Hamaayan / The Torah Spring
Edited by Shlomo Katz
Contributing Editor: Daniel Dadusc
Volume XIV, No. 47
2 Elul 5760
September 2, 2000
Rosh Hashanah 2:5-6
Orach Chaim 318:6-8
Daf Yomi (Bavli): Nedarim 45
Daf Yomi (Yerushalmi): Bava Kamma 2
At the beginning of the month of Elul, R' Chaim Halberstam of
Sanz z"l (see page 4) would often relate the following parable to
A prince once sinned against his father the king, and was
exiled from the palace. The prince began to wander, and, at
first, he was shown great honor as befits royalty. However, as
he went farther and farther from the palace, people no longer
recognized him or paid any attention to him.
Eventually, the prince found himself on the verge of
starvation, and he took a job as a shepherd. The job was easy
and his needs were simple. However, the prince found that he was
unable to construct a lean-to such as shepherds typically used to
protect themselves from the rain.
One day, the prince heard that the king (his father) would be
traveling through this distant province, and that anyone who had
a request could toss a note into the king's carriage. The prince
wrote a note asking for help in constructing a lean-to, and he
threw it straight into the king's lap as the royal carriage
The king recognized his son's handwriting and was pained
greatly. Had the king's son fallen so far that all he could ask
for from his father was help in constructing a humble lean-to?
Had the prince forgotten the closeness that he once had to the
king, and had he given up hope of restoring that closeness?
"We, too," concluded R' Chaim, "have forgotten that we are the
King's children. When Hashem comes to hear our prayers during
these Days of Mercy leading to Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur come,
we forget to ask Him to restore our former closeness to Him, and
we instead focus on our relatively petty material needs." (Otzar
Chaim: Minhagei Sanz p. 267)
"Righteousness, righteousness shall you pursue, so that you
will live and possess the Land that Hashem, your G-d, gives
R' Shlomo Halberstam z"l (died Rosh Chodesh Av of this year;
see page 4) explained this verse in light of two Talmudic
First, the gemara (Bava Metzia 83a) relates that porters
working for the sage Rabbah Bar Bar Chanah carelessly broke a
barrel of his wine. Rabbah Bar Bar Chanah took the workers'
coats as compensation, and the workers called him to a din Torah
(a civil suit before a bet din). "Return the coats," the sage
"Is that the law?" asked Rabbah Bar Bar Chanah.
"Yes," said Rav, "for it is written (Mishlei 2:20), 'in order
that you may go in the way of the good'." [In other words,
although Rabbah Bar Bar Chanah was not obligated by _civil_ law
to return the coats, he was obligated by _moral_ law to be more
forgiving than the law required (see Rashi).]
After Rabbah Bar Bar Chanah returned the coats, the porters
complained, "We worked all day, and we were not paid."
"Pay them," Rav ordered.
"Is that the law?" asked Rabbah Bar Bar Chanah.
"Yes," said Rav, "for it is written (also in Mishlei 2:20),
'and keep the paths of the righteous'."
Another passage from Bava Metzia (30b) tells, "Rabbi Yochanan
said, 'Yerushalayim was destroyed only because people insisted on
enforcing their legal rights [without compassion]'."
Said R' Halberstam: From the first passage we learn that one's
obligation to act in a more forgiving manner than the law
requires may sometimes cause a person to pay double (just as
Rabbah Bar Bar Chanah had to absorb the loss of his wine _and_
pay the workers for their work). This is alluded to in the
words, "Righteousness, righteousness (even twice!) shall you
pursue." Only then, we learn from the second Talmudic passage,
"You will live and possess the Land that Hashem, your G-d, gives
you." However, if you do not act thus, then, G-d forbid,
Yerushalayim will be destroyed and you will not possess the Land.
(Quoted in Otzarei Tzaddikei U'geonei Ha'dorot p. 554)
"If a matter of judgment is hidden from you . . . You shall
come to the Kohanim, the Levi'im, and to the judge who will
be in those days; you shall inquire and they will tell you
the word of judgment." (17:8-9)
Asks R' Yechezkel of Shiniva z"l (died 1899; eldest son of R'
Chaim Halberstam; see page 4): why doesn't the verse say "you
shall inquire _of them_ and they will tell you the word of
judgment"? He answers:
Frequently, when someone comes to a sage to ask his advice, the
seemingly "small talk" that the sage engages in contains the
answer to the visitor's as yet unasked question. [R' Yechezkel
records that this happened when he went to seek his father-in-
law's advice on some matter. Similar stories were told by
visitors to the Chafetz Chaim.] The verse means: You shall
inquire _within_your_heart_ and you will realize that they have
already told you the word of judgment. You may not have to ask!
Thirty Days before the Shemittah
[This coming year, 5761, is a shemittah / sabbatical year, and,
from time-to-time, we will be presenting articles dealing with
the laws and concepts of the shemittah. As with any halachic
issue discussed in Hamaayan, our goal is to familiarize the
reader with issues, not to give practical halachic advice. For
such advice, consult a competent rabbi.]
The prohibition on working the land of Eretz Yisrael during the
shemittah actually takes effect 30 days before the seventh year
begins. The Sages added to this, and prohibited certain tasks
beginning as early as Pesach of the sixth year.
However, the gemara (Moed Kattan 4a) teaches that all of the
above applies only when the Bet Hamikdash is standing. Today,
all agricultural work is permitted until Rosh Hashanah itself.
(Ha'aretz U'mitzvotehah p. 191)
R' Shlomo Halberstam z"l
(The "Bobover Rebbe")
Yesterday (Friday) marked 30 days since the passing of R'
Shlomo Halberstam, the "Bobover Rebbe." Born in Bobov, Galicia
on Rosh Chodesh Kislev 5668 / November 7, 1907, R' Halberstam was
a descendant of R' Chaim Halberstam (1793-1876; the famed "Sanzer
Rav"). His grandfather (R' Chaim's grandson; also named
R' Shlomo Halberstam) was the founder of the Bobover dynasty.
Our subject's father, R' Ben-Zion, led the Bobover chassidim
from 1905 until his murder near L'vov on 4 Av 5701 / 1941. Under
R' Ben-Zion's leadership, Bobov chassidut was almost alone among
chassidic groups in its focus on youth, and the network of 50(!)
yeshivot which R' Ben-Zion founded recaptured the hearts and
minds of thousands of youth who were left spiritually devastated
by the first World War.
R' Shlomo Halberstam first entered public life in 1931, when
his father left Bobov and moved to another town for five years.
(R' Ben-Zion had reached the age at which his father had died,
and he hoped that his self-imposed "exile" would change his
"mazal." As for his staying away for five years, see Rashi to
Bereishit 27:2.) At that time, the younger R' Halberstam was
appointed Rabbi of Bobov and Rosh Yeshiva of its yeshiva.
(Because of his years as the town's rabbi, R' Halberstam was
referred to by his chassidim as the "Bobover Ruv.")
In addition to his father, R' Shlomo lost his wife and two
children in the Holocaust. The story of his wanderings with his
eldest son, R' Naftali Zvi (born 1931; the new Bobover Rebbe),
and their miraculous survival is told in the book Nor the Moon by
Night by Devora Gliksman [Feldheim 1997]. In 1984, R' Halberstam
authored a kinnah / lamentation over the Holocaust, and he later
said (as recorded in the Artscroll Tishah B'Av Service p. 384):
For years, I had wanted to express my grief over my
personal loss and Klal Yisrael's [the Jewish People's]
loss, but I hesitated. I felt that in order to compose a
kinnah one must be on the exalted level of [the legendary
liturgist] R' Elazar Hakalir, who wrote with Ruach
Hakodesh [Divine inspiration]. Moreover, he was a master
of kabbalistic secrets and knew the mystical incantations
of the ministering angels. Still, many chassidim
requested a vehicle to convey their personal sorrow on
this bitter day [i.e., Tishah B'Av], but I held back,
because I felt genuinely unworthy.
Then one day, I was studying the laws of Tishah B'Av in
the book Seder Hayom, where the author writes:
Whoever can wail on this day should wail, and whoever
can recite kinnot should recite kinnot - either those
already recorded in the holy books or the kinnot he
himself composed with the intellect G-d has granted him.
It is a mitzvah for each and every individual to compose
kinnot for weeping and moaning, and to recite them on
this bitter day. One who does this is considered most
righteous, and he is worthy of being described as one of
Yerushalayim's mourners and one of her holy people.
Following the war, R' Halberstam first lived in Bari, Italy,
where a small contingent of chassidim began to regroup around
him. He eventually settled on the West Side of Manhattan, then
in Crown Heights, and, after 1967, in Boro Park. Tens of
thousands of chassidim gathered around him, and large Bobover
communities formed as well in London, Antwerp, Yerushalayim, Bat
Yam (south of Tel Aviv) and Toronto. R' Halberstam's concern for
his chassidim is illustrated by a story that his family heard
repeatedly during shivah from widowed women who used to come to
R' Halberstam for his advice and blessings. At the conclusion of
interviews with such women, R' Halberstam would call a car
service for them and would personally walk them out to the car.
Later, he would call the women to be sure they had arrived home
R' Halberstam was recognized as a profound Torah scholar; the
Steipler Gaon said of him, for example, "The Bobover Rebbe is
singular in this generation in his ability to explain pesukim and
midrashim." He was beloved even outside of Bobov because of his
warm personality and his avoidance of controversy. Regarding the
former, the story is told of a long-haired man who walked-in on
R' Halberstam's tisch, marched up to the head table, extended his
hand, and announced, "Hi there, I'm Mike." R' Halberstam took
Mike's hand and responded, "I'm Shloimie! How are you?" As for
the latter trait, it was not lost on R' Halberstam's chassidim
and those who eulogized him that he died on the yahrzeit of
Aharon Hakohen, who is referred to in Avot (1:12) as "the lover
of peace and pursuer of peace." (Sources: Encyclopedia
Le'chachmei Galicia p. 539; Olat Shabbat Be'shabbato [Toronto],
Vol. XIII, Nos. 46 & 48; Dr. S. Meth)
Dr. and Mrs. Robert Klein
in memory of father
Dr. Ernst Shlomo Kaplowitz a"h
Copyright © 1998 by Shlomo Katz and Project Genesis, Inc.
The editors hope these brief 'snippets' will engender further studyand discussion of Torah topics ("lehagdil Torah u'leha'adirah"), andyour letters are appreciated. Web archives at Project Genesis start with 5758 (1997) and may be retrieved from the Hamaayan page.Text archives from 1990 through the presentmay be retrieved from http://www.acoast.com/~sehc/hamaayan/. Donationsto HaMaayan are tax-deductible.