Re: Women praying with a minyan

MARSHA B COHEN (MCOHEN02@servms.fiu.edu)
Fri, 25 Oct 1996 7:37:41 -0400 (EDT)

Following up on Tara Cazaubon's post the other day about whether or not there
is any merit to women praying with a minyan of 10 men or not, I'd like to
ask another question--directly related--in this regard. In my shul, as in
most orthodox shuls I have been in, the women seem to relate to the dovening
in one of two ways: a) they are totally uninvolved, and talk among themselves
or b) they are totally immersed in tefillah, doing the entire service at their
own pace. In both cases they are, in effect, ignoring the service taking
place downstairs in the men's section.

I happen to like to follow the service that the men are doing and join in
the singing. No one has ever reproached me for doing this. BUT what I do
seems so out of the ordinary that when I read Tara's question, I thought I
would send this follow-up question and ask whether it actually is. If it
turns out that what I am doing is, from some halachic perspectives, "wrong,"
then this makes Tara's question about why women should go to shul at all
even more poignant.

I don't remember whether Tara was talking about shabbat or not--I am. And
BTW, the women at my shul sit in an upstairs gallery, so there is no
pressing problem about Kol Isha because of the distance that I am sitting
from the men below.

Marsha Cohen
Miami, Florida