Parshas Shoftim
Laws and Louisiana
A lawless society is the worst of all curses. The rabbis in Avot
cautioned us to pray for the welfare of government for without the
presence of its restraints and police powers, “one person would swallow
the other person, whole and alive.” The current chaos and unspeakable
tragedies visiting the people and city of New Orleans, Louisiana,
testify to the accuracy of this comment upon human nature by the rabbis
of Avot. Tragedies often bring about the revelation of the most exalted
and noble of human instincts. But they invariably bring into focus the
worst and most base elements of human behavior - looting, price gouging,
violence and cruelty. Those who campaign on the platform of no
government – anarchists and the like - in times of dire emergency are
forced to plead for governmental intervention and help. They and we are
witness to the somewhat depressing fact that technology may advance and
progress but the dark side of human nature has never really changed over
the thousands of years of human civilization. Therefore the opening
words of this week’s parsha that admonishes the Jewish society to
establish an effective and efficient system of police powers and
judicial decision is most relevant to our society, as it has been
relevant to all previous generations of our people as well. Without
effective policing and institutions that defend the rule of law,
civilized societal life as we know it would cease to exist. Eventually,
Torah and the performance of mitzvot will also disappear in a lawless
atmosphere and a society of chaos and anarchy.
However, police and courts also must be restricted in their powers.
Mussolini made the trains run on time and there was little
non-governmental lawlessness in Hitler’s Germany or Stalin’s Soviet
Union. In fact, all totalitarian regimes are the model of law and order,
but unfortunately of an evil type of law and order. The Torah therefore
limits the powers of the police, the courts, of government itself, by
demanding that their actions and policies conform to the oft-stated
standards of righteousness, compassion, fairness and tolerance that the
Torah emphatically espouses. Moral inhibitions are the brake against
enslaving others in a totalitarian world of all-powerful police and
courts. The rabbis of the Talmud enjoined us to pursue the finding of a
fair, equitable, wise, “beautiful” court – beit din – before which our
disputes should be resolved. The “beautiful” beit din is in reality a
metaphor for the entire society and its government. The pursuit of
righteousness, of fairness and incorruptibility, both in the private and
public sectors of Jewish life is a commandment of the Torah. It is a
lofty goal to achieve, but the mere attempt to do so already introduces
into our society the presence of those moral forces that can inhibit
totalitarian behavior by government, police and courts. In the balanced
view of life and society that the Torah always provides us with, the
necessity for police, courts and government is emphasized. But
side-by-side with this, the Torah’s moral inhibitions on power and base
human nature are clearly spelled out and defined. “For its ways are ways
of pleasantness and all its paths lead to peace and harmony.”
Shabat shalom.
Rabbi Berel Wein
Text Copyright © 2005 by Rabbi Berel Wein and Torah.org
Visit www.rabbiwein.com for a complete selection of Rabbi Wein's books and tapes.
