Rabbi Eliyahu Hoffmann
Going Beyond the Carrot
In Parshas Eikev we read the second section of the Shema. "And it will
be, that if you will diligently listen to My commandments... And you
shall teach them to your children - to speak in them - while you sit in
your home, while you walk on the way, when you retire and when
you arise." [11:13,19]
Mefarshim (Torah commentators) note the problematic wording of the
above pasuk. The phrase "to speak in them" seems to be describing
how we should teach our children: i.e. We should teach them in such a
manner that they... Seemingly, then, the Torah should have continued,
"When they sit in their homes; while they walk on the way; when
they retire and when they arise."
Nachal Eliyahu explains that above pasuk deals not with the children's
dedication to Torah study, but rather with the parents'. The most
important aspect of chinuch (Torah education) - even more than what we
teach our children - is how we conduct ourselves. As the oft quoted
expression goes, "Children do as we do, not as we say." It is all very well
for a parent to prod and encourage his child to excel in their studies - to
learn diligently and energetically; to play less and learn more - but more
often than not the deciding factor will be the parent's own behavior.
Does he spend his spare time learning, or is there always something else
to do? Does she encourage her husband to spend more hours studying
Torah, or is it somehow the last item on the list? Is it clear to their
children that their main preoccupation is with Torah - or does is
sometimes seem that their real interests lie elsewhere (money and
possessions, vacations and hobbies, keeping up with the news and
keeping up with the Jones', and other untold distractions)?
Which parent hasn't told their child umpteen times, "Torah is the best
schorah (merchandise)," and, "Tov li Toras ficha - The Torah of Your mouth
is better for me, than thousands in gold and silver." (Tehillim/Psalms
119:72) Little do we realize just how perceptive their little minds are at
determining if we really mean what we say, or if it's no more than lip
service. Not to say that every child is a born cynic, critically analyzing
everything he's taught. Many children willingly accept things at face
value. But only those lessons which have been reinforced through the
lessons of life - which children learn from observing and interacting with
those around them - will truly withstand the "test of time."
And you shall teach them to your children. What is the best and most
effective way to teach them? By speaking in them - when you sit in
your house; while you go on your way; when you retire and
when you arise. (See also Olas Shabbos Volume 12 Issue 42 Torah
Education - Starting With the Best Materials which addresses this issue
I once saw another explanation of the above pasuk. Education doesn't
simply mean getting a child to do something - to learn, pray, review, etc.
Using appropriate and timely positive and negative reinforcement, it is
relatively easy to make a child do as we please. With a combination of
threats and/or incentives, all but the most stubborn child can be had, at
But true education is so much more. It means getting the student to
want to do something - to love to learn, and to want to pray with
dedication. Humans can not be and will never be trained mice. In the
long run, we pursue those matters for which we have gained a true
appreciation, and disdain things for which we have gained little respect.
What this means is that even the most diligent student, if his education
has consisted primarily of acting and learning through incentives, but has
never been encouraged to go beyond the incentives and gain an
appreciation of Torah for its own sake, has gained very little. His parents
and teachers may pat themselves on the back - after all, he is a model
student. But a time will come when there are no more incentives, no
more prizes or punishments - no more carrots.
The Torah stresses that a parent/teacher/rebbe can not take pride simply
because their children/students are good while they are around. Our
task is to help our children and students acquire a love for Torah such
that even when we're not there, their dedication remains steadfast. And
you shall teach them to your children - not just teaching in the
conventional sense, but rather to teach them to speak in them - even
when, you - the educator, sit in your home, while you walk on the
way, when you retire and when you arise - and you're not there to prod
and prompt, to arouse and encourage, still their behavior bespeaks that
of a Torah Jew.
It is essential that every educator - parent and teacher alike - ask
himself: Am I an educator, or a policeman? What goes on when I'm not
around? Am I the wise sage, or just the carrot-holder? Granted, without
those good-old incentives, children can sometimes deteriorate into an
unruly bunch. But are we at least making an effort to go beyond the carrot?
Text Copyright © 1999 Rabbi Eliyahu Hoffmann and Project Genesis, Inc.