Torah.org Home Subscribe Services Support Us
 
Print Version

Email this article to a friend
Rambam

Rambam

Rabbi Yitzchok Etshalom
Talmud Torah 6:13

13. If a teacher declared *Nidui* for his own honor, all of his students are obligated to ostracize the *Menudeh* (person under *Nidui*). However, if a student declared *Nidui* for his own honor, the teacher is not obligated to treat [the offender] as a *Menudeh*. Nevertheless, everyone else is obligated to treat him as *Menudeh*. Similarly, one who is *Menudeh* to the *Nasi* (Head of the court) is [therefore] *Menudeh* to all Jews. [Conversely], one who is *Menudeh* to all Jews is not *Menudeh* to the *Nasi*. One who is *Menudeh* to his city is *Menudeh* to other cities. [Conversely], one who is *Menudeh* to another city is not *Menudeh* to his own city.

Q1: Why do the teacher's students have to ostracize the *Menudeh* of their teacher? Is it part of the honor for their teacher - or because his rulings have a different level of authority over them?

YE: Honor for the teacher - the teacher is not operating here as a *Poseq* (Halakhic decisor) - so their obligation toward following his rulings - if such an obligation exists at all - is irrelevant.

Q2: Why does the *Nasi* seemingly "represent" all Jews regarding *Nidui* and his honor?

YE: Since the Nasi is the chair of the court, his honor is an embodiment of the honor of the court and, indirectly, the honor of Torah. One who offends him is offending the court and the Torah - and his *Nidui* applies to everyone.

Q3: What is the rationale behind the "his city/other cities" law?

HH: Two possibilities: 1) Since his kinsfolk and his friends live in his city, his city is supposed to be indulgent towards him. So, if even his own city ostracizes him, he must have done something really serious. 2) A city has a special level of authority with regard to its regular inhabitants that it does not have with regard to foreigners.

Additional questions [AD (Aviva Dayan)]: - Q4a: How are we to know who is a *Hakham*? YE: See posting at TT 6:6, Question 1.

Q4b: Could there be such a thing as an imposter?

YE: Since the first experience with him which gives us reason to believe that he is a *Hakham* is a clear demonstration of his wisdom and knowledge - it's highly unlikely.

Q4c: Could there be such a thing as a 'reverse imposter' - a person who is a *Hakham* but pretends not to be?

YE: Sure there could - but the Talmud (BT Sotah 22a) warns us against "the one who is ready for instruction and does not instruct" - equating him with the one who "is not ready to instruct and instructs."

Q5a: To what extent does a personŐs public behavior determine whether or not he/she is a *Hakham/a* (and can a woman be classified as a *Hakham* at all and why or why not; if not, is there anything parallel that would apply to her?)

YE: The "public behavior" issue is addressed above. As to the status of a scholarly woman, such a notion does exist in the Talmud - where the *Isha Havera* (lit. - "woman-peer" - a scholarly woman) is compared, in some Halakhic respects, to the *Haver* (BT Kiddushin 56a, Sanhedrin 8b, 41a). It would certainly seem that if someone had the great fortune to study with Nechama Lebowitz, for example, that he or she should treat her with all of these measures of honor - and, of course, if any of us see her or meet her, the measures of respect accorded a *Hakham* would be appropriate.

Q5b: To what extent does a personŐs private behavior determine whether or not he/she is a *Hakham/a*? How is this private behavior monitored (if this question is relevant)

YE: See MT De'ot, Chapter 5, for a full presentation of the "lifestyle" of the *Hakham*.

Q6a: To what extent does a person's attitude determine if he/she is a *Hakham/a*?

YE: See above (answer to Q4a).

Q6b: If attitude matters, why do we do all these things for the *Hakham*? Wouldn't all these 'fringe benefits' tempt the *Hakham* to deteriorate - as in, enjoy the benefits and be lax in studies, or become full of *Ga'ava* (haughtiness)? Wouldn't it also tempt imposters?

YE: Just because we do these things "for" the *Hakham*, that doesn't automatically lead him to the negative attributes presented in your question. Remember - he doesn't need to accept all of these "honorifics" - and is encouraged to forgo them (as we have seen several times in R). Tempting impostors? - maybe - but they would have a hard time keeping up the act. In reality, the burdens and responsibilities of the Hakham far outweigh any privileges he may be afforded. See MT De'ot Chapter 5. See also BT Yoma 86a, where the responsibity for others' love for God rests, to a great extent, on his shoulders!

Rambam, Copyright (c) 1999 Project Genesis, Inc.

 
Sell Chometz Online







ARTICLES ON PESACH AND THE OMER:

View Complete List

Urchatz, Karpas, Yachatz
Rabbi Yehudah Prero - 5755

To Express a Higher Yes!
Rabbi Label Lam - 5766

“Letter to my Son Akiva” (born 10 years ago, on Erev LAG B’OMER)
Jon Erlbaum - 5771

Looking for a Chavrusah?

Worth the Struggle
Rabbi Label Lam - 5767

Pesach: The Obligation of Profound Appreciation
Rabbi Label Lam - 5764

Matzah and Maror - Worthy Mechutanim
Rabbi Eliyahu Hoffmann - 5759

ArtScroll

Seven Days of Pesach
Rabbi Yehudah Prero - 5756

Hagadah Shel Pesach
Rabbi Pinchas Winston - 5764

Why Four Cups?
Rabbi Yehudah Prero - 5757

Frumster - Orthodox Jewish Dating

Tarnished Treasures of Pesach
Rabbi Yehudah Prero - 5759

Focus on the Counting
Rabbi Yehudah Prero - 5756

Another Link in the Chain
Rabbi Yisroel Ciner - 5759

> Telling Others
Rabbi Yehudah Prero - 5755

Jogging Ancient Memories
Rabbi Label Lam - 5763

Ha Lachma Anya
Rabbi Yochanan Zweig - 5771

Taking It Personally
Rabbi Pinchas Avruch - 5764



Project Genesis

Torah.org Home


Torah Portion

Jewish Law

Ethics

Texts

Learn the Basics

Seasons

Features

TORAHAUDIO

Ask The Rabbi

Knowledge Base




Help

About Us

Contact Us



Free Book on Geulah!




Torah.org Home
Torah.org HomeCapalon.com Copyright Information