Everything New Under the Moon1
Hashem said to Moshe and Aharon in the land of Egypt, saying: This month
shall be for you the beginning of the months; it shall be for you the first
of the months of the year.
The calendar described in this section, the first mitzvah given to the
people about to become a nation, is a study in engineered inefficiency. And
so it was meant to be. Efficiency, in the Torah’s view, pales in comparison
to the value of important instruction. In this case, the inefficiency of the
calendar tells us volumes about human free will.
Calendars, we would think, ought to be linked to astronomical events that
are known and predictable. We see great advantage in a calendar that would
allow all people, in all places, to know in advance when the important
events of the year will take place, so that they could plan accordingly,
long in advance.
Such a calendar, however, would leave in place an impression that the Torah
insists on overturning. Were our holidays linked to fixed astronomical
events, we might conclude, as so many others did, that all of us – Man, G-d,
and the way we relate to each other – are equally fixed and constrained.
If Rosh Chodesh were determined by the time of the earth receiving
the first rays of sunlight reflected by the lunar mirror, we would be
worshiping the dutiful periodicity of Nature. The Torah wants us to do
nothing of the sort. We are not worshippers of Nature. It is not Nature and
its regular ways that we celebrate each month. The waxing and the waning of
the moon mean nothing to us, other than to act as symbols of the
vicissitudes of life. We are required to pass through times of darkness and
obscurity – but they will always be followed by glimpses of illumination.
The moon and its phases are no more than a model to us, challenging and
prodding us to rejuvenate ourselves periodically, to renew out dedication to
Him after a lapse of time in which the relationship may have become dulled.
It is not the astronomical חדש – the first appearance of the new moon – that
has us count the days till the מועד – the special days of encounter. Rather,
it is the חידוש, the newness, that takes place within ourselves that allows
us to spend time with G-d on the special days of the year. Because we can
change and move towards Him, we experience something powerful when He makes
Himself available to us. Without that change, we would just be commemorating
the past, but is would not be a מועד, a meeting and encounter.
In other words, Rosh Chodesh is not determined so much by the moon as
by the way it is noticed and perceived by us. Our calculation of the
astronomical event does not fix the day of Rosh Chodesh. In the
system that the Torah here describes, human beings must visually note the
appearance of the moon. Their testimony has to be accepted by the court,
which then formally proclaims the day as Rosh Chodesh.
(Interestingly, this is only a requirement when the moon is cited by the
witnesses on the day that it is expected to be seen by calculation, but not
if the that day has already passed. It is only when the astronomical event
coincides with the visual sighting that it is important to downplay the role
of “natural” law, and treat it as unworthy of veneration in its own right.)
It is Man that declares the New Moon – not the moon itself!
Halacha dictates that the visual sighting predominates over the
“actual” occurrence in other ways as well. The court can artificially tamper
with the calendar and delay Rosh Chodesh for human convenience. In
this way, they can prevent Yom Kippur from falling on the day before
or after Shabbos, which would be a hardship. It is thus the human
court that determines when the Heavenly one will meet in judgment of the
people! The declaration of the court has finality, even when it is later
learned that the testimony of the witnesses was inaccurate, whether by error
or intentionally. In all these cases, human need trumps natural “fact.” The
occurrences of holidays that count from the beginning of the month depend
entirely on human input. They are fixed by us, and recognized by Heaven only
after our declaration.
How foolish it is to cheer the establishment of the fixed calendar that we
rely upon today as if it were a monumental achievement, an improvement upon
the “primitive” method of the past. Our calendar is a sad concession to the
realities of galus, of not having a court populated by judges with
real semicha. Gone – until the restoration of the old system when the
Redemption draws near – is our consciousness of being the ones who control
time, rather than time controlling us.
One vestige of the old system remains enshrined in the fixed calendar, to
remind us of what the calendar was supposed to be. When the moon was still
sighted visually, distant communities often did not receive word of the
decision of the High Court until a holy day was upon them. Not knowing when
the festival was to begin, they had to observe two days, to remove any
doubt. When the court of Hillel II gave us our fixed calendar, they sent a
plea to the outlying communities not to abandon the old practice of
observing two days, even though they would technically be able to follow the
fixed system. The second day of Yom Tov, observed despite our
knowledge of the “real” day of Yom Tov, serves as a constant
reminder of the older, truer form of living the Jewish calendar. It is only
this second day – disparaged by so many as a useless appendage from the past
– that keeps alive the authentic character of the first day of Yom Tov!
According to Chazal, the musaf of Rosh Chodesh serves
to atone for the unconscious violation of the taharah of the
Mikdash and its holy articles. This is no small detail in the complex
laws of the beis hamikdosh, but a truism about Jewish life in
general. Unconscious contamination of the mikdosh stems from drifting
so distant in the course of time from a focus on holiness and holy ideas,
that we lose some of the reverence we ought to have for them. Inevitably, we
then mistreat and profane the holy.
Left to our selves, the slow drifting would continue to the point that we
would become – like Paroh – so coarse and unresponsive to Divine
illumination that our hearts would remain hardened and resistant even in the
presence of wondrous signs. It is precisely this drifting away that Rosh
Chodesh addresses and cures. Once a month, we remind ourselves to look
for the light and warmth of His spirit. In it, we are refreshed and renewed!
Within this monthly renewal is a strong repudiation of the fundamentals of
paganism. In that universe, there is no renewal and no change – not in Man,
not in the world, not in the ways of the gods. What is, needs to be. Every
tomorrow follows inexorably from today. Everything new was already present
within the old. There is no creation, no something coming into being out of
Just as there is no creation in the physical universe in the mind of the
pagan, there is none in the moral one. From evil will flow only evil.
Everything is fixed, determined. Egypt in particular was mired in this
paganism. The perceived fixity of the universe reached into its social
structure, producing fixed and immutable ranks and castes.
Precisely into this world view, “in the land of Egypt,” Hashem showed Moshe
the sliver of the new moon, and told him that it would serve as a model of a
different order, a different view of life itself.
 Based on the Hirsch Chumash, Shemos 12:1-2