By Rabbi Aron Tendler
Enough With the Miracles!
The story of our exodus from Mitzrayim is resplendent with magical tales of
wondrous events and miraculous feats. Moshe is a towering figure of fearsome
g-dliness fearlessly wielding his staff against the evil forces of Pharaoh's
intentions. Aharon is Moshe's faithful assistant who silently tempers Moshe's
awesomeness with his humaness and legendary compassion. Their confrontations
with Pharaoh were premeditated to increasingly display G-d's unlimited power
in contrast with Pharaoh's childish attempts at exerting control over the Jews
and his own people. The story of our exodus is related in a series of
Parshios that direct our questioning to the purpose of miracles and their
contrast with nature.
The simple understanding of miracles is that they are changes from the
expected norm of nature that are motivated by crisis or emergency. They must
provide an immediate service that benefits the needy and reestablishes a
balance between the forces of good and evil. The Jews were downtrodden and
unfairly enslaved and G-d sent a series of miracles to punish the evil
Egyptians and free the good Jews. The bad were punished, the good were freed,
and the balance of justice has reestablished. However, this view of miracles
presents a fundamental contradiction to our understanding of G-d's almighty
power and control.
Our understanding of G-d's awesome might is that He should never have to
engage in crisis management or intervention. G-d is the master of time and
circumstance. G-d is all-powerful and knowing. He knows what will happen and
when it will happen. He manages the intentions and actions of humankind and
coordinates them with His ultimate plan. "The end result is as He originally
intended! Therefore, anything that appears to be miraculous and seemingly
last minute in truth must have been planned way back at the beginning of time
itself! Otherwise, We wouldn't be able to claim "The Watchman of Israel never
slumbers nor sleeps!"
In ancient China, the wealthier families would have a family physician
who was responsible for keeping the family healthy. He would only receive his
wages for those months that the family wasn't ill. On any month that a member
of the family took ill, and the physician would have to cure the illness, he
would not be paid because he had not done his job! His job was to prevent the
illness from ever occurring. That was considered a good doctor! Likewise, as
magnificent a display of G-d's power as miracles may be in order to get us out
of a "tuff situation", it's even more miraculous when we don't get into
trouble to begin with!
The Ramban in Vayikra (26:11) explains that when Klal Yisroel keeps the Torah
and follows the Mitzvos, then all the blessing for national success, security,
and prosperity will come true. If they don't do as they are supposed to, then
the curses for sickness, warfare, exile, and dispersion will come true. The
fact that individuals are sometimes successful or not doesn't necessarily
reveal the guiding hand of Hashem. These fluctuations in "luck" are
considered to be the norm and the expected. However, when a nation seems to
prosper without the expected fluctuations in economy or national security,
then G-d's presence is obvious. If we do as we are supposed to, then our
continued success in all things as a nation is guaranteed. Hashem will not
have to crisis manage our security and well being. G-d will not have to make
miracles for our benefit. The constancy of our national prosperity would be
the greatest revelation of Hashem's power and majesty, and the greatest of all
"For if one righteous man lives and G-d takes away sickness from him, and he
lives out his days, this also happens to some wicked people and is thus not
acknowledged as miraculous. But when an entire land and a whole people always
have rains coming in their season, and plentitude, security, peace, health,
strength, and defeat of their enemies, in a manner unparalleled in the whole
world, it becomes known to all that this is the Eternal's doing."
(Ramban, Vayikra: 26:11).
In the beginning of this week's Parsha, Hashem differentiated between two of
His manifestations. His name - Sha-kai". The name "Hashem"
described the nature of G-d's relationship with Moshe and the Bnai Yisroel;
while "Sha-kai" described the manner in which G-d had related to the fore-
fathers. My Grandfather Zt"l explained these two different manifestations in
the following way. The name "Hashem" reflects upon G-d's ability to create
new things, such as the creation of the universe and the "doing of miracles."
The name "Sha-Kai" reflects upon G-d's ability to set limits within the world.
This is actually contained within the name itself - "the G-d who says " -
Dai - enough!"
When G-d promised the forefathers that He would redeem their children from
the bondage of Mitzrayim, He promised to do so with the power of the
manifestation of "Sha-Kai" - the G-d who sets limits to all things. This
meant that there would come a time at the end of the prophesied 400 years when
the Egyptians themselves would have, without any "new miracles", set the Jews
free and sent them to Eretz Yisroel. It would have been a time when G-d's
control over all things would have become apparent.
G-d does not allow anything to happen that doesn't have a set purpose and a
set limit. The full impact of that purpose requires the allotted amount of
time for G-d's divine reasons to be accomplished and revealed. G-d had a
reason for the Jews to be enslaved for 400 years. His purpose required the
full amount of time, after which there would have no longer been a need for
the slavery. Therefore, at the allotted 400 year limit, the Egyptian's
themselves would have realized this and simply set the Jews free without any
other need for G-d to "flex His muscles" and do wondrous miracles. (Such as
what occurred when idol worship, human slavery, and Communism came to a
seemingly abrupt end). In fact, it would have been a far greater
manifestation of G-d's power and actuality because it would have proven that
there truly is a G-d who controls all things. There really is a G-d who has
pre-planned everything and who is never taken by surprise. G-d never has to
"crisis manage" or intervene on an emergency basis.
The Egyptians themselves would have recognized His absolute mastery and
joined the Bnai Yisroel in their mission of teaching all the other nations
about the true G-d. It would have been complete redemption and the last exile
we would have had to endure. Instead, G-d felt that He had to manifest
Himself as "Hashem", the G-d who creates new things. The G-d who had to
intervene in the intentions of humankind in order to save the Jews from total
assimilation and eventual annihilation. He had to fulfill His promise to the
forefathers of freeing their children from bondage - before the end of the 400
years. This meant that neither the Jews nor the Egyptians were ready to be
saved. The redemption was going to require a new manifestation of G-d through
miracles and wonders that would shock the world into recognizing the existence
of a Master who controls nature and the universe. It would make a spectacular
impact upon the Jews and the Egyptians that would force an early redemption.
However, it would not be the last redemption. It would not usher in a
partnership between the Jew and the non-Jew that would herald the Messianic
era of universal understanding and acceptance of the G-d who is self evident
within the natural limits of time and circumstance.
In the Aleinu that concludes each of our Tefilos we say,
- to fix the world through the kingdom of the G-d who manifests Himself as
Sah-kai - the G-d who says "Dai" - enough! This is the prayer of each and
every Jew - to reach that point in human development and history when the
world will recognize that nature and history are the greatest manifestation of
G-d's power and mastery possible. We will then understand that the past
events of history were all part of G-d's ultimate intention, and that any
changes within that plan were only out of necessity due to our failings and
frailties. When this will occur, it will herald the redemption that will be
the end of all the exiles. No longer will the Jew have to suffer persecution
and dispersion. No longer will the world suffer ignorance of G-d and His
reasons for selecting us as His Chosen People. Instead, the world will have
been "fixed" through the manifestation of Sah-kai - the G-d who says "Dai" -
Copyright © 1998 by Rabbi Aron Tendler
and Project Genesis, Inc.
The author is Rabbi of Shaarey Zedek Congregation,
Valley Village, CA.