Reading, Reviewing and Reciting
by Rabbi Yehudah Prero
The Shulchan Aruch (Orech Chayim 430) states that "The Shabbos before
Pesach is called *Shabbas HaGadol,' *The Great Shabbos," because of the
miracle that occurred on this day." The Ram"a adds to this that "the
custom is to say, by Mincha, the Hagadah, beginning with the passage of
Avadim HaYinu and ending with the passage of "Lechaper al kol
avonoseinu."
The Mishna Berura explains that in the year the nation of Israel
departed from Egypt, the 10th day of Nissan was on Shabbos. Everyone in
the nation took on that day a sheep for his Paschal offering and tied it
to his bedpost. The Egyptians saw this and queried as to what they were
doing. The people answered they were going to slaughter this sheep as a
Paschal offering, according to the commandment of G-d. The Egyptians
were not able to respond to the information that their god was to be
slaughtered. Because this 10th day of Nissan was on Shabbos, the Shabbos
before Pesach has since been called Shabbos HaGadol. Furthermore, since
the beginning of the miracles associated with exodus began with this
day, we have the tradition to read the Hagadah Shabbos afternoon, even
if Shabbos HaGadol occurs on Pesach eve (as it does this year).
Another reason offered for why we read the Hagadah on the Shabbos before
Pesach concerns the laws regarding special prayers for the holidays. The
Shulchan Aruch (Orech Chayim 100) writes that regarding the prayers for
the holidays and Rosh Chodesh, people should review and prepare the
prayers before they actually pray, so that when they actually do pray
they are fluent in the text of the prayer. Similarly, the Maharshal
writes (Teshuva 88), one should review the Hagadah before Pesach, so
that each person can recite the Hagadah the night of Pesach with a
greater sense of fluency and understanding.
The Vilna Gaon has a general objection to this custom. We read in the
Hagadah that one might think that the commandment of relating the story
of the exodus begins with the start of the month of Nissan. However, the
connotation of the scriptural verse is that this obligation only exists
when the Matzo and Maror are before us at the Seder table. If we are to
wait to the time of the Seder for the recitation of the events as
contained in the Hagadah, how then can we recite the Hagadah on the
Shabbos before Pesach?
The Hagadah Agudas Aizov offers a resolution of the Vilna Gaon's
contradiction. The verse which indicates that we recite the Hagadah only
at the Seder refers specifically to the commandment that we must relate
these events to our children. At the Seder, the children have to be
motivated to stay interested. The children need to have their curiosity
piqued. If the contents of the Seder night are laid to them in advance,
they will lose interest and not focus on the important message that we
must impart to them at the Seder. Therefore, we are not supposed to
relate the story of the Exodus, as contained in the Hagadah, until we
have arrived at the Seder. Adults, however, are able to appreciate new
nuances and deeper understandings each time they read the Hagadah. As
adults can gain new insight with each time they review the Hagadah, it
is clear that reading the Hagadah before the Seder night will not cause
them to lose interest come the actual Seder night. In fact, the opposite
should occur: the insights gleaned in the review of the Hagadah before
Pesach will enrich the Seder experience.
It is clear from this custom that the recitation of the Hagadah is of
utmost importance on Pesach. We should review it beforehand so that we
are familiar with its contents. We have to relate the Hagadah to our
children in a way that will best impress upon them the important message
that in contains. And we, the adults, have to appreciate the Hagadah
anew every year.
(adapted from Minhag Yisroel Torah)
R' Yehudah Prero
For questions, comments, and topic requests, please write to Rabbi Yehudah Prero.