Why We Want the Messiah
Chapter 9, Law 2
"On account of this, all of Israel -- their prophets and sages -- yearned
for the era of the Anointed King (the Messiah), in order that the wicked
kingdoms, who do not permit Israel to occupy itself in Torah study and
mitzvah observance properly, will be put to rest. [The Children of Israel]
will [then] enjoy serenity and will increase wisdom in order that they merit
the life of the World to Come.
"For in those days knowledge, wisdom and truth will increase, as it is
stated, 'For the land will be full of the knowledge of G-d' (Isaiah 11:9).
It [also] states, 'And a man will not teach his brother, nor a man his
fellow, [saying 'know G-d', for they will all know Me]' (Jeremiah 31:33). It
[further] states, 'I will remove the stone hearts from your flesh' (Ezekiel
"This is because that king who will rise from David's descendants will be a
wise man greater than Solomon and a great prophet nearly as great as our
teacher Moses. Therefore he will teach the entire nation and will instruct
them in the way of G-d. All of the nations will come to hear him, as it is
stated, 'And it will be in the End of Days that the mountain of G-d's house
will be established on the top of the mountains... [and all the nations
shall flow unto it. And many people will will go and say, 'Come, let us
ascend to G-d's mountain... and He will teach us of His ways...']' (Isaiah
"The final reward in it entirety and the ultimate good which will never be
interrupted or decreased is the life of the World to Come. By contrast, the
days of the Messiah is [a part of] this world, and the world will operate in
its ordinary way, just that sovereignty will return to Israel. The earliest
Sages have already stated, 'There is no difference between this world and
the days of the Messiah other than the subjugation of the nations alone'
(Talmud Brachos 34b).
This week's law closely follows the Rambam's earlier discussion. In Law 1
the Rambam explained that the rewards the Torah promises the faithful --
rain, crops, peace, good health -- are not the true reward for our deeds.
That will be in the World to Come. They are rather the fringe benefits G-d
provides us -- in order to make it easier for us to serve Him. If we serve
God to the best of our abilities, He will remove the difficulties and
distractions which draw us away from Him. We will not have to suffer hunger,
disease or war. The world will provide us with our needs -- so we will be
able to dedicate ourselves fully and wholeheartedly to the service of G-d.
This week the Rambam broadens this topic, relating it to the era of the
Messiah. There too Scripture promises world peace and harmony. And the
Rambam sees precisely the same purpose in that. The greatness of the End of
Days will be the very simple fact that we will be able to serve G-d
undisturbed. Rather than suffer exile and deprivation, Israel will be
ascendant. The entire world will recognize the G-d of Israel and unite in
His service. It will be a time of world peace, of universal enlightenment.
But perhaps best of all, nothing will stop us from studying G-d's Torah all
There is something I find enormously refreshing about the Rambam's approach
to the age of the Messiah. We tend to think of the Messianic Era in very
frightful, supernatural terms. Some apocalyptic struggle will take place --
the final showdown between good and evil. Good will ultimately triumph but
only after much blood is spilled on both sides. As I've quoted in the past,
Sages in the Talmud actually went on record as saying that they would much
rather not be around for the Messiah's coming (Sanhedrin 98b). It ain't
gonna be pretty. Unless mankind begins behaving *much* better than it
presently does, the transition to that period will be cataclysmic indeed.
Likewise, when the end comes, we tend to think of it in very otherworldly
terms. The few of mankind to survive the Armageddon will live some utterly
supernatural existence -- in a world we do not know and probably would not
care to be in. Or perhaps we see the End of Days in political terms -- as do
some other religions. The Messiah will be warrior-king, scion of King David,
running a worldwide empire of blood and steel. He will send his faithful
troops to the four corners of the earth, subjugating all the nations to
G-d's heavenly reign.
The Rambam, in refreshing contrast, depicts the age of the Messiah in much
more modest, relatable terms. When the Messiah comes, we will be granted all
we really wanted during our many years of exile: to be left alone. We will
serve G-d undisturbed. No one and nothing will hinder us. In fact, the
nations of the world will come to *us* -- far from our having to subjugate
them -- both to assist us in serving G-d and to learn G-d's wisdom from us.
It will be, more than anything else, an age of universal knowledge. "For the
land will become filled with the knowledge of G-d as the waters cover the
sea" (Isaiah 11:9).
There are two very important lessons which emerge from the Rambam's picture
of the End of Days. The first is that the Messianic Era may be viewed not as
the end of world history, but in a sense as a beginning. History is not
brought to a successful resolution with the Messiah's arrival. Judaism does
not see the Messiah as a greater-than-life figure, who will atone for us all
and single-handedly bring about world salvation. In fact, Scripture focuses
much more on the Messianic *Age* than the *person* of the Messiah.
And this is because the Messiah will merely set the stage. He will restore
world peace and rebuild the Temple. But at that point, it will be up to us.
Every one of us will devote himself to G-d and the study of His Torah. No
one else can connect to G-d for us. We will at last be able to do what we've
been wanting to do throughout most of world history -- just to study G-d's
Torah and serve Him undisturbed. With the Messiah, a utopian era will begin.
But at that point, it will be up to us to create that ideal society, a world
which is a perfect reflection of G-d.
There is a second lesson from the Rambam's description of the End of Days
which I find especially heartwarming. The Age of the Messiah is depicted as
a time of universal harmony. Mankind will unite in service of G-d. We will
all be striving towards the same noble goal, and we will all help each other
to get there.
Now, when we consider this image as compared to Israel's years in exile, a
very beautiful contrast emerges. The Jewish people have arguably been the
most mistreated, persecuted nation to have walked the face of the earth. At
best we have suffered prejudice and second class citizenship. At worst we
have faced pogroms, expulsions, and genocide. When the final judgment
arrives, there is no question that the many wrongs and injustices Israel has
suffered throughout the ages will be righted. Many unpaid debts will be
collected in full. The Messiah will have a lot of scores to settle.
Yet, even so, this image does not figure in to the Sages' description of the
End of Days in the slightest. There is no hint that at long last we will
beat up the nations who for so long have bullied us. We do not see the age
of the Messiah as one in which we will gloat or have the last laugh, those
despicable nonbelievers groveling at our feet begging us for mercy.
In fact, quite the opposite will occur. We will lead those very nations who
have persecuted us to their salvation. Certainly we will be at the helm. But
the age of the Messiah is not one in which we will dominate and conquer the
nations, but one in which we will *instruct* them. We will tell them -- and
they will listen -- to the message we had for them all along: that there is
an infinite God who loves them and cares for them, that He gave us mitzvos
(commandments) to enable us to gain a connection with Him and earn the World
to Come. Rather than lording over those low-down goyim (Gentiles) who never
paid us any heed, we will happily give to them what their souls needed all
along. We will at last be that "light unto the nations" (Isaiah 42:6) G-d
intended us to be.
Many Jews have died at the hands of the Gentiles with the "ani ma'amin" on
their lips, expressing their belief that the Messiah would ultimately arrive
and bring about the redemption. My teacher R. Yochanan Zweig
(www.talmudicu.edu & www.torah.org/learning/rabbizweig) explained what the
ani ma'amin under such circumstances means and what it does *not* mean.
The ani ma'amin does not mean that today you are beating us up, but in the
future the Messiah will arrive and we're going to beat *you* up. Pious Jews
about to give their lives in sanctification of G-d's Name did not have such
pettiness on their minds.
Rather, such Jews were seeing purpose in their suffering. They saw that even
in their darkest moments, when G-d's guiding Hand appeared least evident,
G-d was really there for them all along. The suffering of today is somehow a
step towards the ultimate salvation of tomorrow. It is somehow one of the
required steps to bring the Messiah. Thus, rather than being wrapped up in
their own suffering, such people turned outwards, seeing G-d's hand at its
most hidden time. Instead of looking angrily at the Gentiles who persecuted
them and awaiting their sweet revenge, they saw the faintest dawning of the
glorious End of Days -- the day in which we will bring our very oppressors
to salvation. May that time come speedily in our days.
Text Copyright © 2013 by Rabbi Dovid Rosenfeld and Torah.org