Let’s do a quick review of Sefer Bamidbar (Book of Numbers) from
B’haloscha through Pinchus.
(B’Haloscha) Miriam and Aharon spoke Lashon Harah (slander) about Moshe
and G-d confirmed Moshe as the humblest of all men and the most trusted in
(Shelach) The Miraglim (spies) spoke Lashon Harah against Eretz Yisroel
(land of Israel) and the generation of the Exodus was consigned to die in
(Korach) Korach rebelled against Moshe’s divinely assigned office and was
swallowed by the earth.
(Chukas) The laws of the Parah Adumah (red heifer) were recorded in the
Torah followed by the deaths of Miriam and Aharon.
(Balak) Bilam failed to curse the nation but succeeded in compromising
their sanctity with the daughters of Moav. G-d’s aroused wrath resulted in
the deaths of 24,000.
(Pinchus) Pinchus earned His Covenant of Peace for zealously killing Zimri
and bringing the plague to a stop. Finally, this week’s Parsha concludes
by detailing the Musaf offerings for the various Yomim Tovim (holidays)
during the year.
The events identified in the above review appear to be in chronological
order except for the laws of Parah Adumah. Chazal tell us (Rashi, Shemos
15:25) that the laws of Parah Adumah were actually revealed to the Bnai
Yisroel at the beginning of the 40 years in the desert before the giving
of the Torah. However, our record of the Parah Adumah has it sandwiched
between Korach’s rebellion and Bilam’s failed curses. According to all
opinions that places it sometime after the inauguration of the Mishkan and
the end of the 40 years. Why did Hashem (G-d) reserve the recording of
Parah Adumah for the end of Sefer Bamidbar rather than record it earlier
in the Torah?
I believe that the placement of the Parah Adumah was presented out of
chronological order because it defines the essence of Sefer Bamidbar and
humanities struggle with G-d’s law.
When the Jews were asked if they would accept G-d’s law they heroically
answered, “Naaseh V’Nishmah, We will do as G-d comm attempt to understand
the reason for His commandments”. Their response was more than heroic it
became the foundation for our relationship with G-d contrast we have often
referenced Avraham Avinu’s answer to Avimelech’s accusation as to why he
had lied about Sarah claiming that she was his sister rather than
acknowledge that she was his wife. (Ber. 20:9-11) “How have I sinned
against you that brought upon me and my kingdom such great sin? …What did
you see to do such a thing?” Avraham answered, “Because I said there is no
fear of G-d in this place?”
Humanity, no matter how knowledgeable, intelligent, and wise is limited.
Humans cannot be the final arbitrators of good and evil. Truth and
falsehood cannot be a human determination. There must be criteria for
right and wrong that transcends the human limits of time and space;
otherwise, good and evil become as convenient as personal bias and power.
However, the eternal Creator of the universe is an absolute not subject to
the whims of time, circumstance, or human avarice. A society that
believes in G-d and lives by His commands can be trusted to act in
accordance with eternal truths of good and bad. However, a society that
only depends on the value constructs of its leaders is not to be trusted.
Who is to say that they won’t change their minds and what was true today
will be false tomorrow?
The statement, “Naaseh V’Nishmah” unambiguously proclaimed that the Jews
accepted their human limitations and subjugated themselves to the absolute
goodness and judiciousness of G-d’s determination. In last week’s Parsha
the evil Bilam defined the international character of Am Yisroel as
(23:9) “a nation that dwells alone and is not reckoned among the nations.”
As a nation we do not judge ourselves by the values of any other nation or
society. The scale that determines the rights and wrongs of our lives is G-
d’s law, regardless of our comprehension, lack of comprehension, agreement
Parah Adumah is a mitzvah that the Torah presented as the quintessential
Chok - decree. As the verse states, (19:2) “This is the decree of the
Torah” It is a commandment that defies comprehension, yet we must
nevertheless live by its limitations. It forces us to remember the
courageousness of our forefathers who accepted the Torah with the
words, “Naaseh V’Nishmah.” “Yes, we will attempt to understand G-d’s
intentions; however, we humbly acknowledge that we are intellectually,
emotionally, and physically limited. We proclaim for all time that we
trust Hashem’s determination of good and evil right and wrong to the
extent that we subject ourselves and the destinies of our families and
nation to His will.”
In Sefer Bamidbar, G-d confirmed Moshe as the “humblest and most
trustworthy of all humans” before detailing the selected account of the
nation’s trials and tribulations. The key to Moshe’s trustworthiness was
his humility. Hashem was able to trust Moshe to deliver and teach His word
verbatim because Moshe had completely subjugated himself to G-d. Moshe
suspended all independent action in relation to G-d. He only did that
which G-d commanded him to do. Moshe became the true Man of G-d, the
essential Servant of G-d. Despite Moshe’s great intellect, despite Moshe’s
fundamental independence and courage, Moshe subjugated himself to G-d’s
will. Therefore, G-d could trust him. In other words, Moshe was gifted
with a level of Nishmah/understanding uneq history, yet, he lived on the
level of Naaseh/doing as he was told necessarily that which he understood.
For Moshe all of the Torah was no different than the Parah Adumah.
Regardless of how much he knew and understood, regardless of the fact that
Moshe knew and understood more than anyone else who ever lived or would
ever live, Moshe accepted as an absolute truth that relative to G-d
Himself Moshe knew and understood nothing. He was truly the “humblest of
The episode with Miriam, the Miraglim and Korach highlighted humility as
the essential criteria for acceptance of G-d’s law. Miriam, with all her
good intentions and love for G-d, Moshe, and the Jewish people did not
understand the level of her brother’s humility. As a prophet in her own
right Miriam thought that she understood what it took to be G-d’s First
Teacher, but she was wrong. The totality of Moshe’s willful subjugation to
G-d rendered him as One In All Of History.
The Spies worried that the reality they perceived during their
reconnaissance of the Promised Land was different than G-d’s promises to
the Forefathers. Rather than rise above the reality based fears of their
human perceptions and trust that G-d’s promises defined reality, not the
other way around, the Spies trusted their own conclusions, not G-d’s. They
were unwilling to function within the framework of Naaseh and therefore
failed because of their limited Nishmah.
Korach challenged Moshe in the most direct way possible. He claimed that G-
d’s desire was for humanity to function within the realm of Nishmah, human
comprehension, and not be limited to the constraints of Naaseh, doing. The
Torah was given to humans so that they would struggle to unlock its
secrets to the extent of their abilities. G-d could not hold them
responsible for anything more than that. Korach failed because his
greatest challenge was his own ego and arrogance. The fact that he
disguised it behind a cloak intellectual honesty and challenge didn’t fool
anyone. He was arrogant in contrast to Moshe’s humility. He was unwilling
to accept the limitations of physicality in contrast to the divine
radiance of Moshe’s countenance.
Korach was punished in the most exacting way possible. Earth itself, the
essence of all physicality, (Ber. 3:19 “until you which you were taken”)
responded in absolute obedience to t “in a new manifestation of G-d’s
opened its mouth and swallowed Korach alive.” (16:31) The measure for a
measure of Korach’s punishment was that Korach who limited G-d’s will to
the extents of human understanding died in a manner that miraculously
defied all human comprehension.
The laws of Parah Adumah and the removal of impurity associated with death
underscored humility as the foundation for serving Hashem. Parah Adumah is
a decree that never left the category of Naaseh. It is a Mitzvah that we
can never comprehend yet we must nevertheless do as told. It is a
commandment that Nishmah cannot encompass. Just as the human is limited by
the inevitability of death so too is he limited by the inevitability of
being human. Nishmah would suggest that we attempt to beat death back and
try to live forever. It is the stuff of fantasy and fiction since time and
memorial; however, death is inevitable and the limitations of human
comprehension are inevitable. To serve Hashem is to trust Hashem. To trust
Hashem is to be humble. To be humble is to accept and do Naaseh regardless
Bilam refused to live with the limitations of Naaseh. Even though he was a
prophet of extraordinary prowess, Bilam could not accept the fact that he
served G-d, the Jews, and humanity - but not himself. He refused to find
nobility, purpose, and fulfillment through humble service and subjugation.
He refused to accept that diminution creates greatness. Instead, Bilam
sought to control G-d and control His world. Chazal tell us that even as
he spoke the blessings that G-d placed in his mouth his mind meant them as
curses. Bilam gave in order to take whereas Am Yisroel gave in order to
be. Naaseh doing is an ac Regardless of intention the action accomplishes
the intent of the deed.
Bilam was punished a measure for a measure. Because he desired to not do
as he was told he was forced against his will to do as he was told. Bilam
hated to be controlled. Bilam hated doing for anyone else but himself. In
the end G-d used him no differently than he had used Bilam’s donkey, to do
G-d’s will regardless of Bilam’s true intentions. While Bilam
screamed “no” within the confines of his own skull, Bilam blessed the Jews
and guaranteed their destiny as G-d’s chosen children. He guaranteed that
he and all the other nations could only attain purpose and fulfillment by
subjugating themselves to the will of G-d as defined by the Torah and
Pinchus (and the daughters of Tzlaphchad) is the final example. Confronted
by a nation gone crazy, Pinchus witnessed the desecration of G-d’s name by
those sworn to uphold its sanctity. The Jews had accepted the conditions
of their covenant with G-d and had proclaimed that they would do G-d’s law
regardless of any other human limitations including intellectual,
emotional, or physical. Even the great Zimri, prince of Shimon, somehow
rationalized consorting with a Moabite princess. Moshe and the rest of the
Sanhedrin seemed frozen. The plague raged uncontrollably taking the lives
of thousands. Pinchus decided not to question, think, analyze, argue, or
seek rationalization. Pinchus reacted in a fit of zealous jealousy for the
sake of G-d and His glory. Immersing himself in single-minded Naaseh
action, Pinchus killed Zimri and stopped the he thought about it, the
chances are that he would not have done so. Had Pinchus taken the time to
confer, debate, argue, or defend, the chances are that thousands more
would have died in the plague of G-d’s wrath. Instead, Pinchus accepted
that just as it was G-d’s will that he not be chosen as a Kohain, so too
there could not be any excuse or rationalization to justify and allow the
public and private desecration of G-d’s name. Instead, it was G-d’s will
that he be jealous for G-d’s sake. Suspending all attempts at Nishmah
Pinchus entered the realm of Naaseh.
His reward was G-d’s Covenant of Peace. Pinchus was elevated to the status
of Kohain. Peace reflects on the eternity of the Jewish people and
fulfillment of G-d’s promise to the Avos and Imahos. G-d promised them
that they would be Kohanim to the World. G-d promised them that they would
serve G-d and serve humanity. G-d promised them that their children would
find blessedness in blessing others. However, their children would have to
first trust Hashem and subject themselves to His omnipotent reality. Their
children would have to be humble.
Pinchus proved that he was willing to sacrifice himself for the sake of
truth and goodness with no thought other than serving G-d. Pinchus
willingly suspended Nishmah and accomplished the ultimate in Naaseh.
Humanness and physicality exists in the two dimensions of time and space.
G-d, on the other hand, exists beyond the limitations of both time and
space. The Talmud in Bava Basra describes the Aron Hakodesh (holy ark) and
the Keruvim (cherubim) that adorned it as “not occupying space.” The
Talmud is actually stating that the physical box containing the Luchos
(tablets) and the Torah as well as the golden Keruvim that adorned it,
miraculously did not occupy physical space. Impossible you say! Of course
it’s impossible but that’s the point! The Torah that we lovingly cherish
and study and pride ourselves in our intellectual insights and
understanding is actually a reality that defies human comprehension. Just
as we cannot possibly conceive of an actual physical box constructed from
wood and gold that does not occupy space, so too we must accept that our
comprehension of any part of the Torah is an illusion of Nishmah that in
no way modifies the enormity of the Naaseh. In essence we play at
comprehension and are obligated to do so to the extents of our inescabable
intellectual limitations; however, we must always remember that in the end
we are merely playing.
At the end of Parshas Pinchus the Torah again presents us with a set of
laws that appear to be out of place. The details of the Musaf offerings
would be better served in Vayikra (Leviticus) rather than at the end of
Bamidbar. Why now? The service in the Bais Hamikdash was highlighted on
the holidays by the specific Musaf offerings that were unique to that
holiday. Special days such as Shabbos, Rosh Chodesh, Pesach, Shavuoth,
Rosh Hashanah, Yom Kippur, Succos, and Shimini Atzeres, are imposed on us
regardless of personal convenience or preference. The days listed at the
end of Pinchus present the degree of our subjectivity to G-d’s time
schedule rather than our own. Just as G-d is not bound by space, “His
honor fills the universe,” so too He is not bound by time.
The lesson of Pinchus is that although we proclaimed, “Nishmah - we would
attempt to comprehend G-d’s law,” it was conditional on the first
proclamation, “Naaseh we will accept the limits of our mortality and sub
the absolute authority of G-d s law.” By accepting the conditions of
Naaseh we become like Pinchus, able to do the work of bringing G-d’s
Covenant of Peace to the entire nation and the entire world.
Text Copyright © 2004 by Rabbi Aron Tendler and Torah.org
The author is the Rabbi of Shaarey Zedek Congregation, Valley
Village, CA, and Assistant Principal of YULA.