Charitable Belief 1
Frown, and you compromise the entire mitzvah.
We are taught to perform every mitzvah with concentration, with joy, and
with no foreign agenda other than responding to Hashem’s command. We
realize that we often come up short of that mark. We solace ourselves with
the very fundamental understanding that the performance of the mitzvah in
and of itself is crucially important. When our intensity and devotion
flag, we can assure ourselves that the bare mitzvah is still a precious
thing, and accomplishes much of its purpose in uplifting our soul.
Tzedakah, it seems, is the exception.
The Sefer HaChinuch 2 includes a
positive attitude in his very definition of the mitzvah: “to perform
tzedakah with joy and a good feeling.” A verse in our parshah warns about
tzedakah accompanied by grumbling and a jaundiced eye. “Do not let your
heart feel bad when you give him.” .3
This exhortation has halachic teeth. The Rambam 4 writes that one who give tzedakah while displaying a
disagreeable countenance loses the merit of his gift. Some go beyond that,
arguing that such a display puts one in violation of a full Torah
prohibition!5 (The Meor V’Shemesh finds
in this thought a solution to a different problem – the lack of any
berachah before the performance of the mitzvah of tzedakah. Since simchah
is crucial to the mitzvah, and most people simply do not give with all
that much enthusiasm, their mitzvah comes up short. Chazal did not
mandate a berachah for a mitzvah so often performed deficiently.
Why should a joyous attitude, as important as it is, rise to the level of
deal-breaker in regard to tzedakah – unlike any other mitzvah? (You will
get nowhere by arguing that tzedakah is somehow exceptional, and must be
performed in a near-perfect manner to “count.” It is clear in our
tradition that if one gives tzedakah for less than altruistic reasons, his
action indeed “counts,” so long as the recipient benefits from his gift.
An admixture of self-interest does not erase the mitzvah, even though it
detracts from the luster of the mitzvah. Why, does a less-than-joyous
attitude erase the mitzvah altogether, while a less-than-perfect purpose
While we take note of this anomaly about tzedakah, we might mention
another. Long ago, the navi Yeshaya told us that our national aspiration
of full redemption hinges directly on tzedakah. “Tziyon will be redeemed
through justice, and her returnees through tzedakah.” 6 In what sense is tzedakah also described as “the equal
of all mitzvos?” 7 Why does so much
depend upon tzedakah?
All indications point to a single, elegant solution to the problems we
have raised. At its core, tzedakah is about emunah. At the Mishnah in
Avos8expresses it, “Give Him from what
is His, for you and yours are His.” Rabbenu Yonah expands upon this. When
you give, you part with nothing that is yours – not your self, and not
your property. All belongs to Him; all that a Jew possesses belongs to
Hashem; we are at most custodians of His property. We enjoy no proprietary
interest in anything of this world. This realization is fundamental to the
way a Jew believes. He attributes nothing to his own powers, but sees G-d
as the immediate cause and proprietor of everything.
Emunah may well be the idée fixe animating all our mitzvos. “All your
mitzvos are emunah.”9 All mitzvos
revolve around emunah; some, however, deal essentially with emunah. It is
easy to see that Shabbos is primarily an expression of emunah. It is in
this sense – as a pillar of emunah – that Shabbos is described as the
equal of all other mitzvos. This same reasoning applies to tzedakah, and
why it as well is seen as some kind of super-mitzvah.
Toldos Yaakov Yosef, further illuminates the Mishnah in Avos with a
vignette about a person who was never observed to worry. Questioned about
the reason for his equanimity, he responded that he literally had nothing
to worry about, because he had nothing! He possessed nothing; he related
to nothing in his life as his own. He therefore had nothing of himself
invested in any of items in his universe; he found nothing to worry him.
Everything belonged to Hashem, Who could do all the worrying for him.
The Toldos Yaakov Yosef also cites Sefer Chasidim to explicate a
phrase in Tehilim. 10“Chesed is Yours,
Hashem, because You reward a person according to his deeds.” It would seem
that justice, not chesed, should be His for rewarding each person as He
promised. The pasuk points out to us, however, that the element of chesed
is even more pronounced than din when we are rewarded for our choices. We
must keep in mind that when we bind tefillin upon ourselves in the
morning, it is HKBH who gave us the tefillin; it is HKBH who gave us the
arm upon which to place the tefillin; it is HKBH who gave us the thought
process and the will to put on the tefillin. How can we claim any reward
for what is entirely His doing? Indeed, Hashem’s chesed is underscored by
His generosity with us in rewarding us for our deeds as if they were
entirely of our own doing.
Tzedakah-as-emunah solves our original problems. Giving dejectedly
with regret does not merely detract from the quality of tzedakah, as it
would from any other mitzvah. It is an essential contradiction to the
emunah that all comes from Him, and there is nothing to be dejected about
in parting with money that one does not really own. (Giving for an
ulterior motive does detract from the quality of tzedakah, but in fact
does not negate it.) “Were a person to give all the treasure of his house
in love, they would scorn him.” 11 Why
scorn a person’s sacrifice of all that he owns in his love for Hashem?
What better gift could there be? The Sabba Kadisha pointed to the culprit –
the words “his house.” A person who believes that he gives up what truly
belongs to him should indeed be met with scorn and derision.
Geulah depends on the opposite attitude. “Yisrael is redeemed only through
tzedakah.” 12 When our understanding of
tzedakah reaches completion, when we comprehend with perfect clarity that
all is His, we are perforce no longer in galus. This realization is the
redemption of Israel, in regard to both individual and community.
The permutation of the Divine Name associated with Elul13 is found in the concluding letters of the words of
tzedakah tihyeh lanu k i(nishmor la’asos es kol ha-mitzvah
sees this as commentary to the phrase in the verse immediately preceding
it, where mitzvos are described as existing “for our good, all the days.”
The tzedakah, he explains, lies in the fact that we are duty bound to
observe the mitzvos simply because Hashem asks it of us. Any reward He
gives us is purely tzedakah. Why then, asks the Ohr HaChaim, does the
phrase read, “and it will be tzedakah for us,” rather than “He does
tzedakah for us?”
Our approach provides an answer. In describing the inner logic of the
entire system of mitzvos, the Torah stipulates that all of our mitzvah
observance should be like the mitzvah of tzedakah! The core realization
behind tzedakah is Hashem’s absolute ownership of everything, including
ourselves. We should bring that same realization to ther performance of
all mitzvos, recognizing that we are beholden to Him for the very ability
to respond to His will.
The allusion to Elul in the first letters of the words ani le-dodi ve-
li is well known. Perhaps we can now deepen our appreciation of it.
avodah of the month of Elul lies primarily in our ability to negate
ourselves to His Being. The phrase might better be rendered ani le-
when I succeed in seeing myself and everything important to me as owing
completely and absolutely to my Beloved – then dodi li – then my
is close to me, rewarding me for my actions, even though I do not really
deserve to be rewarded for what He has every right to demand of me without
Or, when the quality of our emunah infuses the way we give tzedakah, HKBH
charitably shows that He believes in us.
1 Based on Nesivos Shalom, pgs. 97-99
2 Mitzvah 489
3 Devarim 15:10
4 Matnos Aniyim 10:4.
5 See Ramban, comments to Sefer HaMitzvos, Mitzvos Lo Sa’aseh,
#17. The Smag seems to take this position; see Shach Yoreh Deah 249:5 who
seems to try to harmonize the Smag with the Mechaber, although the latter
only cites the position of the Rambam
6 Yeshayahu 1:27
7 Bava Basra 9A
8 Avos 3:7
9 Tehilim 119:86
10 Tehilim 62:13
11 Shir HaShirim 8:7
12 See, in somewhat different form, Shabbos 139A and Medrash
Zuta, Shir HaShirim 1:15
13 Each month has a form of the four-letter Name of Hashem
associated with it. These forms are spelled out by the initial or final
letters of words within certain Torah verses. See Pardes Rimonim of the
Ramak, 21:14 (The gematria of the four-letter Name is 26; multiplying by
12 yields 312, which happens to be the gematria of chodesh. – B’nai
Yissoschor, Nisan 1:1)
14 And it will be tzedakah for us if we are careful to perform
this entire commandment. Devarim 6:25
15 Devarim 6:20
Text Copyright © 2008 by Rabbi Yitzchok Adlerstein and Torah.org