Our Attitude Matters
The attitude of Jews towards the Land of Israel has always been a litmus
type of test of Jewish commitment and even faith throughout the ages. As we
see in this week’s parsha, from the beginning of our national existence
there have always been Jews – leading Jews, well-intentioned Jews, even
outwardly pious Jews – who have preferred living somewhere else in the world
to living in the Land of Israel.
Even when Hitler came to power, European Jews in many cases refused to
consider the option of immigration to the Land of Israel. It is not my place
to judge others for their behavior in a very dreadful time, especially since
I am blessed with the perfect hindsight that they tragically lacked, but it
is a strange fact that throughout Jewish history the naysayers regarding the
Land of Israel in Jewish society have always abounded.
Jews in the generation of Moses claimed their preference for the land of
Egypt over the Land of Israel. An entire generation of special and gifted
Jews was destroyed in the desert of Sinai because of their unwillingness to
consider living in the Land of Israel as a viable option for them and their
descendants. The challenge of living in the Land of Israel was apparently
too great a problem for them to overcome - physically, psychologically and
To me this attitude remains one of the supreme mysteries of all of Jewish
history. But mystery or not, it certainly is a fact that has governed Jewish
life over the ages.
When Moses’ own relative refused the offer to go to the Land of Israel,
Rashi explains that the two reasons for his behavior had to do with family
and making a living. These are very strong reasons that exist today that
prevent many Jews from considering immigrating to the Land of Israel. Again,
I neither judge nor begrudge anyone in this or any other life changing matter.
However, I feel that the issue of the Land of Israel, independent of any
other causes and motives, strikes at a very deep place within our personal
and national soul. The fact that the most ultra-assimilated and the most
outwardly ultra-pious within the Jewish people are included in our
generation’s most vociferous of the anti- Land of Israel groups, shows that
the problem is both deep and sensitive.
The extremes in Jewish society cannot deal with the Land of Israel as a
reality and earnestly hope that the issue will somehow disappear completely.
There are millions of Jews who prefer living in exile to living in the Land
of Israel. The Jewish people, as a whole has not absorbed the lessons of the
exile, its alienation, assimilation and its ultimate corruption of Torah values.
Today, many Jews who physically live in the Land of Israel still
psychologically and spiritually live in the exile, in a fantasy of the
long-destroyed shtetel of Eastern Europe. As foretold to us by our prophets,
the ultimate fate of the Jewish people will be determined for us by our
attitude to the Land of Israel. Living in the Land of Israel or at least
visiting it regularly is currently the centerpiece of Jewish life, its faith
and its future.
Rabbi Berel Wein