Re: Blessing on Water
Fri, 14 Feb 1997 00:06:27 -0500 (EST)

On Fri, 31 Jan 1997, Mark Duman <> wrote the following:
"If one of the concepts behind reciting a brocho is to acknowledge that
Hashem is the source of all such good, why should the need to say this be
negated when we don't actually "need" the item."

I believe that the answer is that making a blessing over food is a Birkat
Nehenin, which means that it's a blessing made based on enjoyment. If one
does not derive enjoyment, one need not make such a blessing. (Of course
there are other types of blessings besides the Birkot Nehenin, to which the
rule of the derivation of pleasure does not necessarily apply.)

I hope this helps some!