Chapter 2: Mishna 2 Part 3
The yetzer hara, the force of destruction in a person,
has no power over one who is in the process of "becoming."
It is for this reason that "sitting" ("yeshiva") has
negative implications. When a person is striving for
perfection, he is demonstrating that he has not yet attained
perfection but is ready for that perfection. He is in the
process of "becoming" the perfection to which he aspires.
In that situation, defects do not become attached to him.
But when he is "at rest," the implication is that he has
accomplished perfection and is no longer "becoming." At
this point, the natural process of deterioration which
exists in the created [physical] world sets in. When a
person is at rest, not striving to accomplish, he is
vulnerable to the yetzer hara. This is why all "sitting"
implies "tza'ar" (pain and suffering) and "takala"
(obstacle, stumbling block).
(There is a subtle balance that must be maintained. If
one is satisfied with ones level of growth and
accomplishment, then this attitude of having "made it"
leaves the person vulnerable to the yetzer hara. On the
other hand, if a person has low self-esteem, feeling that he
will never amount to very much and not recognizing his own
great potential, he won't be striving towards further
perfection. A person who recognizes that he is not perfect,
recognizes his potential for attaining greater perfection,
and is striving towards that perfection, is in the process
of growth, of "becoming." It is this person who is insulated
from the yetzer hara.)
When man is striving for perfection in both elements of
existence, then he is completely involved in the process of
"becoming," and he is insulated from the yetzer hara.
Derech eretz is man striving for greater perfection in the
material dimension ("guf") where he is involved in having
his physical side reach its potential. Torah is man
striving for greater perfection in his spiritual dimension,
moving his spirit ("nefesh") towards its potential.
Therefore it is specifically a person who is striving in
both Torah and derech eretz that is distanced from sin. For
if either dimension is not in the process of being
perfected, man is vulnerable to the yetzer hara in that
There is deeper level of understanding here, also. The
striving in the two areas, Torah and derech eretz, oppose
the two forces of evil that exist withing man (two yetzer
haras, if you will, two different inclinations to evil): The
inclination to improper sexual behavior ("yitzra
d'ervah")and the inclination to idol worship ("yitzra
d'avodah zarah," puruit of false values). Through striving
in the derech eretz, to perfect his physical dimension, man
eliminates the yetzer hara of sexual improprieties (which is
the uncontrolled drives of man's physical nature). The
striving of his spirit in Torah study is eliminates the
yetzer hara of worshipping false values. These matters go
to the deepest levels of wisdom, and we will not elaborate
here, since they have been explained in other places.
(The Maharsl is referring to sections in Netivot Olam,
Netiv Halshon, chapter 6, and in Netiv Koach Hayetzer,
chapter 1. We have discussed these ideas in our classes on
Chapter 1, Mishna 2. For those of you who weren't with us
then, I recommend retrieving those shiurim from the Project
The Tanna then continues "And all Torah that does not
have work accompanying it is ultimately nullified..." Due to
the fact that he lacks work, which is a componenet of man's
completion, if the Torah is not accompanied by work, man
lacks something which befits him. This is a deficiency in
his perfection, and as such it lacks the ability to endure.
"...and drags [in] sin." Something which has a
deficiency draws to it other deficiencies. Sin is the
ultimate deficiency, which is drawn ot something which lacks
perfection. Torah accompanied by work is said to distance
one from sin, even sins that to which a person is directly
vulnerable (since man is being perfected on every level).
On the other hand, Torah which is NOT accompanied by work
attracts even sins that are not directly related to his lack
of work (since the person has inadequcies that are not being
perfected). Therefore, we are taught that it is ultimately
nullifed and drags in sin, which is what happens to
something which maintains and inadequacy. And though we
know that many Torah scholars did not do work (implying
physical labor), they were involved in some kind of
commercial interactions, which is comparable to work.
Alternatively, there were special individuals who had such
an affection for and a devotion to Torah that there Torah
could be maintained without the accompaniment of and see
work. (See Yevamoth 63b about Ben Azzai who never married.
To better understanding the PRACTICAL ramifications of this
Mishna, see Orach Chaim 156, which quotes this Mishna in the
Halacha, and the Biur Halacha's commentary on it.)
The class is taught by Rabbi Shaya Karlinsky,
Dean of Darche Noam Institutions, Yeshivat
Darche Noam/Shapell's and Midreshet Rachel for Women.
SHOFTIM AND ELUL / ROSH HASHANAH:
To Hear and To See
Rabbi Aron Tendler - 5765
G-d Save the King
Rabbi Pinchas Winston - 5757
Judge Me Tender, Judge Me Sweet
Rabbi Dovid Green - 5760
Are We listening?
Rabbi Yaakov Menken - 5762
Torah is Talking to YOU
Rabbi Yissocher Frand - 5759
Rabbi Dovid Green - 5758
Rabbi Berel Wein - 5755
One Corrupt Judge May Blind Two Wise and Righteous Judges
Rabbi Yissocher Frand - 5774
'Sin... Don't Laugh!'
Rabbi Yaakov Menken - 5755
The Essence of Jewish History
Rabbi Berel Wein - 5773
One of A King
Rabbi Pinchas Winston - 5764
The Epitome of G-d's Kindness
Rabbi Yehudah Prero - 5755
Truth and a Place Called Kushta
Rabbi Eliyahu Hoffmann - 5758
Every Month Should Be Elul
Shlomo Katz - 5758
In The Shadow Of Hashem
Rabbi Yochanan Zweig - 5770
The Battle Is Joined
Shlomo Katz - 5761