Part 6: Chapter 1, Verses 7-8
7. "And the Lord said to Satan, Where have you been? Satan said "I've been
going back and forth, and walking up and down across the earth."
8. "And the Lord said to Satan, have you seen my servant Job? Is there
anyone else like him, any earnest, upright, G-d fearing man who stays away
The Satan's response to G-d needs some explanation. Why was he wandering
"back and forth, and walking up and down across the earth"? The Malbim
elucidates this in the following way. The manifestation of evil in this
world is destruction of varying forms and degrees. Destruction exists only
in the physical realm. Hence, the Satan can carry out his functions only
within the perimeters of this world. He must, therefore, spend his time
meandering around the earth.
Destruction manifests itself in three ways.
1. By way of the natural vulnerability of animate objects to disease, death
and their subsequent decomposition.
2. Death and havoc inflicted by violent eruptions of forces of nature and
3. Acts of folly and wickedness perpetrated by man.
The "wandering back and forth, and walking up and down across the earth"
indicates that the Satan is responsible for delivery of all of the above
should man's evil actions grant him license to do so. The world of the
spiritual is by its very nature immune to these phenomena. This means that
the Satan can accomplish his mission only in the physical world. We shall
understand the significance of this in the next verse.
It seems only logical that in this verse the Satan should begin his
prosecution of Iyov in light of the fact that G-d has just granted him the
permission to do so (see our commentary part 5b). Instead, G-d takes the
floor and begins proclaiming the virtues of Iyov. Apparently the Satan had
nothing to say. Indeed, was he not described as a totally "upright, G-d
fearing man who stayed away from evil" (in verse 1). Iyov was exceedingly
agitated and disturbed by his suffering. We can readily justify his
attitude. Even G-d testified to his sterling character.
The Malbim explains the significance of the Divine testimony. Evil and
destruction are natives of the physical world. Man was created from
physical matter along with a Divine soul that his Creator breathed into
him. These two aspects of human nature are in a constant struggle. The
physical drives of man, when unrestrained, want no restrictions or
limitations. The more pleasure the better, regardless of the means and
The soul, on the other hand, desires closeness to G-d which is
accomplished only through moral and ethical discipline. As the practice of
prudent control and moderation replace unbridled physicality, we become
more spiritual than corporeal. To the extent that this transformation
progresses, conceivably, one could become immune to evil and destruction of
In light of this G-d's testimony about his servant Iyov takes on new
meaning. ".....my servant Job? Is there anyone else like him, any earnest,
upright, G-d fearing man who stays away from evil?" Iyov elevated himself
above and beyond the mundane existence of most humans. He, by his Creator's
own testimony, achieved a state of G-dliness that deemed him immune to evil
Destruction, in any of its forms can occur only within the perimeters of
the physical. G-d informs the Satan that he can have no effect upon Iyov.
His level of spiritual perfection placed him outside the Satan's
jurisdiction. Since Iyov was absolutely righteous his suffering cannot be
attributed to guilt or flaw of character.
Text Copyright © 1996 Rabbi Y. Schwartz and Project Genesis, Inc.
The author is the Rosh Hayeshiva (Dean) of
Orchos Chaim Yeshiva in Jerusalem.