Part 1 of 2
Devorah as Prophetess, Judge and Mother:
A Woman's Innate Ability to Inspire
The story of Devorah appears in The Book of Judges (4:1 - 5:31). Devorah
becomes Judge at a time when the Jewish nation is experiencing a spiritual
and moral ebb. This state of affairs is summarized in the Artscroll Tanach
introduction to the Book of Judges:
"With the death of Joshua, the Jewish nation entered a new era. No longer
was there a single national leader, a virtual king of the nation, as Moses
and Joshua had been. True, there were courts in every town and city, as
commanded by the Torah, so that there would be a system of justice, but there
was no formally constituted national leader... As the Book of Judges notes
all too sadly, "...In those days there was no king in Israel; every man did
what was proper in his own eyes" (17:6 & 21:25). There were episodes of
extreme sinfulness that caused God to remove His protective providence from
Israel, and foreign oppressors would exercise predatory control over parts of
the country. Nevertheless, the masses of the people never lost their faith
in God and their basic allegiance to Torah. God would choose a leader, known
as a judge, who would rally the people to repent and thus deserve God's help
once again. Then, generally, the judge would conquer and expel the oppressor
and the nation would enjoy a long period of tranquility - until it slid
downward again...In reading the Book of Judges, it is essential to note that
the combined years of peace and righteousness far outnumbered the years of
failure and persecution. Always, the Judge was chosen by God, and whenever
he or she called upon the people to repent, they responded. The nation had
shortcomings, but it was essentially righteous and true to the Torah and its
The above description suggests that a judge must be a capable leader/
commander-in-chief and must have a character that merits God's appointment.
Beyond meeting these criteria, Devorah as the only judge in Jewish history
apparently brings to the position something only a woman can provide.
Devorah's selection as judge raises a fundamental question. Given that Torah
law prohibits a woman from holding public office, why does God appoint her
the highest public official in the land?
Commentaries bring many explanations for God's choice of Devorah. One
opinion differentiates her as the only judge in Jewish history who is also a
prophet. As a prophetess/judge, Devorah does not formulate rulings in the
traditional manner, but is essentially a vehicle and spokeswoman for rulings
from Above. For this reason, she might be considered an exception to the
ruling that a judge be male.
Another commentary on Devorah's role as judge cites a prophet's prerogative
to make one-time changes in Jewish law, in order to rectify a problem. As a
prophetess, Devorah exercises this right by making an exception for herself
to the rule excluding women from public office. She does so not in order to
pave the way for future female judges, but in response to her assessment that
she, alone, is best equipped to respond to the needs of her generation.
Beyond Devorah's validity as a judge according to the explanations of the
above commentators and others, the question remains: why does God proceed
outside mainstream parameters of Torah in order to appoint a woman. Why does
He not make the more straightforward choice of a qualified man? (In this
regard, Pinchas, son of Elazar, remains a suitable candidate for judge in
this era, however, God chooses Devorah because 1)she has a particular merit,
to be discussed further and 2) as also discussed further, her feminine
character is appropriate for a leader of this particular generation.
Devorah, herself, states, "I arose as a mother to Israel" (Judges 5:7)).
Devorah's unique vitality radiates from the privacy of her own home (where it
transforms her husband), to the public domain where it re-inspires the Jewish
nation. Devorah's power to empower is the source of her effectiveness as
both public leader and wife.
Devorah is married to Lapidot (also referred to in the text as, "Barak") - a
man who is not knowledgeable about Torah. The Hebrew word Lapidot means,
"torches," which provides insight into the significant role of light in the
relationship between Devorah and her husband. Rashi observes that the Hebrew
description of Devorah as "wife of Lapidot" indicates she is "a woman who
makes wicks." Devorah does indeed fashion wicks. She sends them with her
husband to the Temple for use in its Menorah, the symbol of the light of
Torah, which is the essence of the Jewish nation. Because of his wife's
initiative, Lapidot is exposed to the holiness of the Temple and the people
in it, and he is inspired to get involved in making the wicks and to take
part in spreading the light of Torah among the Jewish people.
Central to Devorah's aspirations for her husband - and for the Jewish people
- is her hope that each Jew will find a deeper understanding of and
connection to life's purpose. Devorah's generation needs inspiration in this
regard, and God selects her to help them pursue it. As a leader, Devorah
motivates the Jews to take responsibility for their own internal
illumination. In the same subtle way that Devorah inspires her husband, she
moves the Jewish nation to re-embrace Torah.
The text of Judges (4:5) relates that Devorah prophesies and leads her nation
from her seated place under a date palm:
"...a prophetess, the wife of Lapidoth...She would sit under the date palm of
Devorah, between Ramah and Beth-el on Mount Ephraim, and the children of
Israel would go up to her for judgement."
The date palm is a metaphor for Devorah's generation. In the same way the
life giving sap of a date palm is limited to its trunk (whereas in other
trees it extends through the leaves), Devorah's generation has limited access
to the life force of Torah, because it has but a few Torah scholars. To
continue the metaphor, the date palm's minimal shade represents the relative
absence of spiritual and physical protection without Torah.
Inasmuch as the date palm exemplifies the shortcomings of the Jewish people
in Devorah's day, it is also a symbol of their strength. Specifically, the
concentration of sap in the date palm trunk typifies the Jews of Devorah's
era, who are said to be united towards God with one and the same heart. This
attribute seems to contradict their deficits. How can both extremes be true
of the same generation?
Devorah herself understands the reality behind this seeming contradiction.
As judge, she inherits a somewhat disconnected generation, with a potential
for spiritual greatness. She then empowers them with Torah knowledge, with
her own exemplary righteousness and - most significantly - by believing in
them. Devorah's faith in the Jewish people comes from what may be considered
her maternal love. In the same way parents want the best for their children,
Devorah holds such hopes for the Jews. And in the same manner a mother
understands how to foster a child's own sense of accomplishment and
self-esteem, Devorah inspires in the Jews a renewed sense of their value as
God's chosen people.
In sum, Devorah exhibits a woman's ability to instill rather than impose, to
invigorate rather than force, and to cultivate rather than command.
As judge, Devorah brings a feminine sensibility to a male dominated office.
She refers to herself as a "mother of Israel," and her commitment to
nurturing the Jews with subtlety and patience bespeaks this title. Devorah's
leadership style is profoundly generous - focused as it is on her populace,
rather than on herself. This style, together with her appreciation and
knowledge of Torah, and her prophetic gift, marks Devorah as an agent of
Contemporary society is only now beginning to recognize that in order to
succeed, a woman need not jettison her innate patience, insight and ability
to inspire. Indeed, these feminine assets may prove essential to her
accomplishment and personal fulfillment in life. Devorah embraces and
utilizes the full extent of a woman's power for positive change. As wife,
judge, prophetess and mother, or in the quintessentially male role of
commander-in-chief (as will be seen in part 2 of this essay), Devorah is
consistently, successfully and wholeheartedly a Jewish woman.
Women in Judaism, Copyright (c) 2002 by Mrs. Leah Kohn and Project Genesis, Inc.
MIKETZ AND CHANUKAH:
Those Small Jars
Rabbi Pinchas Winston - 5758
Chanukah: A Postscript
Rabbi Yehudah Prero - 5756
A Superficial Light
Rabbi Yochanan Zweig - 5772
Non Negotiable Part II
Rabbi Aron Tendler - 5765
The Ideal Answer, or the Answer of Ideals
Rabbi Dovid Green - 5759
A Higher Calling
Rabbi Mordechai Kamenetzky - 5759
The Real Story
Rabbi Yaakov Menken - 5763
Rabbi Yaakov Menken - 5760
Analyzing The Imagery of A Familiar Chanukah Poem
Rabbi Yissocher Frand - 5765
Behind the Gray Blur
Rabbi Naftali Reich - 5768
Lighting Up the Streets
Rabbi Eliyahu Hoffmann - 5760
Rabbi Osher Chaim Levene - 5766
Rabbi Yehudah Prero - 5766
Our Power is Found
Rabbi Label Lam - 5764
We Should Not Assume What Happens Is Necessarily 'Bad'
Rabbi Yissocher Frand - 5766
Of Endings and Beginnings
Rabbi Pinchas Winston - 5759