The Holiness of the Physical, Part II
Chapter 6, Law 2(b)
By Rabbi Dovid Rosenfeld
"There is a positive [Torah] obligation to cleave to the wise in order to
learn from their deeds, as it states 'and to Him you shall cleave' (Deut.
10:20). Now is it possible for a person to cleave to the Divine Presence?
Rather, so said the Sages in explanation of this law: Cleave to the Torah
scholars and their students (Talmud Kesuvos 111b). Therefore, a person
must endeavor to marry the daughter of a Torah scholar, marry his daughter
to a Torah scholar, eat and drink with Torah scholars, do business with
Torah scholars, and connect with them in every manner, as it states, 'and
to cleave to Him' (Deut. 11:22). And so too did the Sages command,
saying '...cleave to the dust of their [the scholars'] feet, and drink
thirstily their words' (Pirkei Avos 1:4)
Last week we began discussing the concept of cleaving to the wise. As the
Rambam states, the primary reason for this is so that we will learn from
their ways. To this we asked why all the illustrations brought by the
Talmud and Rambam are so physical -- marriage, eating and drinking, etc.?
Wouldn't we expect the obligation to primarily be to study from the
wise and observe their behavior in more religious contexts?
We suggested simply that it goes without saying that we should study from
the wise. The novelty here is that we must observe them even while
performing their mundane activities. And this is because it is not always
so evident how to live a religious life out of the study hall. It is
relatively clear how to study Torah and perform the mitzvos (commandments)
properly. But how to go about in the world at large often requires much
closer observation of the scholarly.
However, I believe there is a much more profound concept here. The
obligation here is not merely to observe the wise but to "cleave" to them,
forming an intense blood bond with them, as through marriage. And this
begins to shed light on one of the truly fascinating concepts of Judaism --
the holiness of the physical world.
We began last week by making a very simple observation regarding the
physical world. Physical existence allows for something which could never
occur in the spiritual realm -- closeness between two dissimilar objects.
Two creations, even if fundamentally different by nature, can coexist in
close physical proximity.
In the spiritual realm, by contrast, such could never occur. The spiritual
plane lacks spatial dimension; thus, "closeness" as we perceive it here is
meaningless. Rather, two objects are "close" if they are similar -- just
as two people might be "close" even if they're on opposite sides of the
world, and may be worlds apart even if they live in the same house.
This in fact, Kabbalistically speaking, is one of great novelties of the
physical universe. In the spiritual realm such opposites as good and evil
could never coexist. Metaphysically, they are diametrically opposed and
could never come in contact with one another. In the physical world,
however, they can and do coexist -- often within a single man's very
bosom. And this allows for one of the great purposes of the physical
world -- that man confront evil and overcome it. On a spiritual plane,
such a confrontation by definition could never occur. But in the physical,
it is not only possible; it is the ultimate purpose of creation.
(In a similar vein, a person's body and soul are inherently different and
incompatible. This too is one of the great miracles of the physical world
in that they may coexist -- even if uneasily -- in a single being.)
Another implication of this is that man's very physicality affords him
true spiritual growth. Only as physical beings can we face and endure
challenge and temptation, and by overcoming them attain holiness. Had we
been pure spiritual beings, life could not have offered us challenge. We
would never be confronted by evil. We would have our spiritual state,
whatever that may be, and never come in contact with anything less or more
holy than we. Thus, our lives would be entirely stagnant, offering us no
opportunity for growth.
This is as the World to Come is depicted by the Sages as blissful -- yet
stationary -- existence, in which we'll be "sitting... and enjoying the
shine of the Divine Presence" (Talmud Brachos 17a). It may be great, yes,
but we'll be who we'll be. We will no longer be able to surmount further
challenge and get even closer to the G-d we will then so desire.
Thus far we have explained that the physical world, with all its confusion
and distance from G-d, is actually the very vehicle which allows us to
come closer to Him. But the idea is even more profound, as we will now see.
According to most commentators, the ultimate reward the worthy will
achieve is physical -- at least in part. After the era of the Messiah, at
the End of Days, all of mankind will arise from the dead for the ultimate
Judgment Day. The worthy will rise and live forever -- according to the
level of spirituality they attained during their lifetimes. The unworthy
will rise to be judged -- and will then be destroyed or eternally
punished. "And many of those who sleep in the dirt of the ground will
awaken, these to eternal life and these to shame, to everlasting
abhorrence" (Daniel 12:2).
According to most opinions, this Resurrection of the Dead will herald the
final and everlasting state of man, in which we will live as perfected
physical beings who will, to use the Sages' metaphor, "stroll together
with G-d in the Garden of Eden" (based on Leviticus 26:12: "And I will
stroll among you"). By contrast, the spiritual Heaven which the
worthy among us will merit immediately after our deaths is only a pleasant
holding pattern (known in philosophical writings as "Olam HeNeshamos" --
"The World of Souls"). We will enjoy closeness to G-d but will basically
be "passing time" until the world is ready for its true fulfillment. (See
however _The Way of G-d_ (I:3:12), who explains the great value and
benefit even that passing phase will afford us, further readying us for
the ultimate state.)
And this of course requires explanation. We can understand that the
physical world offers us challenge and temptation the spiritual cannot,
but why should the reward be physical as well? Even if, as the
Sages teach us, we will be created in a higher, more perfected state, how
can physicality bring us closer to G-d? Isn't physical matter by
definition less lofty and spiritual than the heavens? Doesn't it basically
further remove us from holiness?
The idea, however, is that only through physicality can we truly cleave to
G-d. For again, as spiritual beings alone we could never connect to
anything beyond us. There is no true "closeness" to G-d in a purely
spiritual world, lacking spatial dimensions. And further, no matter how
much we sanctified ourselves during our lifetimes, we will not truly be
any closer to an infinite G-d -- just as 10,000 is no closer to infinity
than 100. Thus, only with a physical side can closeness to G-d truly be,
can we "stroll together with G-d in the Garden." During our lifetimes we
can bond physically with those very items G-d placed His commands upon,
performing good deeds with the very matter of the physical world. And
binding with objects upon which G-d placed His instructions in a sense
binds us directly to G-d.
Finally, we can now appreciate the great significance of the obligation to
cleave to Torah scholars. The Talmudic passage the Rambam quoted above,
discussing the importance of cleaving to Torah scholars, immediately
continues by discussing the Resurrection and the miraculous state the
world which reach in the End of Days. For cleaving to G-d is not at all
possible in this universe. Yet G-d has granted us the opportunity to bond
with individuals who have such a spark of holiness within them. And by
physically connecting with them we will ultimately both be readied for and
grow to appreciate the ultimate closeness to G-d our souls so dearly
(The ideas above are primarily based on R. Aryeh Kaplan's treatise "A
World of Love," Ch. 9, available as part of _The Aryeh Kaplan Anthology_
Text Copyright © 2009 by Rabbi Dovid Rosenfeld and Torah.org