Jewish Law in Society Today
Jewish civil law is a most complicated subject. The subjects that are most
discussed, argued over and analyzed in Talmudic and rabbinic literature
concern themselves with Jewish civil law – torts, contracts, evidence, real
estate, inheritance, civil procedure, etc.
Almost every Jewish child will cut his first tooth in Talmudic studies in
matters related to Jewish civil law. As important as observance and
knowledge of ritual is in Jewish life and continuity, it is the
understanding of Jewish civil law that forms the basic structure of the
value system and lifestyle of Judaism. Therefore there is a strong
admonition that Jews should not allow themselves to judge their civil
disputes in non-Jewish courts or on the basis of non-Jewish law and ordinances.
It is not the laws alone that may differ – it is the moral underpinning of
the legal decisions that are different. People are naturally very zealous
about protecting their property rights. But seen in isolation from a general
moral code of behavior and its important relationship to the welfare of the
society as a whole, the primacy of property rights alone can destroy a
nation and its society.
Jewish civil law is predicated on the idea that there must always be a
balance between the welfare of society generally and the property rights of
the individual personally. All of Jewish civil law and its attendant values
attempt to strike this balance in a fair and practical manner. This is the
skeleton of understanding that lies beneath the surface of all the detailed
decisions and opinions that form Jewish Talmudic and rabbinic legal decisions.
The Torah provides the necessary wiggle room to decide exceptional cases and
disputes on a more moral and correct basis than the strict interpretation of
the law itself would indicate. This concept is called “lifnim meshurat
hadin” – an almost extra-legal mechanism that goes “beyond the measure of
the law itself” and empowers the Jewish court to decide matters with
ultimate justice without being restricted by the pure letter of the law itself.
Naturally, such an extraordinary legal mechanism can only be used sparingly
and most wisely, for otherwise it presages the destruction of the entire
stability of the law and the legal system of Judaism itself. Nevertheless,
the existence of such a mechanism itself is testimony to the balance and
general considerations of society that are required in Jewish judicial
Therefore such difficult decisions regarding the right of governmental
eminent domain, the displacement of human workers by advancing new
technology and sophisticated money and investment schemes are all part of
the scope of Jewish law. Jewish law is equipped to deal with all possible
questions and problems of human society.
I think that is what Justice Minister Yaakov Neeman meant when he stated
that the basic principles of Israeli law should be based on the principles
of Jewish law as derived from the Torah, the Talmud and the millennia-long
challenges met by the rabbis of Israel to create a just legal system for the
Jewish people. This is inherent in the opening words of this week’s parsha:
“And these are the laws that you shall place before them” – these laws and
not other laws and legal systems.
Rabbi Berel Wein