Humanity in Speech
The disease of tzoraat, the description and cure of which occupies most of
the subject matter of these two parshiyot that we read this Shabat, is
closely linked in rabbinic thought and literature with the sin of speaking
lashon hara – slander and idle gossip. The connection between the sin of
lashon hara and the resultant punishment and consequence of tzoraat is not
immediately obvious. And, the fact that tzoraat is no longer clearly
definable or even present today further complicates this issue.
The sin of lashon hara unfortunately is still hale and hearty today but
apparently its consequences have become invisible to us. One of the many
explanations given as to the connection between lashon hara and tzoraat is
that lashon hara attempted to “kill” and defame a person in private and
secret – a discreet stab in the back tactic – so the punishment was a
public physical disfigurement able to be seen by all.
But disfigurement is disfigurement only in relation to the appearance of
the general population. If everyone is disfigured in a like manner, so to
speak everyone has tzoraat, then no one is really disfigured and the
punishment of tzoraat has lost its punch, its deterrent effect. Thus in
biblical times, when lashon hara was not yet very commonplace, tzoraat was
deemed a just punishment – a public exposure of the slanderer who “kills”
secretly. But in later times, when in the words of the Talmud, “everyone
is covered with the dust of lashon hara,” then tzoraat loses its effect.
For as I stated earlier, a society where everyone is disfigured is a
society where no one is deemed to be disfigured.
There is a further relationship between tzoraat and lashon hara. Speech,
the gift of verbal communication and intercourse, is a uniquely human
characteristic. The Targum Onkelos translates the phrase that God gave man
the breath of life as meaning that God gave man the gift of speech and
communication. There is nothing therefore more definitive of being a human
being than the ability to speak and talk to others.
There is nothing more dehumanizing than being horribly disfigured. All
sorts of prosthetic devices have been created to help people minimize their
disfigurement. Though our modern society has become more tolerant of people
suffering from disfigurement than was the society of our grandparents, we
all still feel that the disfigured person is less “human” than the rest of
society. Thus the gift of speech promotes the great concept of human
uniqueness while the punishment of tzoraat serves to minimize that person’s
humanity in the eyes of others.
Lashon hara – evil, gossipy speech – dehumanizes us all. It takes a holy
vessel, speech and communicative ability, and defiles it and turns it into
an instrument of harm and tragedy. Tzoraat came to remind us all of that
basic lesson of life. And even though tzoraat is not visible amongst us
today, our reading and studying of these two parshiyot of the Shabat serves
as a vehicle for us to think about and appreciate the gift of speech given
to humans and arrange our speech accordingly. We must wipe off the dust of
lashon hara from our bodies and minds.
Rabbi Berel Wein
Rabbi Berel Wein- Jewish historian, author and international lecturer offers a complete selection of CDs, audio tapes, video tapes, DVDs, and books on Jewish history at www.rabbiwein.com
Text Copyright © 2007 by Rabbi Berel Wein and Torah.org
Visit www.rabbiwein.com for a complete selection of Rabbi Wein's books and tapes.