of Esther is moved forwards, the fast of Tisha B'Av is pushed off
until Sunday. Why is one tzom made sooner and the other postponed?
The fast of Esther was established to remember the miracles that took
place in the days of Mordechai. With regard to miracles, we do not want to
delay their commemoration. Conversely Tisha B'Av commemorates Hashem's
punishment of the Jewish people. Therefore we try and delay the fast as
long as we can (Shailtos, Vayikahal 20).
The poskim note another interesting difference between the altered dates
of the two fasts.Some opinions allow everyone invited to the bris on the
fast of Esther to break their fast in order to participate in the seudas
mitzvah. However regarding a bris on the tenth of Av, only the baal bris,
sandak and mohel are allowed to break the fast after mincha. The reason
for this is that all opinions agree that in such a case the tenth of Av is
the proper time for the milah, [J1]and consequently we must treat this
fast day more stringently. After the ta'anis has ended, the main seudah is
celebrated (Shaar Hatzion 686,13).
Asarah B'Teves, Sheva Asar B'Tamuz, and Tzom Gedalia are days of sadness.
Accordingly there is a custom to observe a minimum amount of mourning
beforehand and not to take a hot shower on the night before (Sha'ar
Hatzion 550,8). Others have the minhag to treat the night before these
fasts (excluding Tzom Gedalia) with all the halachos of the nine days, and
forbid weddings on these two nights (Biur Halachah (551,1). Since Ta'anis
Esther is a joyous day, none of these restrictions are applicable (Rav
Shlomo Zalman Auerbach zt"l as cited in Halichos Shlomo 18,6).In this
vein, many have the custom to break ta'anis Esther with a meat meal, even
though this is forbidden on other fast days (with the exception of Yom
Generally we recite Avinu Malkeinu during mincha of a fast day. However on
Taanis Esther, which falls just before the Ytom Tov of Purim, we do not
say this tefilah. Nevertheless if Purim falls on a Sunday, and the fast is
pushed off until Thursday, then Avinu Malkeinu is recited (Mishna Berura
Making Up the Fast
There was once a woman who had to meet with the sultan on the thirteenth
of Adar. Traveling was not an easy matter, and she was afraid that if she
fasted, she would be too worn out to meet with the ruler of her country.
Could she eat on the day of her journey, and make up the fast on Friday?
Her question was brought before Rashi, and he responded that the halachos
pertaining to Taanis Esther are more lenient than those of other fast
days, for it is a custom and not an obligatory taanis. Nonetheless eating
on the thirteenth of Adar is considered to be separating oneself from the
rest of the community, a possible Torah prohibition (Devarim 14,1).
Therefore, Rashi obligated her to fast on that day (cited in Shebulei
HaLeket 194, Mishna Berura 686,6).
A person who is sick however, is not permitted to fast on Taanis Esther or
on any other fast days except for Yom Kipur, and in doing so is not
considered to be separating himself from the community. How sick must one
be in order to fit into this category? On Taanis Esther, even an eye ache
that makes one very uncomfortable would be sufficient grounds to break the
fast (Shulchan Aruch 686,2).
Depending on the situation, the missed taanis may have to be made up later
in the month of Adar. Since the fasts comes to commemorate the tefilos and
fasting before Purim, what is the point of fasting afterwards? [J2]Some
have the custom to fsat Bahab after Purim in commemoration of the three
days of fasting that Esther declared necessary for the entire Jewish
nation preceding her momentous confrontation with Achashverosh to plead
for the plight of her people (Shaarei Tzion 686,11). Therefore the end of
Adar is also considered an appropriate time to "make up" Taanis Esther. In
all cases a halachic authority should be consulted (Mishna Berura 686,5).
Annuling Harsh Decrees
Kabalistic literature reveals another reason behind the fast of Esther.
Even though Haman's plans were overturned, a small part of the decree
remained. Every year, at the time that his plans were to be carried out,
the Satan comes to Hashem, claiming that the Jewish people should be
destroyed. In this vein some mekubalim find an indication in the megilah
about the massacres of Tat VTach (pagroms that took place in those years),
for the letter teis (in the word tichtov) and the letter cheis (in the
word chor) hint to the tragic year of "tach", the start of these assaults
(as cited in Responsa Shevet HaKahasi 1,203).
The Rambam writes that when the Jewish people are experiencing such tragic
situations, the Torah obligates us to cry out to Hashem and sound trumpets
to arouse us to repentance (Bamidbar 10:9). If we realize that our own
actions are at the root of our difficulties, we will learn to mend our
ways and cause the harsh decree to be rescinded. If we don't follow this
path, and instead relate to what is happening as mere coincidence, the
tzaros will simply increase (Rambam, Hilchos Taanis 1:1-3, Mishna Berura
In the merit of our fasting and prayers this Taanis Esther may all past
decrees on the Jewish people be overturned, all future decrees annulled,
and may all of Haman's evil intentions be put to an end once and for all.
Text Copyright © 2004 Rabbi Daniel Travis and Torah.org.