By Rabbi Aron Tendler
Destiny For A Bowl Of Beans
"Rivkah suffered from the seemingly internal struggle of a schizophrenic child
who could not decide between right and wrong."
Parshas Toldos begins the story of Yakov Avinu and his conflict with
Eisav. To understand their conflict, the background to the conflict must be
understood along with a number of other questions.
Why is it that there are four Imahos - Mothers and only three Avos -
How is it that Yitzchak was fooled by Eisav's facade of righteousness
while Rivkah saw through the chardade?
Why did Yakov, the scholarly, truthful, man of G-d resort to deceit and
conspiracy in order to receive Yitzchak's blessings and his rightful destiny?
Rivkah and Yitzchak's twenty long years of waiting and praying culminated
in Rivkah's pregnancy. From the moment of conception, the Torah related that
the pregnancy was difficult. Rivkah suffered from the seemingly internal
struggle of a schizophrenic child who could not decide between right and
wrong. At times, the child seemed to desire the world of Torah, and at other
times he seemed to crave the immoral freedom of paganism.
Rivkah sought direction from Shem the son of Noach and his great-grandson
Eber. They explained that the internal conflict she was suffering was between
twins doing battle for dominance over each other. However, in the end, "the
greater will serve the younger."
As with all prophecies, the prophecy needed to be interpreted. A closer
examination of the prophecy (25:17) suggested two possible explanations.
1. The two brothers - nations, one good and one evil, would be in constant
conflict with each other as they struggled for world dominance. However, in
the end, the good would prevail over the evil.
2. The two nations would work in concert with each other to create a
single world vision of goodness and devotion to G-d. Each brother - nation
would contribute his talents in teaching the world to recognize the Creator
and fulfill Avraham's legacy. At times, Eisav's strong economic and political
leadership would be necessary; and at other times, Yakov's sanctity,
spirituality, and truthfulness would lead. However, in the end, the strength
and devotion of Eisav would serve the spiritual leadership and Torah of Yakov.
It is the dream of every parent that their children follow in their
footsteps. Yitzchak and Rivkah were no different. Their dream was that both
sons share equally in becoming the Chosen People. However, as the two boys
matured, it became apparent that Eisav would not be following in his parent's
If Eisav had joined Yakov in carrying on Avraham's mission, Yakov would
have married Rachel and Eisav would have married Leah. Each of them would have
fathered six of the tribes. In the end, there would have been four Fathers and
four Mothers! The six tribes from Eisav would have assumed the external
leadership of the nation dealing with issues of international relations,
security, and commerce. The six tribes from Yakov would have focused on the
internal structure of the nation attending to the Bais Hamikdash, the teaching
of Torah, and the internal administration of Eretz Yisroel. Together, the 12
Tribes would have worked in concert with each other to be "a light onto the
Chazal tell us that at the early age of 15, at the time of Avraham's death,
(year 2123) it became painfully apparent to Yakov that Eisav could not be a
partner in fathering the Jewish people. Yakov's deal to buy the first-born
rights from Eisav removed Eisav's spiritual prerogative to father six of the
tribes. This placed upon Yakov the full responsibility of fathering both
components of the Jewish people. Therefore, he had to marry both Rachel and
In order to accomplish both his and Eisav's missions, Yakov had to learn
to survive in the big, bad, outside world. He had to learn to manipulate and
lie in order to best the likes of Eisav and Lavan. Rivkah, the sister of
Lavan, was the proven master of survival. As Rashi explained, she was a
righteous woman coming from a wicked family and a wicked community. Yet,
Rivkah survived them all to be worthy of marrying Yitzchak. It also allowed
her to recognize Eisav for who he was.
Yitzchak, on the other hand, maintained the hope that his son would one-
day reform and join Yakov as a partner in fathering the Jewish people. A
careful reading of the scene leading up to Yitzchak having "mistakenly" given
the blessings to Yakov and not Eisav (27:1-40) shows the degree of Yitzchak's
After questioning the disguised Yakov and feeling his "hairy" arms,
Yitzchak proclaimed, "….The voice is Yakov's voice but the hands are the hands
of Eisav." (27:22) The absurdity of the scene begs for an explanation! A
blind man depends more on his hearing than a man who can see. Yet, Yitzchak
ignored the "voice of Yakov" and concluded that it was the "hands of Eisav"?!
However, if Yitzchak hoped that Eisav would join his brother in serving
Hashem's design, and if the two brothers were identical except for Eisav's
hairiness, then the whole scene becomes understandable.
Immediately preceding Yitzchak having touched Yakov's disguised arms,
Yitzchak asked Yakov how he had returned so quickly from the hunt. Yakov
naturally answered by attributing his success to Hashem's benevolent
intervention. (27:20) This response surprised Yitzchak because Eisav never
attributed his successes to Hashem. Just the opposite! He always took full
credit for himself and denied any divine intervention. Therefore, Yitzchak,
with growing anticipation, allowed for his most heartfelt wish to surface.
"Could it be? Had Eisav finally come around to recognizing Hashem and
accepting his partnership with Yakov? Yes! The time had finally come that
Eisav was speaking with the voice of Yakov but maintaining the hands of Eisav!
What a moment! My greatest wish has been realized, both my sons will follow
in my footsteps and merit to be fathers of the Jewish people!"
After Yitzchak blessed Yakov, Eisav returned and the duplicity was
revealed. The Torah describes Yitzchak's "dreaded" realization that he had
been wrong about Eisav all along, and that Rivkah had been right. "Eisav
would not be a partner in the future of the Jewish people."
In an extraordinary show of acceptance and strength, Yitzchak immediately
confirmed on Yakov the blessings that he had given him assuring that Eisav
would never be a partner in the creation of the Jewish nation. Eisav,
distraught and angered by Yakov's trickery, begged his father for a blessing.
Yitzchak explained to Eisav that he could no longer confirm upon Eisav any
part of Jewish destiny. At best, he would serve Yakov as a "servant-ally",
but never as a partner in the creation of Kllal Yisroel.
In a final confirmation of Yakov's destiny as the sole father of the
Jewish people, Yitzchak gave Yakov the "blessings of Avraham," before sending
him out to confront Lavan. (28:4)
Copyright © 1998 by Rabbi Aron Tendler
and Project Genesis, Inc.
The author is Rabbi of Shaarey Zedek Congregation,
Valley Village, CA.