Eyeing the Eye
In this week's Torah portion, the Torah deals with various types of tzoraas,
commonly mistranslated as leprosy. Tzoraas is a Heavenly affliction that
strikes a person for various transgressions he committed, most commonly for
slandering a friend.
Embedded in this form of Divine retribution are miraculous properties, one
of which is that it targets not only a person but his belongings-his house,
clothing and possessions.
The verse at the end of this week's Torah portion instructs the kohein how
to treat tzoraas when it afflicts clothing. The posuk uses a singular
expression; "vehinei lo hofach hanega es eino." If the kohein sees that the
garment even after being washed remains unclean-still contains signs of
tzoraas-it must be destroyed.
The language vehinei lo hofach hanega es eino is laden with symbolic
meaning. Ayno, literally means "its eye," which means the blemish [tzoraas]
has not changed its eye. This unusual choice of words contains profound
insights into human nature, and the working of Divine justice, explains the
saintly Chidushei Harim.
He notes that punishment of tzoraas is brought about by tzoras hoayin,
literally narrowness of the eye. [Note the similarity between tzoraas and
tzoras.] Narrowness of the eye refers to a person's tendency to view another
through negative, critical lenses. His is not the benevolent, charitable
gaze of a tov ayin, who sees the good in others, who hopes and prays for his
neighbor's well-being. The "tzar ayin" perceives only another's shortcomings
and flaws; he begrudges his neighbor's good fortune and is preoccupied with
his own ego.
The Chidushei Harim explains that when the verse says 'vehinei lo hofach
hanega es eino,' the tzoraas did not change its appearance, a double meaning
is implied. The affliction didn't change because the ayin, (eye)-the
person's negative outlook -did not change. Since the person failed to do
teshuva for his callous view and behavior toward his fellow Jew, the tzoraas
continues to attach itself to his clothes.
We explain that the word "nega" (affliction) is really the same word as
"oneg" (pleasure), and is spelled with identical Hebrew letters except for
one difference-the location of the ayin. In oneg, the ayin is at the very
beginning of the word; in nega, the ayin is at the end.
Everything is dependent on our hofach es eino, changing the eye. If we have
a "good eye," taking a positive approach to others and to life, life then
becomes a pleasure and a delight. We are connected to the Divine for we see
the innate goodness and Divine energy within one another. However, the
metzora who continues to demonstrate mean-spiritedness remains with the
nega; he has not been able to change his "eye." He is preoccupied only with
himself and therefore, is appropriately afflicted.
Most of us have a bit of tzar ayin in our nature. A Jew's responsibility is
to convert that trait and become a tov ayin, a person with a benevolent eye.
In Biblical times, only when the metzorah succeeded in uprooting his
negativism toward others did the affliction disappear. Today, we do not have
that powerful incentive to spur us to change. Yet it is still incumbent on
us to try to improve our character. When we have "a good eye," we are happy
with our lot and judge others charitably. We walk with a spring in our step
and uplifted spirit. We are at peace.
If we harbor feelings of being shortchanged and look at others begrudgingly,
however, then we are truly afflicted. Although highlighting others'
shortcomings may be temporarily gratifying, keeping a jaundiced eye will
prove toxic in the end-to ourselves.
Wishing you a wonderful Shabbos,
Rabbi Naftali Reich
Text Copyright © 2014 by Rabbi Naftali Reich and Torah.org.
Rabbi Reich is on the faculty of the Ohr Somayach Tanenbaum Education Center.