by Rabbi Yaakov Menken
"And Noach went in, and his sons, and his wife, and his sons' wives, went
with him into the Ark, because of the waters of the flood." [Gen. 7:7]
Rabbi Shlomo Yitzchaki says (from the Medrash Tanchuma) that Noach
"believed and did not believe" that there would be a flood, so he did not
enter the Ark until the last moment, when the rising water forced him to
What does this mean? This comment by Rashi would appear to make no sense.
The Medrash tells us that Noach built the Ark over a period of 120 years,
to save himself and his family! If he doubted the flood was coming, why was
he building a boat in his backyard?
Several years ago, a small yeshiva in Israel was attempting to recruit more
students. One Rabbi there was familar with a high school in America, and he
strongly believed that the students of that school would benefit most if
they continued their studies in his yeshiva. So he called a friend, a
teacher there, and asked - since the students didn't know the Israeli Rabbi
- if the latter himself could work to convince his students that they
should go to the yeshiva in question.
The American Rabbi replied that unfortunately, he would be unable to
fulfill his friend's request. Not because he didn't believe that the
yeshiva had wonderful benefits, but simply because he had not had the
opportunity to observe and to become fully convinced that this was indeed
the destination of choice for his students. He explained his position by
referring to Noach in our parsha.
The reason why Noach was supposed to take such a long time building the Ark
is because it offered people a last opportunity to change their behavior.
They would come and ask Noach what he was doing, and he would explain - and
encourage them to abandon their immorality before it was too late. And yet
he had no impact; no one outside Noach's immediate family was spared. Asked
the Rabbi: was Noach so much worse than Rabbi Noach Weinberg? [Rabbi
Weinberg, the Dean of Aish HaTorah institutions, is world-renowned in
Jewish outreach.] Why was Noach unable to convince even one member of his
generation to change his behavior?
The answer is that there is a great difference between belief of the mind
and belief of the heart. It is one thing to believe intellectually that
something is true, and quite another to feel it intensely, in the heart.
The Birkas Peretz says that Noach certainly believed the flood was
coming... but on an intellectual level. If he had internalized this
knowledge and had truly feared the coming flood, he would certainly have
entered the Ark immediately.
It was for this reason, explained the Rabbi, that Noach could not affect
his generation. Because he himself only believed that the flood was coming
on an intellectual level, he had no impact. Had he feared the destruction
on a visceral, internal level, _then_ he would have been able to reach
others. [It should be pointed out that this doubt was not necessarily a
point against Noach - many say that he held onto the hope that G-d would be
merciful, even at the last moment. But in any case, it made no difference:]
Since Noach did not feel absolute certainty in his heart, he could not
adequately transmit this fear to others.
The same principle held true for the Rabbi, and it holds true for us: if
our beliefs are merely acknowledged on an intellectual level, then others
will perceive the shallowness, and our words will have little impact. If we
truly hope to influence those around us, then we must first feel the
importance of our beliefs through the core of our being.
About the Author