Getting Directed 1
Getting firmly oriented in the parshios of the Mishkan can be
fairly…disorienting. Without devoting attention to details of the Torah’s
expressions, we have no chance of rescuing our parshios from our feelings of
frustration and inadequacy. What are we to make of a prolonged and repeated
succession of construction numbers and details? We recognize that if it is
Torah, we are looking at a treasure trove of meaning and profundity – and
yet its intended impact evades us.
If we want to understand the details of the Mishkan, we have to carefully
scrutinize and account for the details of their description in the Torah.
Two verb-forms are used throughout the parshios of both the building of the
Mishkan and the avodah: terumah and tenufah. Both concern directing
something to a different direction or place. If we try to be more precise
we realize that terumah (literally, raising up) directs in an upward
direction, while tenufah (literally, waving) directs laterally, from one
side to another. We first react to them as if they were interchangeable,
until we detect a pattern that begs for explanation.
To begin with, they sometimes turn up in the same place at the same time.
Some korbanos require that the kohen moving about of specified parts of the
animal. Halachically, both terumah and tenufah are included in the avodah
of both the chazeh (chest) and the shok (thigh). Each is waved both up and
laterally. Yet the Torah speaks of the chazeh ha-tenufah (the waved chest)
and the shok ha-terumah) the lifted up thigh. Surely this is significant!
In our parsha, the Torah couples silver and nechoshes  with terumah –
“terumas kesef u-nechoshes .” Yet further along, the Torah switches to
tenufah – “zahav he-tenufah; nechoshes ha-tenufah .”
Unless we are mistaken, this is all very deliberate and precise. The two
words describe two different tasks that Hashem assigned to us in using His
Some things stand ready to be used for a Divine purpose. Eyes trained to
look for advancing Hashem’s agenda easily see how some things stand ready to
be utilized. Their orientation towards furthering Hashem’s plans is fully
part of their makeup. All we need do is direct them to the proper place, to
deliver them to where they can be best used. This is symbolized by tenufah,
by simply moving in a different direction, but within the same plane. They
are simply moved to the best position, like a missing piece in a puzzle.
Other things, however, require an extra step. Potentially, they can also be
put to good use in moving the world to a better state. Before they can
assume such a role, however, they must become something different, something
higher. When a person takes one of these items and presses it into Divine
service, he must elevate it to a different purpose from that which it would
ordinarily seem most suited. This elevation is what stands behind the
concept of terumah, raising up.
We can see this readily in regard to the avodah of the shelamim. The
diaphragm roughly divides a person between upper and lower regions. The
animal selected as a korban stands as a symbolic surrogate for the people
who offer it. The thigh is one of the organs of locomotion, of pedestrian
bodily function. In sharp contrast, the chest represents the upper, or
higher aspects of life, starting with the feelings and emotions associated
in our speech with the heart, and the even higher forms associated with
thought. Together, they suggest spiritual capabilities. Nothing is more
intuitive or natural for the serious eved Hashem than to apply these
capabilities to His service. Our job is simply to move them, to do tenufah,
to the right place. Their orientation towards this purpose is essential and
organic. They move – but in the same plane that they began.
Other parts of our being do not seem to belong to the world of the spiritual
at all. By nature, they are part of a different universe of values, of
things physical and material. They are symbolized by the shok, the thigh.
The eved Hashem will look for ways to use them in the service of Hashem, and
he will find them – but he will first have to elevate them. Terumah,
elevation, is justly coupled with the shok.
The same symbolic framework applies to the metals used in the Mishkan.
Metals have a number of properties that make them useful. They are
malleable. Whether through heat or hammering, metals can be forced to take a
specific shape. Once formed this way, metals retain that shape – including
some that display enormous structural stability and rigidity.
Additionally, many metals are commonly found associated with various
impurities. To make good use of them requires a many-faceted labor of
Taken all together, the metals occupy points on a symbolic continuum. At one
end stands gold, already purified and refined. It is the king of the metals,
a substance of beauty that can be beaten, twisted and shaped, after which it
will hold that shape. The Torah speaks, therefore, of zahav ha-tenufah, of
gold that needs only be moved into the proper position to maximize kevod
At the other end of the continuum is nechoshes. Relative to the luster of
gold, nechoshes seems to lack any refinement at all. Silver stands between
the extremes, suggesting something in which purification has begun but
requires still more refinement. Both nechoshes and kesef are appropriately
joined to terumah, because they require elevation before they can do the
best they are capable of.
One pasuk poses a serious challenge to this treatment. It speaks of
nechoshes ha-tenufah . Why would nechoshes, on the lowest rung of
purity, be associated with tenufah, as if already waiting and able to play
an important role in Divine service?
The Torah calls attention to one of the most important themes and truths
about Judaism. Holiness is not detached and abstracted from the realm of
the ordinary. It resides comfortably within the everyday materials and
events of life. The altar must stand directly on the ground, with no
intervention. When Bnei Yisrael first entered the Land, they set up an altar
not on the plush, verdant slopes of Har Gerizim, but on the desolate face of
neighboring Har Eival. The Torah suggests by this that all things of this
world, even the least obvious and attractive, can and must be used in G-d’s
service. To be sure, we have to first change and elevate many things, and
many forces within us. Yet this terumah, this refinement, is in the end
nothing more but the natural orienting of everything towards Hashem.
The terumah of the lowest order of things, of nechoshes, is in the final
analysis nothing more than its real tenufah.
1. Based on the Hirsch Chumash, Shemos 35:22
2. Depending on the commentator, some metal of lesser worth like copper,
bronze, or some alloy
3. Shemos 35:24
4. Shemos 38:24, 29
5. Shemos 38:29